cumulative

B.11 Operant vs. respondent extinction, as operations and processes

What the task asks: Tell operant extinction (no longer reinforcing a previously reinforced response) apart from respondent extinction (presenting a conditioned stimulus without the unconditioned stimulus), and distinguish each procedure from the decrease it produces.

Concepts and Principles6 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Extinction is how learned behavior weakens when the relation that built it is broken. Because there are two kinds of learning (see B.3), there are two kinds of extinction:

  • Operant extinction: a behavior that used to produce a reinforcer no longer does, and it decreases.
  • Respondent extinction: a conditioned stimulus keeps appearing without the unconditioned stimulus, and it gradually stops eliciting the conditioned response.

Each term also does double duty. It names the operation (the procedure someone carries out) and the process (the decrease in responding that results). The exam checks whether you can tell which is meant.

Breaking it down

Operant extinction

As an operation, extinction means discontinuing reinforcement for a previously reinforced behavior: the response no longer produces the consequence that maintained it. As a process, it is the resulting decrease in that behavior, often to near zero.

What gets withheld is the maintaining reinforcer, so extinction looks different for each function:

  • Positive reinforcement: the attention, item or activity no longer follows the behavior. If whining was maintained by attention, whining produces no attention.
  • Negative reinforcement: the behavior no longer ends or avoids the aversive stimulus. If a learner screams to escape tasks, the task continues (escape extinction).
  • Automatic reinforcement: the sensory consequence is blocked or reduced, where that is possible (sometimes called sensory extinction).

Ignoring is extinction only when attention is the maintaining reinforcer. If a student screams to get out of work, ignoring the scream while also removing the work is not extinction at all.

Side effects of operant extinction

  • Extinction burst: an immediate increase in the frequency, duration or intensity of the behavior when extinction starts. Bursts are common but do not always occur.
  • Extinction-induced variability: new forms of the behavior appear. This can create new problem behavior, but it also supplies the variation that shaping relies on.
  • Extinction-induced aggression: aggression and other emotional behavior may appear or increase.
  • Spontaneous recovery: after the behavior has decreased, it suddenly reappears, often at the start of a later session, even though reinforcement is still withheld. It is usually weaker and briefer, and it fades if extinction continues.

Giving in during a burst or a recovery reinforces the behavior intermittently, which makes it harder to extinguish next time. Planning for these effects is covered in H.4, and relapse in H.5.

Resistance to extinction

Resistance to extinction is how long, or how many times, a behavior keeps occurring after extinction begins. It is greater when the behavior was reinforced intermittently, especially on variable schedules, and it is also affected by the length of the reinforcement history, the current motivating operation and how much effort the response takes. Research on behavioral momentum (see B.22) adds that richer reinforcement can make behavior more persistent in some conditions, but the exam usually expects the general rule that intermittent reinforcement produces more resistance than continuous reinforcement.

Respondent extinction

As an operation, respondent extinction means repeatedly presenting the conditioned stimulus (CS) without the unconditioned stimulus (US). As a process, it is the gradual weakening of the conditioned response (CR) until the CS no longer elicits it. Consequences of the person’s behavior play no role.

Pavlov’s dogs stopped salivating to the sound when it was presented again and again without food. Spontaneous recovery occurs here too: the CR can reappear after a break and then fade with more CS-alone presentations.

0246810Session 1Session 2, after a rest1234567891011121314Sound-alone presentationsDrops of saliva
Respondent extinction. The sound is presented again and again without food, and salivation fades. After a rest it partly returns at the start of the next session (spontaneous recovery), then fades again.

Exposure-based treatments for fear draw on respondent extinction. Because a frightened person usually also has operant escape and avoidance behavior, these treatments often prevent escape, so the person stays in contact with the CS long enough for the CR to weaken.

Side by side

Operant extinctionRespondent extinction
OperationStop delivering the reinforcer after the responsePresent the CS repeatedly without the US
ProcessResponse frequency decreasesThe CS gradually stops eliciting the CR
What is brokenThe response-consequence relationThe stimulus-stimulus relation
Typical side effectsBurst, variability, aggression, spontaneous recoverySpontaneous recovery

Seeing it in practice

  • Home, operant. For months, Mateo’s parents have gone back into his room whenever he calls out after lights-out. They agree to stop. On the first night, calling out lasts 40 minutes and gets louder (an extinction burst). By night six it is gone. On night ten it briefly returns (spontaneous recovery), and his parents stick to the plan.
  • Clinic, escape extinction. A client, Grace, throws materials to end work sessions. With escape extinction, the session continues after throwing. Throwing first increases, then declines across sessions.
  • Dental office, respondent. After a painful procedure, the smell of the office makes an adult patient nauseous. The dentist schedules several short, painless visits. The smell (CS) occurs repeatedly without pain (US), and the nausea (CR) fades.
010203040Parents go back inExtinction24681012141618NightsMinutes of calling out
Mateo's calling out after lights-out. On the first night of extinction it jumps to 40 minutes (the burst). It is gone by the sixth extinction night, then returns briefly and more weakly on the tenth (spontaneous recovery).

