cumulative

I.2 Building effective supervisory relationships

What the task asks: Recognize and use the practices that set up a productive relationship between supervisor and supervisee, including a written contract, explicit expectations, rapport and feedback that flows in both directions.

Personnel Supervision and Management5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Supervision works through a relationship. A supervisee who trusts the supervisor will ask for help, admit mistakes and try new skills in front of them. A supervisee who is confused about expectations, or wary of the supervisor, will hide problems until they reach the client.

Good relationships do not depend on luck or personality. They are built with specific supervisor behaviors: putting roles and expectations in writing, investing in rapport early, delivering feedback well and asking for feedback in return. Sellers, Valentino and LeBlanc (2016) list setting up an effective relationship among their first recommendations for individual supervision, ahead of the teaching itself.

Breaking it down

The supervision contract

A supervision contract is a written agreement that sets the terms of supervision before it begins. Typical contents:

  • The roles and responsibilities of each party
  • Schedule, frequency and modality (in person, video, individual or group), and how cancellations are handled
  • What will be taught and how performance will be evaluated
  • How and when feedback will be given
  • Documentation and confidentiality
  • How disagreements will be resolved, and the conditions for ending supervision

For trainees accruing fieldwork, certification rules require a signed contract before hours count. Beyond compliance, the contract prevents the most common relationship problem: two people working from different assumptions. The Ethics Code asks behavior analysts to define their professional role in writing (Standard 1.04, Practicing within a Defined Role), to follow every applicable supervision requirement (Standard 4.01, Compliance with Supervision Requirements), and to plan any ending of supervision so it does as little harm to the supervisee as possible (Standard 4.12, Appropriately Terminating Supervision). Revisit the contract when circumstances change.

Clear expectations

“Be professional” is not an expectation anyone can meet reliably. “Arrive five minutes early, have materials set up and submit session notes within 24 hours” is. State expectations in observable terms, and state them in both directions. The supervisee should also know what the supervisor will provide: how quickly messages are answered, when observations happen and how feedback will be delivered. Review expectations at the first meeting, and refer back to them when problems arise, so feedback is tied to agreed standards rather than to the supervisor’s mood.

Rapport

Rapport is a working relationship in which the supervisor’s presence and feedback have become reinforcing rather than aversive. Supervisors build it by learning about the supervisee’s goals, keeping commitments, praising often and specifically, admitting their own mistakes and pairing themselves with good things before they correct. Rapport is not friendship. It stays inside professional boundaries and avoids multiple relationships (see E.7).

Giving feedback

Performance feedback is information about past performance that helps someone improve future performance. It works best when it is:

  • Specific: it names the exact behavior (“You delivered the token within two seconds on every trial”).
  • Timely: it comes soon after the performance, especially for new skills.
  • Balanced: it includes frequent praise for what went well, plus clear correction.
  • Actionable: it says what to do next time, ideally with a model and a chance to practice.
  • Private for corrections, unless the supervisee prefers otherwise.

Receiving feedback

Accepting feedback is a skill, and supervisors can teach it like any other: listen without interrupting, ask clarifying questions, summarize the feedback, thank the person and apply it. Supervisors should model it too. Bidirectional feedback means the supervisor regularly asks how supervision is going and acts on the answers. Because the supervisor controls hours, references and sometimes employment, many supervisees will not volunteer criticism. Ask directly, offer anonymous options and respond without defensiveness (see I.3 on power differentials).

Supervisor Supervisee Performance feedback Specific, timely, balanced, actionable Feedback on supervision Asked for at set points, with anonymous options Agreed in writing first: roles, expectations, schedule, how feedback works
Feedback runs in both directions. The supervisor gives specific, timely feedback; the supervisee is asked for feedback on supervision at set points, and both rest on terms agreed in writing first.

Seeing it in practice

ProblemLikely causeRelationship strategy
A trainee often arrives without materials“Be prepared” was never definedWrite the expectation in observable terms and review it together
A supervisee argues with every correctionReceiving feedback was never taught, and rapport is thinTeach a receiving-feedback routine and increase specific praise
At the final meeting, the supervisor learns the trainee wanted more caregiver-training experienceNo channel for the supervisee’s feedbackAsk for feedback at set points and use a short anonymous survey
Supervision meetings keep getting cancelledNo agreed cancellation policyAdd cancellation and make-up terms to the contract

Common mix-ups

  • The contract is not a formality. It is the first antecedent intervention in the relationship. Expectations that are never written down tend to be remembered differently by each person.
  • Rapport does not mean avoiding correction. A supervisor who withholds corrective feedback to stay liked leaves clients exposed to errors.
  • Feedback is not only criticism. Praise for correct performance is feedback too, and most supervisees need far more of it than they get.
  • Feedback runs both ways. A supervisor who never asks how supervision is going cannot improve it (see I.7).

