cumulative

B.20 Multiple control in verbal behavior

What the task asks: Recognize that most verbal responses are influenced by more than one variable, and identify convergent and divergent multiple control in examples.

Concepts and Principles4 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

B.19 sorts verbal responses into clean categories, but real speech seldom comes from a single source. Skinner (1957) pointed out that the strength of a verbal response is usually a function of more than one variable, and that a single variable usually affects more than one response. This is multiple control. Michael, Palmer and Sundberg (2011) named the two directions convergent and divergent.

Multiple control explains why puns are funny and why speech is flexible. It is also behind everyday clinical problems: prompts that never fade, a child who names cookies only when hungry, and answers that fall apart when the question is worded differently.

Breaking it down

Convergent multiple control

Convergent multiple control occurs when a single response is controlled by more than one variable at once. A tired office worker (an MO) looks at the coffee pot (a nonverbal stimulus) just as a coworker asks, “What do you need?” (a verbal stimulus), and says “Coffee.” Three sources converge on one response, and together they make it stronger than any one of them would alone.

Divergent multiple control

Divergent multiple control occurs when a single variable strengthens several different responses. A photo of a dog can evoke “dog,” “puppy,” “golden retriever,” “Buddy” or “woof.” The question “Name a fruit” can evoke dozens of answers. Divergent control is what makes a speaker’s repertoire flexible, and it is why one question can have many correct answers.

Convergent: many sources, one response Tired MO Coffee pot in view nonverbal "What do you need?" verbal "Coffee" Divergent: one source, many responses Photo of a dog nonverbal "dog" "puppy" "golden retriever" "woof"
The two directions of multiple control, using the examples above. Several sources pointing at one response is convergent; one source pointing at several responses is divergent.

Common multiply controlled responses

  • Impure tact: a response controlled jointly by an MO and a nonverbal stimulus, such as saying “Cookie!” when both hungry and looking at a cookie. It is part mand and part tact, and some texts call it a mand-tact. A learner who tacts food only when hungry has a response under MO control, not a pure tact.
  • Tacts evoked by questions: when a therapist holds up a car and asks, “What is it?”, the answer “car” is controlled by the object and by the question. Change the question to “What color is it?” and the same object evokes “red.” Responses that require both sources at once are sometimes called verbal conditional discriminations.
  • Prompted responses: “Say ‘cup’” while holding up a cup puts an echoic source and a tact source on the same response. Transfer of stimulus control depends on this overlap: the echoic prompt is faded until the cup alone evokes “cup” (G.7, G.8).
  • Puns, wordplay and slips: Skinner described formal sources of control (sound or spelling, as in echoics and textual behavior) and thematic sources (meaning, as in tacts and intraverbals). A pun is evoked by both at once. Walking past a bakery, someone says the business is “on a roll.”
  • Audience: the listener is also a variable. People talk differently to a toddler, a colleague and a grandparent.

Why it matters for teaching

If a response stays under the control of a prompt, it will fail when the prompt is gone. To find out what is controlling a response, probe each source alone: present the item when the learner is not deprived, or ask the question without the picture. Multiple control can also be used on purpose: add a source to strengthen a weak response, then fade it.

Seeing it in practice

ExampleSourcesType
At lunch, hungry Omar sees pizza and says “pizza.”MO and the pizzaConvergent (impure tact)
The teacher asks, “What animals live on a farm?” Students say “cow,” “pig,” “horse,” “goat.”One verbal stimulus, many responsesDivergent
The therapist holds up a cup and says, “Say cup.” Yuki says “cup.”Echoic prompt and the cupConvergent; the prompt still needs fading
During a game, a lemon evokes “yellow,” “sour,” “fruit” and “lemonade” from different players.One nonverbal stimulus, many responsesDivergent
Shown a red apple, Ben says “apple” to “What is it?” and “red” to “What color is it?”The picture and each questionConvergent (verbal conditional discrimination)

Common mix-ups

  • Convergent vs. divergent. Converge means many variables act on one response. Diverge means one variable acts on many responses.
  • One label rarely tells the whole story. Most real responses have more than one source. Items may ask you to identify which sources are present.
  • Impure does not mean wrong. The term describes what controls the response, not a mistake by the learner.
  • Divergent control is not response generalization. In divergent control each response has its own history with the shared stimulus. Response generalization (B.14) is about untrained responses appearing.
  • Multiple control is not a multiple schedule. Multiple schedules (B.10) are a reinforcement arrangement.

