cumulative

G.1 Positive and negative reinforcement procedures

What the task asks: Plan reinforcement procedures that strengthen a target behavior, by adding a stimulus or by removing one, and judge from the data whether the procedure worked.

Behavior-Change Procedures5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

B.4 asks you to recognize reinforcement. G.1 asks you to build it. A reinforcement procedure is a plan: which behavior earns what, how soon, how much and how often. When the behavior increases and stays up because of the plan, it worked. When it does not, the plan, not the learner, is what needs to change.

Both kinds of reinforcement belong in practice. Positive reinforcement procedures add a stimulus after the behavior (praise, a token, a turn on the swing). Negative reinforcement procedures remove or postpone a stimulus after the behavior (a short break from work, fewer problems left, the end of a loud noise). The test is the same for both: does the behavior occur more often in the future?

Breaking it down

Pick a stimulus that works as a reinforcer

Start with a preference assessment (see F.4), but remember that preference is a prediction, not proof. A reinforcer assessment checks directly: deliver the item contingent on a simple response and compare responding with a condition where the item is not delivered. A child who always picks bubbles may still not work for bubbles.

Plan for variety. Rotating several reinforcers, or letting the learner choose from a small menu, slows satiation (see G.5).

Make it contingent

A contingency is the dependency between a response and its consequence. In a reinforcement procedure, the reinforcer comes only when the target behavior occurs. If the learner can get the same item freely at other times, the contingency is weak and so is the effect. Write down exactly which response earns the reinforcer, and make sure every implementer agrees.

Make it immediate

Immediacy matters because the reinforcer strengthens whatever behavior happened just before it. A 30-second delay lets other behavior (looking away, getting up, complaining) slip in between. During acquisition, deliver within a second or two. When a delay cannot be avoided, bridge it with a conditioned reinforcer such as praise or a token (see G.4).

Immediate within 1 second Labels picture 1 s Token Delayed 30 seconds later 30 s delay Labels picture Looks away Gets up Token strengthened by the token
Kenji's token, delivered at two delays. Within a second, it follows the label. After 30 seconds, it follows whatever he did last, here getting up from the table, and that is the behavior it strengthens.

Set the magnitude

Magnitude is the amount, duration or intensity of the reinforcer. Too little may not be worth the effort. Too much produces satiation and long pauses while the learner consumes it. A bite-sized edible or 30 seconds of a preferred video usually keeps a session moving better than a whole snack or ten minutes of screen time. Harder tasks may need a larger or higher-quality reinforcer.

Choose the schedule

Reinforce every correct response while a skill is new, then thin to an intermittent schedule so the behavior holds up when reinforcement is less frequent (see B.9 and G.16). Thinning too fast is a common reason a working plan suddenly stops working.

Using negative reinforcement on purpose

Many teaching situations already contain something the learner would rather avoid: hard work, a noisy room, a long task. A negative reinforcement procedure makes escape from that condition depend on the behavior you want.

  • Earned breaks: finish three problems, then take a one-minute break.
  • Functional communication: asking for a break produces a short break (see G.2).
  • Reduced demands: finishing part of a task removes the rest.

Two cautions. Use the aversive conditions that are already part of the situation, and never add an aversive stimulus just so you can remove it. And plan to make the work itself less aversive over time. Positive reinforcement for compliance can help here: research on escape-maintained behavior shows that a strong positive reinforcer for working can compete well with the chance to escape.

Evaluating the procedure

Compare the target behavior with baseline. If it does not increase, work through the likely causes:

  1. Integrity: was the reinforcer really delivered contingently and immediately?
  2. Motivation: was the learner satiated, or is the item freely available elsewhere?
  3. Effort: is the response too costly for the payoff?
  4. Value: does the stimulus pass a reinforcer assessment?

Seeing it in practice

SettingTarget behaviorProcedureType
ClinicKenji labels picturesA token for each correct label; five tokens buy a short videoPositive
ClassroomAmara finishes math problemsAfter every four problems, a two-minute break from mathNegative
HomeLuis brushes his teethPraise, and he picks the bedtime storyPositive
WorkplaceStaff submit data sheets on timeAnyone who submits by Friday skips the Monday catch-up meetingNegative (avoidance)

Amara’s plan is negative reinforcement because math work is removed for a while. If she also earns a sticker for each problem, the plan combines both kinds.