Common mix-ups

  • Extinction is not punishment. Nothing is added or taken away; the behavior simply stops producing its usual consequence. Removing a different reinforcer is negative punishment (see B.5).
  • Extinction is not forgetting. Forgetting is weakening over time without the chance to respond. Extinction requires the response to occur and go unreinforced.
  • The operation does not guarantee the process. If the wrong reinforcer is withheld, the procedure is carried out but the behavior will not decrease.
  • Respondent extinction does not involve consequences. It changes what follows the CS, not what follows the behavior.
  • A burst is not failure. An early increase is a predictable effect of extinction, not evidence that it is not working.

Exam tip: Ask what is being withheld. If a response no longer produces its reinforcer, it is operant extinction. If a CS keeps appearing without its US, it is respondent extinction. Then ask whether the stem describes what someone did (operation) or what happened to the behavior (process).

Quick recap

  • Operant extinction: stop reinforcing a previously reinforced response, and responding decreases.
  • Respondent extinction: present the CS without the US, and the CR weakens.
  • Each term names both an operation and a process.
  • Expect bursts, variability, aggression and spontaneous recovery.
  • Intermittent reinforcement increases resistance to extinction.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 2 and 24.
  • Lerman, D. C., & Iwata, B. A. (1996). Developing a technology for the use of operant extinction in clinical settings: An examination of basic and applied research. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 29(3), 345-382.

Key terms

Extinction (Operant extinction, EXT)
Discontinuing reinforcement for a previously reinforced behavior, so the behavior no longer produces the consequence that maintained it. The term names both the procedure (the operation) and the process it produces: a decrease in the frequency of the behavior, sometimes after an initial extinction burst.
Respondent extinction
Repeatedly presenting a conditioned stimulus without the unconditioned stimulus, so the conditioned stimulus gradually stops eliciting the conditioned response. The term names both the procedure and the resulting weakening of the conditioned response.
Extinction burst
An immediate, usually temporary increase in the frequency, duration or intensity of a behavior when extinction begins. Bursts are common but do not always occur, and giving in during a burst reinforces the more intense behavior.
Spontaneous recovery
The reappearance of an extinguished behavior after time has passed, often at the start of a later session, even though reinforcement is still withheld (or, in respondent extinction, the unconditioned stimulus is still absent). The recovered behavior is usually weaker and briefer than before and fades if extinction continues.
Resistance to extinction
How long, or how many times, a behavior keeps occurring after extinction begins. It is greater after intermittent reinforcement (especially on variable schedules) than after continuous reinforcement, and it is also affected by the length of the reinforcement history, the current motivating operation and response effort.
Extinction-induced aggression
Aggressive or emotional behavior that appears or increases when a previously reinforced behavior is placed on extinction. It is a known side effect of extinction to plan for, along with the extinction burst and extinction-induced variability.
Extinction-induced variability
An increase in the variety of response forms when a behavior is placed on extinction. New topographies appear, which can produce new problem behavior but also supplies the variation that shaping relies on.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.11. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Jasmine's bedtime tantrums have been maintained by her father lying down with her. Her father stops lying down when she tantrums. On the first night, the tantrum is longer and louder than usual. What is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. An immediate increase in the duration or intensity of behavior when its reinforcer is first withheld is an extinction burst. Spontaneous recovery happens later, after the behavior has already decreased, and ratio strain comes from raising a ratio requirement, not from removing reinforcement.

  2. Question 2Ximena, age 3, became afraid of the bathtub after slipping and getting hurt there. Her parents then bathe her many times in a tub with a non-slip mat, with no further falls, and the fear gradually disappears. Which procedure best describes this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The bathtub became a conditioned stimulus when it was paired with pain. Presenting it repeatedly without the pain (the unconditioned stimulus) weakens the fear, which is respondent extinction. Operant extinction would involve withholding a reinforcer for a response, and no response is being placed on extinction here.

  3. Question 3A teacher stopped giving attention for a student's call-outs, which attention had been maintaining. Call-outs fell to zero over two weeks. On the first morning after a long weekend, several call-outs occurred and then stopped again. What explains the call-outs after the weekend?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. An extinguished behavior that briefly reappears after time away, while reinforcement is still withheld, shows spontaneous recovery. It fades if extinction continues. An extinction burst happens at the start of extinction, not after the behavior has already reached zero.

  4. Question 4A behavior analyst's note reads: 'Extinction was implemented for three weeks, but the behavior has not decreased.' Which statement best describes this situation?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Extinction names both the operation (withholding the reinforcer) and the process (the resulting decrease). Here the operation was used, but no decrease followed. A common cause is withholding something that was not the maintaining reinforcer, which is why function should be identified first.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.