cumulative

B.24 Imitation vs. observational learning

What the task asks: Tell apart copying a model's behavior right after it occurs from learning that comes from watching others' behavior and its consequences, and recognize each.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Watching other people is one of the fastest ways to learn. Behavior analysts separate two outcomes:

  • Imitation: the learner’s behavior copies a model’s behavior, right after it, because the model’s behavior controls it. You clap; the toddler claps.
  • Observational learning: the learner’s behavior changes because they watched someone else’s behavior and the consequences it produced. A child who sees a classmate scolded for running in the hall stops running, possibly days later.

Imitation is usually a building block for observational learning. A learner who cannot imitate rarely learns much by watching.

Breaking it down

The defining features of imitation

Most texts, Cooper, Heron and Heward among them, count a response as imitation only when it passes four checks:

  1. A model came first. Someone demonstrates an action, live or on video (as in video modeling), and that demonstration is the antecedent. Almost any action can serve.
  2. Timing. The learner responds soon after the demonstration, typically within a few seconds.
  3. Resemblance. The response looks or sounds like the demonstration. Behavior analysts call this formal similarity: the two share a sense mode and physically match, as when you see a wave and wave back.
  4. Control. The demonstration is what produces the response. If both people are reacting to the same cue, such as a bell, the match comes from shared stimulus control, not imitation.

Generalized imitation

After imitation of many different models has been reinforced, learners often imitate new models that have never been reinforced. This is generalized imitation (Baer, Peterson, & Sherman, 1967). In that study, children kept imitating unreinforced probe models as long as imitation of other models was still reinforced. Imitation had become a generalized response class, which is what lets a learner pick up new skills from a single demonstration.

Echoic as vocal imitation

The echoic (B.19) is imitation in the vocal verbal mode. It has formal similarity and point-to-point correspondence with the spoken model.

Observational learning

Observational learning is a change in an observer’s behavior that results from watching a model’s behavior and its consequences. Its features differ from imitation’s:

  • Consequences matter. What the observer does later depends on whether the model’s behavior was reinforced or punished.
  • Timing can be delayed. The change may appear hours or days later, in another setting.
  • Formal similarity is not required. The observer may do something different, or stop doing something.
  • It can increase or decrease behavior.
Imitation Ms. Ruiz touches her head and says "Do this." seconds later Malik touches his head Right after the model, same form, no consequence to the model needed Observational learning Santiago puts his plate in the sink He gets a sticker next night Emma puts her plate in the sink Delayed, and it depends on the consequence Santiago received
Two examples from the table below. Malik copies the model within seconds, in the same form; Emma's change comes the next night and depends on the sticker Santiago received.

Observational learning depends on several prerequisite skills: attending to the model, imitating, imitating after a delay, and discriminating the consequences others receive. Many learners need these taught directly. Albert Bandura’s social learning theory made the term popular; behavior analysts account for the same outcomes in terms of stimulus control, generalized imitation and learned discriminations.

Side by side

FeatureImitationObservational learning
TimingImmediately after the modelCan be delayed
Formal similarityRequiredNot required
Model’s consequencesNot neededCentral
Direction of changeProduces behavior like the model’sCan increase or decrease behavior

Seeing it in practice

ExampleOutcomeWhy
A therapist, Ms. Ruiz, touches her head and says “Do this.” Malik touches his head.ImitationImmediate, formally similar, controlled by the model
After seeing her brother Santiago get a sticker for putting his plate in the sink, Emma puts hers in the sink the next night.Observational learningDelayed, based on the consequence Santiago received
In her first week at a store, Aisha sees a coworker reprimanded for using a phone at the register and stops checking her own phone.Observational learningBehavior decreased; no formal similarity needed
Grandpa waves goodbye, and the toddler waves back right away.ImitationImmediate copy of the model
A student who imitates many actions copies a new dance step the first time the teacher shows it.Generalized imitationNew model, no reinforcement for that step
When the bell rings, Leo and his classmates all pack up at once.Not imitationThe bell is the shared SD