Common mix-ups

  • Negative does not mean bad. Negative reinforcement still strengthens behavior. The word refers to removal, not to punishment.
  • A preferred item is not automatically a reinforcer. Only an increase in the behavior shows that it is.
  • The contingency decides which behavior grows. A break after a finished worksheet strengthens finishing. A break after a torn worksheet strengthens tearing.
  • Bigger is not always better. Large reinforcers cause satiation and long interruptions.
  • End-of-day praise does little for one moment’s behavior. Without a bridge, delays weaken the effect.

Exam tip: When a scenario says a reinforcement plan “isn’t working,” look for the broken link: the item is not a reinforcer, it is not contingent, it is delayed, or the learner is satiated. The best answer usually repairs that link rather than adding punishment.

Quick recap

  • Confirm reinforcers by their effect, with a reinforcer assessment when preference alone is uncertain.
  • Deliver reinforcers contingently and immediately, in an amount that motivates without causing satiation.
  • Start with continuous reinforcement and thin gradually.
  • Negative reinforcement procedures, such as earned breaks, use escape from existing demands to strengthen a target behavior.
  • Evaluate against baseline, and troubleshoot integrity, motivation, effort and reinforcer value.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 11 and 12.
  • Iwata, B. A. (1987). Negative reinforcement in applied behavior analysis: An emerging technology. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 20(4), 361-378.
  • Fisher, W., Piazza, C. C., Bowman, L. G., Hagopian, L. P., Owens, J. C., & Slevin, I. (1992). A comparison of two approaches for identifying reinforcers for persons with severe and profound disabilities. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 25(2), 491-498.

Key terms

Positive reinforcement (SR+)
Reinforcement in which a stimulus is added, or increased in intensity, right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs more often in the future. Positive means added, not good.
Negative reinforcement (SR-)
Reinforcement in which a stimulus is removed, reduced in intensity or postponed right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs more often in the future. It includes escape and avoidance. Negative means taken away, not bad, and negative reinforcement is not punishment.
Reinforcer assessment
A direct test of whether a stimulus functions as a reinforcer. The stimulus is delivered contingent on a response, and responding is compared with a condition in which it is not delivered. It confirms what a preference assessment can only predict.
Contingency
A dependency between events, most often between a response and its consequence: the consequence is delivered when, and because, the response occurs. A three-term contingency adds the antecedent conditions in which that dependency holds.
Immediacy of reinforcement
How soon a reinforcer follows the response. Reinforcers delivered within a second or two strengthen the target response most effectively; longer delays let other behavior occur in between and receive the reinforcement instead.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.1. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A therapist gives Xiomara a piece of cracker at the end of each 20-minute session for 'working nicely.' After two weeks, Xiomara's correct responding during sessions has not changed. Which change is most likely to help?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The reinforcer arrives 20 minutes late and is not tied to any particular response, so it cannot strengthen correct responding. Small, immediate, contingent delivery fixes both problems. A bigger cracker at the end keeps the same delay, and stating the rule does not close the gap for a learner who may not yet respond to rules.

  2. Question 2In a paired-stimulus preference assessment, Ezra chose a toy car on almost every trial. When the car was then delivered for each block he stacked, his stacking stayed at baseline levels for five sessions. What is the best conclusion?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. A reinforcer is defined by its effect, and contingent delivery produced no increase. Preference predicts reinforcer value but does not guarantee it. Assuming the car is a reinforcer that just needs time ignores five sessions of flat data; the next step is to check the MO and effort or test other stimuli.

  3. Question 3Joaquin's teacher removes his worksheet for a two-minute break after every five problems he completes. During breaks he sits quietly with no materials and no attention. His completion rate doubles. Which procedure is the teacher using?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Completing problems removes the worksheet for a time, and completion increases, so this is negative reinforcement. Nothing is added during the break, which rules out positive reinforcement. The break depends on completed work, so it is not noncontingent escape, which would be delivered on a time schedule.

  4. Question 4A behavior analyst wants to use negative reinforcement to increase Folake's handwriting practice, which she finds effortful. Which plan is the best design?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The plan uses an aversive condition that already exists (the practice set) and makes its reduction depend on writing. The tone would also be negative reinforcement, but it adds an aversive stimulus just so it can be removed, which is unnecessary and hard to justify. Breaks after crying reinforce crying, and breaks on a timer do not depend on writing at all.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.