cumulative

F.3 Assessing skill strengths and areas of need

What the task asks: Choose, design and interpret assessments that show a client's current skill strengths and the skills they most need to learn.

Behavior Assessment5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Before deciding what to teach, find out what the person can already do. A skill assessment maps a client’s repertoire: which skills are fluent, which are emerging and which are missing. Strengths matter as much as gaps. They show what can be built on, what can serve as a prerequisite and where the client already succeeds.

No single tool does this well alone. Most behavior analysts combine a published assessment, interviews with the people who know the client, and direct observation of skills where they are needed.

Breaking it down

Criterion-referenced vs. norm-referenced

A criterion-referenced assessment compares performance with a fixed standard: can the client do this skill to the stated level or not? The result points straight to teaching targets. Most curriculum tools used in ABA work this way.

A norm-referenced assessment compares performance with a standardization sample of same-age peers and reports standard scores or percentiles. It shows how far a person is from typical development, which funders and schools often require, but it rarely tells you exactly what to teach next.

Criterion-referencedNorm-referenced
Compares the client withA set mastery standardA sample of peers
Typical outputSkills mastered, emerging, absentStandard scores, percentiles, age equivalents
Best forChoosing and tracking teaching targetsEligibility, describing overall functioning
Criterion-referenced Each skill against a mastery standard Requests items Mastered Follows directions Mastered Names pictures Emerging Answers questions Not yet Answers: what to teach next Norm-referenced One score against same-age peers 55 70 85 100 115 130 145 Standard score This learner: 70, about the 2nd percentile Answers: how far from typical
One learner, two kinds of result. The criterion-referenced view lists skills against a mastery standard and points to what to teach. The norm-referenced view places one score among same-age peers: a standard score of 70 is two standard deviations below the mean.

Curriculum-based tools common in practice

A curriculum-based assessment draws its items from a skill sequence, so each item is also a possible teaching target. Brief, neutral descriptions of tools you will meet:

  • VB-MAPP (Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program; Sundberg): language and learning milestones across three developmental levels, roughly birth to 48 months, organized around Skinner’s analysis of verbal behavior, with a barriers assessment and a transition assessment.
  • ABLLS-R (Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills, Revised; Partington): a detailed checklist of language, academic, self-help and motor skills used to track progress over time.
  • AFLS (Assessment of Functional Living Skills; Partington and Mueller): functional skills across protocols such as basic living, home, community, school, vocational and independent living.
  • Essentials for Living (McGreevy, Fry and Cornwall): for children and adults with limited repertoires, with emphasis on a core set of skills such as making requests, waiting, accepting “no” and tolerating health and safety routines.
  • PEAK (Promoting the Emergence of Advanced Knowledge; Dixon): modules for direct teaching, generalization, stimulus equivalence and transformation of stimulus function, drawing on relational frame theory.

Each has its own focus, age range and evidence base. Research on the reliability and validity of several of these tools is still developing, so treat their results as a guide to teaching rather than a precise measurement.

Adaptive behavior measures

Adaptive behavior means the everyday skills a person needs to function independently: communicating, caring for oneself, getting along with others. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales are a widely used norm-referenced measure, completed through a caregiver or teacher interview or rating form. Because they rely on report, they are indirect measures, and administering and interpreting them takes training (Standard 1.05, Practicing within Scope of Competence).

Direct observation and probes

Published tools sample skills, often at a table. Direct observation shows whether a skill occurs where it matters: does Nadia ask for help in class, not just in the clinic? Probes (test trials without prompts or reinforcement) check whether a skill is present before teaching. For chained skills, a task analysis can be assessed with the single-opportunity method, which stops at the first error, or the multiple-opportunity method, which completes any missed step for the learner and keeps assessing.

Water on Wet hands Soap Scrub Rinse Dry Single opportunity 2 of 6 steps not tested not tested not tested Multiple opportunity 4 of 6 steps Assessment ends at the first error Analyst does the step; testing continues
The same handwashing performance scored both ways. The single-opportunity method stops at the first error, so only 2 of 6 steps are credited. The multiple-opportunity method completes the missed step and tests the rest, revealing 4 of 6.