Exam tip: Count the arrows. If several antecedents point at one response, it is convergent. If one antecedent points at several responses, it is divergent.

Quick recap

  • Most verbal responses are controlled by more than one variable.
  • Convergent: several variables strengthen one response.
  • Divergent: one variable strengthens several responses.
  • An impure tact is under joint control of an MO and a nonverbal stimulus.
  • Prompted responses are convergently controlled until the prompt is faded.
  • Puns combine formal and thematic sources.

Further reading

  • Michael, J., Palmer, D. C., & Sundberg, M. L. (2011). The multiple control of verbal behavior. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 27(1), 3-22.
  • Skinner, B. F. (1957). Verbal behavior. Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Key terms

Multiple control (Multiple causation)
The fact that a verbal response is usually a function of more than one variable, and that one variable usually affects more than one response. Its two forms are convergent and divergent multiple control.
Convergent multiple control
Multiple control in which a single verbal response is a function of more than one variable at the same time.
Divergent multiple control
Multiple control in which a single variable strengthens several different verbal responses.
Impure tact (Mand-tact)
A verbal response under the joint control of a motivating operation and a nonverbal stimulus, so that it is partly a mand and partly a tact.
Verbal behavior
Behavior whose reinforcement is mediated by a listener whose own behavior has been shaped by a verbal community to respond to it. It is classified by function, not form, and includes speaking, signing, writing and gesturing.
Mand
A verbal operant controlled by a motivating operation and reinforced by the specific consequence it specifies. Mands let a speaker get what they want or get rid of what they do not want.
Tact
A verbal operant controlled by a nonverbal stimulus, such as an object, action, property or event, and reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcement. Private events such as pain can also be tacted.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.20. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Just before lunch, Asha is hungry. Her teacher holds up an apple and asks, 'What's this?' Asha says 'apple.' Which description fits the response best?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Three variables (hunger, the apple and the question) all bear on one response, which is convergent multiple control. Divergent control runs the other way: one variable affecting many responses. Calling it a pure tact or pure mand ignores the other sources.

  2. Question 2A speech therapist says, 'Tell me things that are cold,' and Mateo answers 'ice,' 'snow,' 'freezer' and 'popsicle.' This illustrates:
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. A single verbal stimulus is strengthening several different responses, which is divergent multiple control. Convergent control would be several variables acting on one response. No echoic is involved, because none of the answers repeats the therapist's words.

  3. Question 3Teaching tacts, a therapist shows a picture of a bus and says, 'Say bus.' Nia says 'bus' every time. When the therapist shows the picture and says nothing, Nia says nothing. What is the most likely explanation?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. During training both the echoic prompt and the picture were present, but only the prompt is controlling the response. Transfer of stimulus control has not happened yet, so the prompt needs to be faded while the picture stays (see G.8). It is not an intraverbal controlled by 'say': Nia's 'bus' matches the therapist's spoken word point to point, which marks it as echoic.

  4. Question 4Liam says 'cookie' when he sees a cookie, but only when he hasn't eaten for several hours. After a meal he looks at cookies and says nothing. Which term best describes his 'cookie' response?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. The cookie alone does not evoke the response; it occurs only when food deprivation is also in effect. A response controlled jointly by an MO and a nonverbal stimulus is an impure tact (sometimes called a mand-tact). A pure tact would occur after meals too.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.