cumulative

I.6 A function-based approach to supervisee performance

What the task asks: Assess why a supervisee's performance falls short, using a function-based tool such as a performance diagnostic, and choose an intervention that addresses the cause the assessment identifies.

Personnel Supervision and Management5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

When a client engages in problem behavior, a behavior analyst does not pick an intervention at random. They assess the function first, then design a treatment that fits it. Supervisee performance deserves the same approach. A technician who skips data collection might lack the skill, not know it is expected, lack the materials, or face consequences that favor skipping it. Each cause calls for a different fix.

Performance diagnostics are assessments that identify the environmental variables behind a performance problem, so the intervention can target the cause. They come from organizational behavior management (OBM), the application of behavior analysis to performance in workplaces. Like a functional assessment for a client, a diagnostic saves time and prevents interventions that cannot work, such as retraining someone who already knows how to do the job.

Breaking it down

Skill deficit or performance deficit?

The first question is whether the supervisee can do the task.

  • A skill deficit means the person cannot perform the task correctly, even under ideal conditions. The fix is training.
  • A performance deficit means the person can perform the task but does not do it reliably on the job. The fix lies in the environment: antecedents, resources or consequences.

A quick test is to ask the supervisee to perform the task right now, with no time pressure, perhaps in role-play. If they do it correctly, more training is unlikely to help. A long-standing rule of thumb from Mager and Pipe asks whether the person could do the task if their life depended on it.

The Performance Diagnostic Checklist

Austin (2000) developed the Performance Diagnostic Checklist (PDC), an interview-based tool that sorts the possible causes of a performance problem into four areas:

AreaThe kind of question it asks
Antecedents and informationDoes the employee know exactly what is expected, and when?
Equipment and processesIs the needed equipment available and working, and is the process workable?
Knowledge and skillsCan the employee perform the task correctly?
ConsequencesDoes correct performance produce feedback or reinforcement, and does anything punish it?

The PDC for human services

Carr and colleagues (2013) adapted the tool for human-service settings such as ABA clinics, schools and group homes. The Performance Diagnostic Checklist-Human Services (PDC-HS) is completed through an interview with the employee’s supervisor, plus some direct observation. Its four domains are:

  1. Training: Has the employee been trained, and can they perform the task accurately and fluently?
  2. Task clarification and prompting: Does the employee know what is expected, and are there job aids or reminders?
  3. Resources, materials and processes: Are the needed materials, time and staffing available, and is the process efficient?
  4. Performance consequences, effort and competition: Is correct performance noticed and reinforced? Is the task high in effort? Do other tasks or contingencies compete with it?

The PDC-HS also suggests interventions for each domain. In early studies of the tool, the intervention it pointed to improved staff performance, while an intervention it did not point to (often more training) changed little.

Performs correctly when asked? Role-play, no time pressure No Yes Skill deficit Cannot do it Performance deficit Can do it, but not reliably on the job Task clarity Steps, prompts Resources Materials, process Consequences Feedback, effort Training BST to criterion Clarify tasks, add job aids Provide materials, cut effort Feedback, goals, reinforcement
The first question separates a skill deficit from a performance deficit. Only a skill deficit calls for training; a performance deficit sends you to the other PDC-HS domains and the fix each one points to.

Matching the intervention to the cause

Cause identifiedMatching intervention (see I.5)
Skill deficitBehavioral skills training to criterion
Unclear expectationsTask clarification, job aids and prompts
Missing materials or an awkward processProvide resources, simplify the process, reduce response effort
Weak or missing consequencesFeedback, goal setting and reinforcement
Competing contingenciesReduce reinforcement for the competing activity or adjust the workload

Often more than one cause applies. Address each, then measure whether performance improves (see I.7). The Ethics Code expects a behavior analyst who finds a performance problem to develop, communicate, carry out and evaluate an improvement plan (Standard 4.08, Performance Monitoring and Feedback).

Seeing it in practice

Technicians at an in-home program, including Ravi, often leave sessions without completing session notes. The supervisor’s first idea is a refresher training. The supervisor completes a PDC-HS instead.

  • Training: Ravi writes an accurate note when asked during supervision. This is not a skill deficit.
  • Task clarification and prompting: The deadline is clear and posted.
  • Resources, materials and processes: Notes require a laptop, and the agency issued laptops to only half the staff, so Ravi writes notes at home.
  • Consequences: Nobody looks at notes until a month-end audit, and late notes have no visible effect.

The diagnosis points to resources and consequences, not training. The supervisor sets up a note template on the agency phone (reducing effort) and starts weekly graphed feedback on note completion. A refresher training would have cost time and changed nothing.

0255075100BaselinePhone template and graphed feedback12345678910WeeksNotes on time (%)
Ravi's weekly note completion before and after the matched fix: a template on the agency phone plus weekly graphed feedback. Completion rises because the intervention targets resources and consequences.

