The big idea
Every procedure in Domain G has two antecedent levers. The motivating operation (MO) sets how much the reinforcer is worth right now. The discriminative stimulus (SD) signals that the response will be reinforced right now. B.16 and B.17 cover how to tell them apart. This task is about using both on purpose.
A well-designed reinforcement plan fails if the learner has just eaten the snack you are using, and a mand program goes nowhere if the learner already has everything they want. Good procedures plan for motivation and for clear signals before the first trial.
Breaking it down
Managing deprivation and satiation
Deprivation, limited recent access to a reinforcer, usually works as an establishing operation that raises its value. Satiation, plenty of recent access, usually works as an abolishing operation that lowers it. In practice:
- Keep the reinforcers used in teaching unavailable, or at least limited, at other times.
- Use small amounts: a crumb of cookie, 20 seconds with a toy.
- Rotate items, or offer a choice among several.
- Run a brief preference check at the start of the session and again when responding slows.
- Schedule sessions that use edibles before meals, not right after.
Never restrict basic needs such as food, water, sleep or contact with family to create deprivation. Limiting access to a favorite toy is acceptable; skipping a meal is not.
Contriving MOs to teach manding
Mands are controlled by MOs (see B.19), so mand training needs the learner to want something right now. When that motivation does not occur on its own, create it:
- Visible but out of reach: a favorite toy in a clear container the learner cannot open.
- Small portions: one cracker at a time, so each one evokes another request.
- Missing item: a bowl of cereal with no spoon.
- Interrupted chain: block a step in a familiar routine, such as holding the door closed on the way to recess, so the learner needs help to continue.
The missing item and the interrupted chain work through a transitive conditioned MO: one stimulus becomes valuable because it is needed to get another reinforcer. Capture natural MOs too: incidental teaching waits for the learner to show interest, then prompts a mand.
Antecedent changes that alter MOs
The same lever works for problem behavior. If behavior is maintained by escape from hard tasks, make the tasks less aversive:
- intersperse easy items among hard ones;
- offer choices of task or order;
- shorten tasks, then lengthen them gradually (demand fading).
If behavior is maintained by attention, frequent free attention (NCR, see G.3) works as an abolishing operation. If it is maintained by automatic reinforcement, an enriched environment with competing items may reduce it. Each of these changes the value of the reinforcer that maintains the behavior.
The high-probability request sequence
In a high-probability (high-p) request sequence, the instructor gives two to five quick requests the learner almost always follows (“Give me five,” “Touch your nose”), reinforces each one, and then immediately gives the low-probability request (“Put the blocks away”). Keep the high-p requests short and fast, reinforce each compliance with something the learner values, and deliver the low-p request within a few seconds. The effect is usually explained by behavioral momentum (see B.22); some analysts describe it instead as an MO effect that makes the demand context less aversive.
Building in SDs
An SD develops only if reinforcement really is more available when it is present. Make the SD:
- clear and consistent, especially early in teaching;
- present only when reinforcement is available, with an S-delta for times when it is not.
A common use is signaling when requests will be honored during FCT thinning. A green card on the desk means break requests work; a red card means keep working for now. With signals, the learner saves requests for green-card times instead of asking constantly or returning to problem behavior.
The two levers work together in mand training. A mand for juice should depend on wanting juice, not only on seeing the juice box. Vary the items, and check that the learner also requests when the item is out of sight.
Seeing it in practice
| Learner | Goal | MO lever | SD lever |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ana, 3 | Mand for “bubbles” | Bubbles used only in sessions, in short bursts | Therapist holds the wand in view |
| Tobi, 9 | Start math without refusing | Easy facts mixed in; high-p sequence before the worksheet | “First math, then break” card on the desk |
| Marisol, 12 | Request attention at suitable times | Brief free attention while the lanyard is red keeps the MO for attention low | Teacher’s lanyard turned to its green side when available |
| Kwame, 7 | Keep working with a token board | Backup menu rotated daily | Board on the desk only during work periods |
Common mix-ups
- An SD does not create motivation. Holding up a cookie signals availability, but if the learner just ate, little happens.
