cumulative

B.3 Respondent vs. operant conditioning

What the task asks: Tell respondent conditioning (learning through stimulus-stimulus pairing) apart from operant conditioning (learning through consequences), and identify each in examples.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Behavior is learned in two basic ways. In respondent conditioning, a stimulus that used to do nothing comes to elicit a reflexive response because it has been paired with a stimulus that already elicits it. In operant conditioning, behavior becomes more or less frequent because of the consequences it has produced.

The quickest way to tell them apart: respondent learning is about relations between stimuli, usually things that happen before the response. Operant learning is about the relation between a response and what happens after it. Most real situations involve both, and the exam often asks you to pull them apart.

Breaking it down

Respondent behavior and reflexes

Respondent behavior is elicited: a specific antecedent stimulus reliably produces it. Many respondents are unlearned reflexes. An unconditioned stimulus (US) elicits an unconditioned response (UR) with no learning needed. Food in the mouth elicits salivation, a puff of air elicits a blink, and a sudden loud noise elicits a startle.

Respondent conditioning

Respondent conditioning works through stimulus-stimulus pairing. A neutral stimulus (NS), one that does not yet elicit the response, is presented just before or together with a US. After enough pairings, the formerly neutral stimulus elicits a similar response on its own. It is now a conditioned stimulus (CS), and the response it elicits is a conditioned response (CR).

Pavlov’s dogs are the classic case. A sound (NS) was followed by food (US), and soon the sound alone (now a CS) elicited salivation (now a CR). The CR usually resembles the UR, but it is often weaker. Pairing works best when the NS comes shortly before the US; presenting the US first and the NS after produces little or no conditioning.

NS first Sound (NS) Food (US) Conditioning The sound comes to elicit salivation US first Food (US) Sound (NS) Little or none The sound stays mostly neutral Time
Order matters in pairing. When the sound comes shortly before the food, the sound comes to elicit salivation; when the food comes first, little or no conditioning occurs.

Higher-order conditioning extends the process. Once a CS exists, it can stand in for the US: pairing a new neutral stimulus with the CS can turn the new stimulus into a CS as well. This helps explain how fear spreads to stimuli that were never paired with anything harmful themselves.

Operant behavior and operant conditioning

Operant behavior is emitted. No antecedent pulls it out the way a puff of air pulls out a blink. Its future frequency depends on its history of consequences. In operant conditioning, a consequence that follows a behavior changes how often that behavior occurs in the future. Consequences that increase it are reinforcers (see B.4), and consequences that decrease it are punishers (see B.5).

Antecedents still matter for operant behavior, but in a different way. A discriminative stimulus (see B.12) does not elicit a response. It evokes one, making the response more likely because the response has been reinforced in its presence before.

Side by side

RespondentOperant
Key relationStimulus-stimulus (NS paired with US)Response-consequence
How the response occursElicited by an antecedentEmitted; evoked by a discriminative stimulus
What produces learningPairing of stimuliConsequences of the response
Typical behaviorReflexes, emotional and physiological responsesMost of what people do: talking, reaching, working, asking
ResultA new CS-CR relationA change in the future frequency of the response

Seeing it in practice

  • Clinic, both at once. Elijah, age 6, has had several painful blood draws at a clinic with a sharp disinfectant smell. Now the smell alone makes his heart race and his hands sweat. Pain was the US, the smell was the NS, and the racing heart is now a CR to the smell (a CS). Elijah has also started running out of the waiting room, and running has delayed the needle several times. The running is operant: it is maintained by its consequence (negative reinforcement, see B.4).
  • Dental office, higher-order. A patient tenses at the whine of a dental drill, a CS from past pain. The hygienist always calls the patient’s name just before the drill starts. After several visits, hearing the name makes the patient tense even before reaching the chair. The name was never paired with pain, only with the drill’s whine.
  • Classroom, operant only. Hana gets a laugh from classmates when she makes a funny noise, and over the next weeks she makes the noise more often. Nothing elicited the noise. Its frequency changed because of what followed it.
Respondent: one stimulus paired with another Before pairing During pairing After pairing Smell neutral (NS) elicits nothing No racing heart Smell, then pain NS paired with US elicits Racing heart unconditioned (UR) Smell alone now conditioned (CS) elicits Racing heart conditioned (CR) Operant: a response followed by a consequence Waiting room Runs out Needle delayed Running out increases Antecedent Response Consequence Future frequency
Elijah's two kinds of learning. The smell gains its effect by being paired with pain, before any response occurs; running out gains strength from what follows it.

