cumulative

G.14 Designing group contingencies

What the task asks: Design group contingencies of each type to fit the group and the behavior, and plan for their risks, such as peer pressure or one member undermining the group.

Behavior-Change Procedures5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

A group contingency makes a shared consequence depend on the behavior of one member of a group, part of the group, or everyone in it. Teachers, coaches, camp counselors and workplace supervisors use them because one contingency can manage many people at once, and because peers become part of the reinforcement system.

The type you choose decides whose behavior counts and who gets the reinforcer. That choice changes how group members treat each other, for better or worse, so a group contingency needs the same careful design and monitoring as an individual plan.

Breaking it down

Independent group contingency

In an independent group contingency, the same rule is announced to everyone, but each person earns the reinforcer for their own performance. “Anyone who completes 20 problems with 90% accuracy gets 10 minutes of free time.” No one’s outcome depends on anyone else. Independent contingencies are often run through token economies or contracts (G.4).

Dependent group contingency

In a dependent group contingency, the whole group’s reward depends on the performance of one person or a small subset. “If Jamal finishes his reading log every day this week, the class gets a pizza party.” When one student earns the reward for everyone, this is often called the hero procedure, and classmates tend to cheer the student on and help.

Interdependent group contingency

In an interdependent group contingency, everyone gets the reward only if the group meets the criterion, so each member’s behavior matters to all the others. Common versions:

  • Every member must meet the criterion (“If everyone turns in homework, we go outside”).
  • The group’s total or average must meet it.
  • The Good Behavior Game (Barrish, Saunders & Wolf, 1969): the class splits into teams, each rule violation by a team member earns that team a mark, and every team that stays at or under a set number of marks earns privileges. Teams compete, but all of them can win.
Behavior counts Met the goal Earns reward Independent Dependent Interdependent
Whose behavior counts, and who gets the reward, for a group of four. Independent: each person earns by their own performance. Dependent: one member's performance earns for everyone. Interdependent: the group earns only when everyone meets the goal.

Randomized components

Randomizing parts of the contingency keeps everyone working without singling anyone out. A teacher can draw the reinforcer, the criterion, the target behavior, or whose performance counts from a jar at the end of the period. If the student drawn did not meet the goal, the teacher can say the class did not earn it today without naming anyone. Sources differ on whether a reward based on one randomly chosen student should be called dependent or interdependent. Because nobody knows whose behavior will count, everyone has to perform, which follows the interdependent logic.

Risks

  • Peer pressure. Group members may threaten, tease or blame a peer whose behavior costs them the reward. Dependent contingencies concentrate this on one person.
  • Sabotage. One member may deliberately break rules so the group loses, especially when peers’ reactions reinforce it.
  • Unfair outcomes. Members who did their part lose the reward because of someone else.
  • Free riders. With a total or average criterion, a few high performers can carry the group while others do little.
  • Skill deficits. If a member whose behavior counts cannot do the behavior, everyone is penalized for a skill problem.

Designing around them

  1. Target behaviors that every member whose behavior counts can already perform.
  2. Set criteria the group can meet, starting easy and raising them over time.
  3. Use reinforcers most members value, checked with a preference assessment (F.4).
  4. Watch individual data, not just the group’s result.
  5. If one member keeps undermining the group, move that person to their own team or to an individual contingency.
  6. Avoid group punishment, such as cancelling everyone’s recess, and watch peer interactions for pressure.

Seeing it in practice

SettingArrangementType
A 4th-grade classEach student who reads 20 minutes a night earns a bookmark.Independent
A high-school soccer teamIf the goalkeeper attends every practice, the whole team gets a pizza night.Dependent
An after-school programIf all the chairs are stacked within 5 minutes, everyone gets a game.Interdependent
A call-center teamIf the team’s average customer rating stays above 4.5, everyone gets a long lunch.Interdependent (average)
A 2nd-grade classTwo teams, marks for calling out, and any team with 4 or fewer marks picks a recess game.Interdependent (Good Behavior Game)

Common mix-ups

  • Independent vs. interdependent. Both may announce one rule to the whole group. Ask whose behavior decides each person’s reward. If each person’s own behavior decides their own reward, it is independent.
  • Dependent vs. interdependent. Dependent means one person or a few earn for everyone. Interdependent means the group must meet the criterion together.
  • The Good Behavior Game is not a token economy. Teams collect marks for rule violations, and the reward depends on staying under a limit.
  • A group contingency is not group punishment. The standard design reinforces. Taking privileges from everyone for one person’s behavior adds the risks of punishment (G.17, G.18).