Exam tip: If a scenario describes friction or confusion early in supervision, look for the answer that clarifies expectations in writing or builds rapport before an answer that adds consequences.

Quick recap

  • Set up the relationship before the teaching: contract, expectations and rapport.
  • The supervision contract covers roles, schedule, evaluation, feedback, documentation and ending supervision.
  • Write expectations in observable terms, for both parties.
  • Effective feedback is specific, timely, balanced and actionable.
  • Receiving feedback is a teachable skill, and supervisors should seek feedback too.

Further reading

  • Sellers, T. P., Valentino, A. L., & LeBlanc, L. A. (2016). Recommended practices for individual supervision of aspiring behavior analysts. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9(4), 274-286.
  • Sellers, T. P., LeBlanc, L. A., & Valentino, A. L. (2016). Recommendations for detecting and addressing barriers to successful supervision. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9(4), 309-319.
  • LeBlanc, L. A., Sellers, T. P., & Ala’i, S. (2020). Building and sustaining meaningful and effective relationships as a supervisor and mentor. Sloan Publishing.

Key terms

Supervision contract (Supervisor-supervisee contract)
A written, signed agreement made before supervision begins. It defines each party's roles and responsibilities, the schedule and modality of supervision, how performance will be evaluated and feedback given, documentation requirements, how concerns will be resolved and the conditions for ending supervision.
Rapport
A working relationship in which one person's presence, attention and feedback have become reinforcing rather than aversive to the other. In supervision it is built by keeping commitments, giving frequent specific praise and showing interest in the supervisee's goals, all within professional boundaries.
Performance feedback (Feedback)
Information given to a person about their past performance so they can maintain or improve it. It can be verbal, written or graphic, immediate or delayed, and can include praise, correction or both. It works best when it is specific and combined with goals or reinforcement.
Bidirectional feedback
Feedback that flows both ways in a supervisory relationship. The supervisor gives feedback on the supervisee's performance and also asks for, accepts and acts on the supervisee's feedback about the supervision.
Supervisee
Anyone whose delivery of behavioral services is overseen by a behavior analyst within an agreed supervisory relationship, such as a behavior technician, an assistant behavior analyst or another behavior analyst. A trainee is a supervisee who is also accruing fieldwork toward certification.

Check yourself

5 questions on I.2. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Before Marcus begins accruing fieldwork hours, his new supervisor suggests they 'just get started and sort out the details as they come up.' What should happen first?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. A signed contract comes before supervision starts, and certification rules require one before fieldwork hours count. Putting terms in writing only at the end defeats the purpose, which is to prevent misunderstandings from the first day. Observing his skills is part of supervision once the terms are set.

  2. Question 2A supervisor tells a trainee, 'You need to be more engaged with your clients.' A week later nothing has changed. What is the most likely problem?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. 'More engaged' does not tell the trainee what to do differently. Restating it as observable behavior, such as delivering praise at least once a minute and joining the client's play, gives a clear target. Blaming motivation skips the simpler explanation that the expectation was never clear.

  3. Question 3Which supervisor action best demonstrates bidirectional feedback?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Bidirectional feedback means feedback also flows from supervisee to supervisor, and the supervisor uses it to adjust. Mixing praise and correction is good practice, but that feedback still flows only one way. Self-ratings concern the supervisee's own performance, not the quality of the supervision.

  4. Question 4When Dana's supervisor gives corrective feedback, Dana interrupts to explain why the error happened and rarely changes the behavior afterward. What is the best next step for the supervisor?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Receiving feedback is a skill that can be taught with instructions, modeling, rehearsal and feedback: listen, ask questions, summarize, thank and apply. Withholding correction protects comfort at the client's expense. Ending supervision is far too early a step for a skill that has not yet been taught.

  5. Question 5A new supervisor wants to build rapport with a technician who seems nervous during observations. Which plan fits best?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Rapport grows when the supervisor's presence is paired with reinforcement and the supervisor proves reliable. Social contact outside work risks a multiple relationship (Standard 1.11, Multiple Relationships). Skipping observations removes the very contact that lets the supervisor become a positive presence.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.