Common mix-ups

  • “They need more training” is the most common wrong default. If the supervisee performs the skill correctly when asked, training is not the answer.
  • Performance diagnostics look at the environment, not character. Labels such as “lazy” or “unmotivated” describe the problem without explaining it.
  • The PDC and PDC-HS are not functional analyses. They are indirect, interview-based assessments with some observation. Nothing is experimentally manipulated.
  • Diagnosis is not the end. The matched intervention still has to be evaluated with data.

Exam tip: If a scenario says the supervisee performs the task correctly in role-play or when observed, the answer is almost never more training. Match the clue to the domain: missing materials point to resources, unstated steps to task clarification, and absent feedback or a more attractive activity to consequences and competition.

Quick recap

  • Assess why performance falls short before choosing an intervention.
  • A skill deficit (cannot do it) calls for training; a performance deficit (can but does not) calls for changing the environment.
  • PDC areas: antecedents and information, equipment and processes, knowledge and skills, consequences.
  • PDC-HS domains: training; task clarification and prompting; resources, materials and processes; performance consequences, effort and competition.
  • Match the intervention to the cause, then measure the result.

Further reading

  • Austin, J. (2000). Performance analysis and performance diagnostics. In J. Austin & J. E. Carr (Eds.), Handbook of applied behavior analysis. Context Press.
  • Carr, J. E., Wilder, D. A., Majdalany, L., Mathisen, D., & Strain, L. A. (2013). An assessment-based solution to a human-service employee performance problem: An initial evaluation of the Performance Diagnostic Checklist-Human Services. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 6(1), 16-32.

Key terms

Performance diagnostics
Assessments that identify the environmental variables responsible for a performance problem at work, such as unclear expectations, missing resources, skill gaps or weak consequences, so the intervention can target the cause.
Performance Diagnostic Checklist (PDC)
An interview-based performance diagnostic developed by Austin (2000). It sorts the possible causes of an employee performance problem into four areas: antecedents and information, equipment and processes, knowledge and skills, and consequences.
Performance Diagnostic Checklist-Human Services (PDC-HS)
An adaptation of the Performance Diagnostic Checklist for human-service settings (Carr et al., 2013). It is completed through an interview with the employee's supervisor plus some direct observation, and it covers four domains: training; task clarification and prompting; resources, materials and processes; and performance consequences, effort and competition.
Skill deficit
A performance problem that occurs because the person cannot perform the task correctly, even under ideal conditions. It calls for training, such as behavioral skills training.
Performance deficit
A performance problem in which the person can perform the task correctly but does not do it reliably on the job. It points to antecedents, resources or consequences in the work environment rather than to a need for more training.
Organizational behavior management (OBM)
The application of behavior analysis to improving the performance of individuals and groups in organizations. It includes performance management, performance diagnostics, behavioral safety and the analysis of organizational systems.

Check yourself

5 questions on I.6. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A technician, Sofia, rarely uses the token system during sessions. When her supervisor asks her to demonstrate it in role-play, she performs every step correctly. What does this suggest?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Sofia can perform the skill under ideal conditions, so the problem lies in the work environment, not in her repertoire. More training would teach a skill she already has. Calling it a motivation problem labels the issue without identifying the variables a supervisor can change.

  2. Question 2A PDC-HS shows that technicians know how to sanitize materials, but the sanitizing supplies are often missing from therapy rooms. Which intervention best matches this finding?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The finding falls in the resources, materials and processes domain, so the fix is to make the materials available. Retraining addresses a skill deficit that the assessment ruled out. Reminders and praise target other domains and cannot work while the supplies are missing.

  3. Question 3A PDC-HS interview shows that Malik, a new technician, can do the end-of-session cleanup correctly, but nobody told him it was part of his job and there is no checklist for it. Which domain does this finding point to?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Malik can do the task, so training is not the issue, and nothing suggests missing materials. The gap is that the expectation was never stated and nothing prompts it, which is the task clarification and prompting domain. A clear checklist would be the matched intervention.

  4. Question 4A supervisor's team keeps missing the deadline for quarterly progress reports. Before choosing an intervention, what should the supervisor do first?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A function-based approach assesses why a problem occurs before selecting a fix, just as a functional assessment comes before a behavior plan. Training, penalties or goals might each turn out to be right, but only if the assessment points to them. Picking one first risks an intervention that does not match the cause.

  5. Question 5Technicians know how to graph session data and have the tools to do it, but they skip graphing on days when parents arrive early and chat with them, which both parents and technicians enjoy. What is most likely responsible?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The technicians have the skills and the tools, and graphing is skipped exactly when a more reinforcing activity is available. The PDC-HS calls this competition and places it in the performance consequences, effort and competition domain. The fix is to rearrange time or consequences, not to retrain.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.