The big idea
Radical behaviorism is B. F. Skinner’s philosophy of the science of behavior. It treats everything a person does as behavior, including thinking and feeling, and explains behavior by its relations to the environment: the species’ evolutionary history, the person’s learning history and their current circumstances.
Radical here means thoroughgoing or to the root, not extreme. Radical behaviorism is thoroughgoing because it leaves nothing out. Thoughts and feelings are part of the subject matter, not excluded from it and not used as explanations of last resort.
For practitioners this has a direct payoff. If “anxiety” or “low motivation” is treated as the cause of a behavior, the analysis stops there. If they are treated as behavior with environmental causes of their own, there is something to assess and change.
Breaking it down
Explaining behavior means finding environment-behavior relations
To explain a behavior is to identify the variables it is a function of. Those variables lie in natural selection (phylogeny), the person’s history of reinforcement and punishment (ontogeny), and the practices of their culture (see selectionism in A.2). Current antecedents, motivating operations and consequences complete the picture.
Private events are behavior
Private events are events inside the skin that only the person can observe directly: thinking, imagining, feeling pain, talking silently to yourself. Radical behaviorism treats them as behavior, or as bodily conditions a person responds to, governed by the same principles as public behavior. The only difference is that one person has access to them.
Two points follow:
- Private events have environmental histories. We learn to describe our own feelings because a verbal community taught us, by responding to statements like “my stomach hurts” when public signs went with them (Skinner, 1945).
- Private events can play a part in a chain of behavior (a thought can be a stimulus for what you do next), but they are not where the explanation ends. They are themselves behavior to be explained.
Mentalism and explanatory fictions
Mentalism explains behavior by an inner dimension: a mind, will, personality trait or cognitive process that supposedly drives behavior from inside. The problem is not that people have rich inner lives. The problem is that the inner cause is usually inferred from the very behavior it is meant to explain.
An explanatory fiction is a name that sounds like a cause but adds nothing: “Tyler does not finish his work because he is lazy.” Here, laziness is just a label for not finishing work. Hypothetical constructs such as willpower or readiness have the same problem when they cannot be observed or manipulated.
Circular reasoning
Circular reasoning uses the cause and the effect as evidence for each other.
- Why does Leo scream in class? Because he is defiant.
- How do you know he is defiant? Because he screams in class.
The loop never leaves the behavior, so it cannot suggest an intervention. Breaking the circle means finding a variable that can be observed on its own, such as what happens right after Leo screams.
Radical vs. methodological behaviorism
Methodological behaviorism accepts only publicly observable events as scientific data. It need not deny that private events exist, but it places them outside science because two observers cannot both see them.
| Methodological behaviorism | Radical behaviorism | |
|---|---|---|
| Private events | Set aside as outside science | Included as behavior |
| Role in explanation | Left out of the analysis | Analyzed as behavior to be explained, not as initiating causes |
| Where causes are found | Observable stimuli | Environment-behavior relations across phylogeny, ontogeny and culture |
Seeing it in practice
A supervisor reviews intake notes written by a new technician.
| Note says | Radical behaviorist rewrite |
|---|---|
| “Priya hits because she is frustrated.” | Hitting occurs most often when her tablet is removed, and the tablet is often returned after hitting. |
| “Marcus is unmotivated to do homework.” | Homework is rarely finished when video games are freely available beforehand and nothing follows finishing. |
| “Ms. Ortiz worries too much, so she avoids driving.” | Ms. Ortiz reports anxious thoughts and a racing heart before driving, and avoiding the trip ends them. The thoughts, the racing heart and the avoidance are all behavior or bodily events to assess. |
The rewrite does not deny Priya’s frustration or Ms. Ortiz’s worry. It moves the explanation to variables that can be observed and changed.
Common mix-ups
- Radical behaviorism does not ignore thoughts and feelings. That is methodological behaviorism. Radical behaviorism includes private events as behavior.
- Radical does not mean extreme. It means thoroughgoing.
- Private events are not mental events. They are physical events inside the skin, observed by one person. Mentalism places causes in a nonphysical mind.
- Labels are not causes. A diagnosis or trait name can summarize behavior usefully, but it cannot explain the behavior it summarizes.
Exam tip: If an answer explains behavior with a trait, a state of mind or a label inferred from that same behavior, it is mentalistic or circular. The radical behaviorist answer points to environmental variables and treats private events as behavior, not as causes.
Quick recap
- Radical behaviorism is Skinner’s philosophy: all behavior, public and private, is explained by environment-behavior relations.
- Private events are behavior that only one person can observe, and they follow the same principles as public behavior.
- Mentalism attributes behavior to an inner mind or trait. Explanatory fictions and circular reasoning are its usual forms.
- Methodological behaviorism excludes private events from science. Radical behaviorism includes them.
Further reading
- Skinner, B. F. (1945). The operational analysis of psychological terms. Psychological Review, 52, 270-277.
- Skinner, B. F. (1974). About behaviorism. Knopf.
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 1.
Key terms
- Radical behaviorism
- Skinner's philosophy of the science of behavior. It treats everything a person does, including private events such as thinking and feeling, as behavior, and explains behavior by its relations to the environment across evolutionary history, learning history and the current situation.
- Methodological behaviorism
- A philosophical position that accepts only publicly observable events as scientific data. It need not deny that thoughts and feelings exist, but it places them outside the scope of science.
- Private events
- Events inside the skin that only the person experiencing them can observe directly, such as thinking, imagining, feeling pain or talking silently to oneself. Radical behaviorism treats them as behavior that follows the same principles as public behavior.
- Mentalism
- An approach that explains behavior by appeal to an inner dimension, such as a mind, will, personality trait or cognitive process, said to cause behavior from inside. The inner cause is usually inferred from the very behavior it is meant to explain.
- Explanatory fiction
- A term that sounds like a cause of behavior but is only another name for the behavior itself, so it adds nothing to an explanation.
- Circular reasoning
- Faulty logic in which the cause and the effect of a behavior are each used as the evidence for the other, so the explanation never reaches a variable that can be observed on its own.
Check yourself
5 questions on A.3. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: D. The cause (low self-esteem) is inferred from the behavior it is supposed to explain, and the behavior is then explained by the cause. That loop is circular reasoning. A functional explanation would point to an environmental variable, such as what happens after the refusals, that can be observed independently.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Radical behaviorism includes private events in the subject matter and treats them as behavior, differing from public behavior only in that one person can observe them. Placing them outside science is the methodological behaviorist position, and treating them as initiating causes is mentalism.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Radical behaviorism includes private events and looks for the environmental conditions of both the thoughts and the avoidance. Mentalism is not the acknowledgment that thoughts exist; it is the use of an inner entity as the explanation. A methodological behaviorist would set Hana's reported thoughts aside.
Show the answer
Answer: D. 'Picky eater' is just another name for eating only a few foods, so it explains nothing. It is an explanatory fiction. A diagnosis would not fix the problem, because any label inferred from the same behavior is equally circular.
Show the answer
Answer: A. The defining difference is the treatment of private events. Methodological behaviorism accepts only publicly observable events as data, while radical behaviorism treats thinking and feeling as behavior to be analyzed. Neither position treats the mind as a cause.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.