Common mix-ups

  • Elicit vs. evoke. Respondent antecedents elicit. Discriminative stimuli evoke. If a stem says a stimulus elicits a reflexive or emotional response, think respondent.
  • “It happened after a stimulus” does not mean respondent. Operant behavior also occurs in the presence of antecedents. Ask what produced the learning: pairing two stimuli, or a consequence following the response.
  • Pairing also builds reinforcers. Establishing a conditioned reinforcer (see B.7) uses stimulus-stimulus pairing, the same operation as respondent conditioning, even though the new reinforcer is then used to strengthen operant behavior.
  • The CR is not always identical to the UR. It is usually similar and often weaker.
  • Skip the voluntary and involuntary shortcut. It works for simple reflexes but breaks down for emotional and complex behavior, and it is not how the field defines the two. Classify by the relation that controls the behavior.

Exam tip: Find what was paired with what. If a neutral stimulus was paired with one that already elicits a response, it is respondent conditioning. If a response was followed by a consequence that changed its future frequency, it is operant conditioning.

Quick recap

  • Respondent conditioning: an NS is paired with a US until the NS (now a CS) elicits a CR.
  • Operant conditioning: consequences change the future frequency of behavior.
  • Respondents are elicited; operants are emitted and evoked by discriminative stimuli.
  • Higher-order conditioning pairs a new stimulus with an existing CS.
  • Many real situations combine both: a feeling elicited by a CS, and an escape response maintained by its consequence.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 2.
  • Pavlov, I. P. (1927). Conditioned reflexes (G. V. Anrep, Trans.). Oxford University Press.

Key terms

Respondent conditioning (Classical conditioning, Pavlovian conditioning)
Learning in which a neutral stimulus is paired with an unconditioned stimulus until the formerly neutral stimulus elicits a similar response on its own. The neutral stimulus becomes a conditioned stimulus, and the response it now elicits is a conditioned response.
Operant conditioning (Instrumental conditioning)
Learning in which the consequences of a behavior change how often that behavior occurs in the future. Operant behavior is emitted rather than elicited, and reinforcement and punishment are its basic processes.
Unconditioned stimulus (US, UCS)
A stimulus that elicits a response without any prior learning. The relation between an unconditioned stimulus and the response it elicits is part of the organism's inherited biology.
Unconditioned response (UR, UCR)
The response elicited by an unconditioned stimulus without any prior learning, such as a reflexive blink, salivation or a startle.
Conditioned stimulus (CS)
A formerly neutral stimulus that elicits a response because it has been paired with an unconditioned stimulus, or with another conditioned stimulus.
Conditioned response (CR)
A response elicited by a conditioned stimulus as a result of respondent conditioning. It usually resembles the unconditioned response but is often weaker.
Higher-order conditioning (Second-order conditioning)
Respondent conditioning in which a neutral stimulus is paired with an existing conditioned stimulus, rather than with an unconditioned stimulus, and comes to elicit the conditioned response.
Stimulus-stimulus pairing (Pairing)
Presenting a neutral stimulus together with, or just before, a stimulus that already has a function, so that the neutral stimulus acquires a similar function. Pairing establishes conditioned stimuli, conditioned reinforcers and conditioned punishers. The same name is also used for a specific procedure that pairs an adult's speech sounds with preferred items to increase a child's vocalizations.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.3. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A child is stung by a bee while wearing a bright yellow raincoat. Afterward, the sight of the raincoat makes the child's heart race. In this example, the yellow raincoat is now:
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The raincoat was neutral until it was paired with the sting, an unconditioned stimulus, and now it elicits a racing heart on its own. That makes it a conditioned stimulus. It is not a discriminative stimulus, because it elicits a reflexive response rather than evoking an operant with a reinforcement history.

  2. Question 2Every time Dario finishes his chores, his grandmother lets him pick the evening's movie, and he now finishes his chores more often. Which statement best describes this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Finishing chores is followed by a consequence (picking the movie), and the behavior has become more frequent. That is operant conditioning by positive reinforcement. Nothing here involves pairing two stimuli to make one elicit a reflexive response.

  3. Question 3At work, Étienne's stomach tightens when his manager's name appears on his phone, because those calls have often brought bad news. He gives the manager a custom ringtone, which always plays a moment before he sees the name. After a few weeks, the ringtone alone makes his stomach tighten, even from across the room. What is this an example of?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The ringtone was paired with a stimulus that was already a conditioned stimulus (the manager's name on the screen), and now it elicits the conditioned response by itself. That is higher-order conditioning. Stimulus generalization would require a stimulus that resembles the original, and a ringtone does not resemble a name on a screen.

  4. Question 4Which statement correctly contrasts respondent and operant behavior?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Respondents are elicited by antecedent stimuli, either unconditioned or conditioned. Operants are emitted and their future frequency depends on consequences. The distractors swap the two, for example by giving discriminative stimuli to respondents, when discriminative stimuli evoke operants.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.