Exam tip: Ask two questions: whose behavior is measured, and who gets the reward? Each person for themselves is independent. One person for the whole group is dependent. Everyone for everyone is interdependent.

Quick recap

  • Independent: one rule, individual outcomes.
  • Dependent: one member or a subset earns for the whole group, as in the hero procedure.
  • Interdependent: the group earns only if everyone, or the group as a whole, meets the criterion. The Good Behavior Game is the classic example.
  • Randomizing reinforcers, criteria or whose performance counts keeps everyone engaged and protects individuals.
  • Plan for peer pressure, sabotage, free riders and skill deficits before you start.

Further reading

  • Barrish, H. H., Saunders, M., & Wolf, M. M. (1969). Good behavior game: Effects of individual contingencies for group consequences on disruptive behavior in a classroom. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 2(2), 119-124.
  • Litow, L., & Pumroy, D. K. (1975). A brief review of classroom group-oriented contingencies. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 8(3), 341-347.
  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 28.

Key terms

Group contingency
An arrangement in which a common consequence depends on the behavior of one member of a group, part of the group, or every member. The three main types are independent, dependent and interdependent.
Independent group contingency
A group contingency in which the same rule applies to everyone but each person earns the reinforcer based only on their own performance.
Dependent group contingency
A group contingency in which reinforcement for the whole group depends on the performance of one member or a small subset of members.
Interdependent group contingency
A group contingency in which every member receives the reinforcer only if the group as a whole meets the criterion, either because each member meets it or because a group total or average does.
Good Behavior Game (GBG)
A classroom interdependent group contingency in which students are divided into teams, each rule violation by a team member earns that team a mark, and every team that stays at or under a set number of marks earns a reward.
Hero procedure
A dependent group contingency in which one person's performance earns a reinforcer for the whole group, which often leads peers to encourage and support that person.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.14. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Ms. Okafor tells her class that if Andrés finishes his math work every day this week, everyone will get an extra 15 minutes of recess on Friday. Classmates begin encouraging Andrés and helping him get started. What type of contingency is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The whole class's reward depends on one student's behavior, which defines a dependent group contingency (this version is often called the hero procedure). It would be interdependent only if every student, or the class as a whole, had to meet the criterion. In an independent contingency, each student would earn recess for their own work.

  2. Question 2During the Good Behavior Game, one student, Jonah, keeps calling out on purpose so his team loses, and he laughs when his teammates groan. Everyone else's behavior has improved. What should the teacher do next?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Moving a member who undermines the group to a separate team or an individual plan removes the payoff of making others lose and protects his teammates' access to reinforcement. Extra marks and public naming add peer attention, which may be what maintains the calling out. Stopping the game punishes the students whose behavior improved.

  3. Question 3A teacher offers a class party if the class average on Friday's spelling quiz is 85% or higher. The class earns the party every week, but four students' scores have fallen steadily. What change best addresses this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. An average criterion lets high scorers carry the group, so some members can slip without anyone losing the reward. Requiring each student to meet a criterion matched to their level makes every member's behavior count. Raising the average still lets the same students coast.

  4. Question 4A teacher plans a dependent group contingency: the class earns extra art time if Mei completes her daily writing assignment. Before starting, what should the teacher confirm?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. If Mei lacks the skill, the class loses the reward for something she cannot yet do, which invites blame and pressure without improving her writing. A skill deficit calls for teaching first. Recruiting peer reminders and posting her progress both increase the pressure on one student.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.