- Satiation is not extinction. Behavior drops in satiation because the reinforcer is temporarily worth less, not because the contingency ended.
- Contrived MOs must stay ethical. Restrict preferred items, never basic needs.
- A high-p sequence needs reinforcement. Rapid easy requests without reinforced compliance lose much of the effect.
Exam tip: When a well-designed procedure suddenly stops working, check the MO (recent access, satiation) before blaming the procedure. When the goal is a learner who responds only at the right times, the answer is an SD paired with reinforcement and an S-delta paired with its absence.
Quick recap
- MOs set the value of a reinforcer; SDs signal its availability.
- Manage deprivation and satiation with limited access, small amounts and rotation.
- Contrive MOs for manding with out-of-reach items, small portions, missing items and interrupted chains.
- Antecedent MO changes (NCR, easier tasks, enriched environments) reduce problem behavior.
- The high-p sequence and signaled schedules are practical antecedent tools.
Further reading
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 16 and 26.
- Laraway, S., Snycerski, S., Michael, J., & Poling, A. (2003). Motivating operations and terms to describe them: Some further refinements. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 36(3), 407-414.
- Mace, F. C., Hock, M. L., Lalli, J. S., West, B. J., Belfiore, P., Pinter, E., & Brown, D. K. (1988). Behavioral momentum in the treatment of noncompliance. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21(2), 123-141.
Key terms
- Motivating operation (MO)
- An environmental variable that temporarily changes how effective a stimulus is as a reinforcer or punisher (the value-altering effect) and changes how often behavior that has produced that stimulus occurs (the behavior-altering effect).
- Establishing operation (EO)
- A motivating operation that increases the reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus and evokes behavior that has produced that stimulus in the past.
- Abolishing operation (AO)
- A motivating operation that decreases the reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus and abates behavior that has produced that stimulus in the past.
- Deprivation
- A period of limited or no access to a reinforcer. Deprivation usually functions as an establishing operation that raises the reinforcer's value. In practice it is arranged by restricting preferred items or activities, never basic needs.
- Satiation
- A temporary reduction in the effectiveness of a reinforcer after recent, repeated or plentiful access to it. Satiation usually functions as an abolishing operation.
- Discriminative stimulus (SD, S-dee)
- A stimulus in whose presence a particular behavior has been reinforced and in whose absence it has not been reinforced, or has been reinforced less. Because of that history, the behavior is more likely when the stimulus is present. A discriminative stimulus evokes behavior; it does not elicit it.
- High-probability request sequence (High-p sequence, High-probability instructional sequence)
- An antecedent procedure in which two to five quick requests that the learner usually follows are presented and reinforced, followed immediately by a request the learner usually does not follow. Compliance with the low-probability request tends to increase.
- Transitive conditioned motivating operation (CMO-T, Transitive CMO)
- A stimulus that makes some other stimulus effective as a reinforcer, usually because that other stimulus is needed to obtain a further reinforcer, and evokes behavior that has produced it.
Check yourself
4 questions on G.5. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: C. An hour of free bubbles just before the session is a satiation operation, which temporarily lowers the value of bubbles and the behavior that has produced them. Nothing suggests the mand stopped producing bubbles, so extinction does not fit. Monday's 20 mands show she has the skill; Tuesday's drop is about motivation.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Yogurt without a spoon makes the spoon valuable because it is needed to get the yogurt, a transitive conditioned MO. Asking 'What is this?' sets up a tact, not a mand. Giving the spoon freely removes any reason to ask, and 'Say spoon' with the spoon already in hand evokes an echoic with no motivation behind it.
Show the answer
Answer: C. Several quick, easy requests that Tobi almost always follows, each reinforced, followed immediately by the low-probability request, is a high-p sequence. Nothing is removed on a time schedule, so it is not noncontingent escape. Clapping is not incompatible with refusing; it is used to build momentum before the hard request.
Show the answer
Answer: B. A signal correlated with reinforcement (an SD) and another correlated with its absence (an S-delta) lets Marisol learn when to mand, which supports thinning without a return of problem behavior. Stopping all reinforcement for mands is extinction of the replacement behavior and invites resurgence. An unsignaled ratio gives her no way to tell when manding will work.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.