Common mix-ups

  • Looking alike is not enough. Formal similarity without control by the model, as when everyone responds to the same bell, is not imitation.
  • Imitation is not modeling. Modeling is the procedure of showing behavior to be copied (G.9). Imitation is the learner’s behavior.
  • Delayed copying. Cooper’s definition requires close timing. Copying a dance move seen last week is usually described as delayed imitation or as observational learning, and sources vary in how they label it.
  • Observational learning is more than delayed imitation. It depends on the consequences the model contacted, and the observer’s behavior may look nothing like the model’s.
  • Echoics are imitation in the vocal mode. They are classified as verbal operants because of their verbal function.

Exam tip: Check three things. Did the response come right after the model? Does it look like the model? Did the model’s consequences matter? Yes, yes and no means imitation. Later, possibly different, and the consequences mattered means observational learning.

Quick recap

  • Imitation: immediate, formally similar behavior controlled by a model.
  • Generalized imitation: imitating new, unreinforced models after a history of reinforced imitation.
  • Observational learning: behavior change from watching a model’s behavior and its consequences.
  • Observational learning can be delayed, can decrease behavior and does not need formal similarity.
  • Shared SDs can make behavior look imitative when it is not.

Further reading

  • Baer, D. M., Peterson, R. F., & Sherman, J. A. (1967). The development of imitation by reinforcing behavioral similarity to a model. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 10(5), 405-416.
  • Bandura, A. (1977). Social learning theory. Prentice Hall.
  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 21.

Key terms

Imitation
Behavior that copies the form of a model, occurs soon after the model and is controlled by it. In generalized imitation, a learner imitates new models that have never been directly trained.
Generalized imitation
Imitation of new models that have never been reinforced, after a history in which imitation of many other models was reinforced.
Observational learning
A change in an observer's behavior that results from watching another person's behavior and the consequences it produces. The change can be delayed, can increase or decrease behavior, and need not resemble the model's behavior.
Formal similarity
A relation in which a stimulus and a response share the same sense mode (both heard, both seen or both signed) and physically resemble each other. It is a feature of echoics, copying a text and imitation.
Echoic
A verbal operant controlled by a vocal verbal stimulus, in which the response has point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity with the stimulus. It is reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcement.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.24. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1In a session, a therapist says 'Do this' and taps the table twice. Within two seconds, Omar taps the table twice. Tapping has been taught and reinforced in earlier sessions. Which best describes Omar's response?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Omar's response follows the model immediately, looks like it, and is controlled by it, which meets the definition of imitation. It is not generalized imitation, because this response has been reinforced before. It is a motor response, not a vocal one, so it is not an echoic.

  2. Question 2At lunch, Jada watches a lunch aide praise a classmate, Darius, for throwing away his trash. Jada does nothing at the time, but the next day she throws away her trash and looks at the aide. This is best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Jada's behavior changed after she watched another person's behavior and its consequence, and the change appeared a day later. That fits observational learning. Imitation requires the response to follow the model closely in time and to be controlled by the model itself.

  3. Question 3Ben has worked in his office for years. When the fire alarm sounds, everyone stands and walks outside, and Ben does the same. A colleague says Ben was imitating his coworkers. What is the strongest reason to doubt that this is imitation?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. For imitation, the model's behavior must be the controlling variable. When everyone responds to the same SD, here the alarm, their behavior can look alike without anyone imitating anyone. The responses do have formal similarity, so that choice is wrong.

  4. Question 4After many different motor imitations have been reinforced, Lucia copies a teacher's brand-new hand gesture the first time she sees it, with no reinforcement for that gesture. This is:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Imitating a new model that has never been reinforced, after a history of reinforcement for imitating other models, is generalized imitation. It is not observational learning, because Lucia did not need to see the gesture's consequences and copied it immediately.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.