Designing and evaluating the assessment

A good skill assessment matches the client’s age, goals and settings (an adult needs functional living skills more than a preschool curriculum), uses more than one source of information, is repeated over time to measure progress, and feeds directly into prioritized goals (F.8) and measurable objectives (H.1).

Seeing it in practice

ClientQuestionUseful assessment
Elias, 3, says few wordsWhich language skills should come first?VB-MAPP milestones plus observation of requests at home
Zainab, 17, preparing to leave schoolCan she manage daily routines and a job?AFLS protocols, with observation in the community and at a work placement
Ji-woo, 7, school needs eligibility dataHow does his functioning compare with peers?Vineland interview with parent and teacher, interpreted by a trained professional
Marcus, 28, limited communication, distress during hygiene routinesWhich core skills will most improve daily life?Essentials for Living, with observation of hygiene routines

Common mix-ups

  • Age equivalents are not teaching targets. “Functions like a 3-year-old” says little about what to teach. Describe specific skills.
  • A developmental sequence is not a norm. Tools ordered by typical development, like the VB-MAPP milestones, are still interpreted as criterion-referenced; they do not compare the client with a standardization sample.
  • A checklist score is not a fluent skill. A skill marked present in a clinic may not occur at home. Check generalization.
  • Do not just teach the next item. Assessment items sample a wider repertoire. Picking goals only because they come next on a list can miss what matters most to the client.

Exam tip: If the question asks how a client compares with same-age peers, look for a norm-referenced tool. If it asks what to teach next or whether a skill meets a standard, look for a criterion-referenced one.

Quick recap

  • Assess strengths as well as needs.
  • Criterion-referenced tools compare with a mastery standard; norm-referenced tools compare with peers.
  • VB-MAPP, ABLLS-R, AFLS, Essentials for Living and PEAK are curriculum-based tools with different focuses.
  • The Vineland is a norm-referenced adaptive behavior measure based on informant report.
  • Combine published tools with interviews and direct observation in natural settings.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 3.

Key terms

Criterion-referenced assessment
An assessment that compares a person's performance with a fixed standard of mastery for each skill, rather than with other people, so the results show which skills are present, emerging or absent.
Norm-referenced assessment
A standardized assessment that compares a person's performance with that of a sample of peers, usually of the same age, and reports results as standard scores, percentiles or age equivalents.
Curriculum-based assessment
An assessment whose items come from a specific curriculum or skill sequence, so that each skill tested is also a possible teaching target. Most curriculum tools used in ABA are interpreted as criterion-referenced.
Adaptive behavior
The everyday skills a person needs to meet the demands of daily life and function independently, such as communication, self-care, home and community living, and social skills.

Check yourself

5 questions on F.3. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A funder asks how a 5-year-old client's communication, daily living and social skills compare with those of other children the same age. Which assessment best answers this question?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Comparing a person with same-age peers is what norm-referenced tools are built for. A curriculum assessment like the ABLLS-R compares performance with a mastery standard for each skill, which is useful for choosing targets but does not show standing relative to peers.

  2. Question 2Which statement best describes a criterion-referenced assessment?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A criterion-referenced tool asks whether the learner meets a stated standard for each skill. Comparing with peers, percentiles, standard scores and age equivalents are all features of norm-referenced assessment.

  3. Question 3An analyst assesses Dana's handwashing using a 10-step task analysis. When Dana does not complete step 3, the analyst completes it for her and then lets her continue with step 4. Which assessment method is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. In the multiple-opportunity method, the assessor completes any missed step and keeps assessing, so every step is tested. In the single-opportunity method, assessment stops at the first error. Backward chaining and prompting are teaching procedures, not assessment methods.

  4. Question 4Zainab, 17, has mastered most items on an early-learner language assessment. Her family wants her to shop, cook simple meals and ride the bus on her own. Which assessment best fits the next step?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Zainab's goals concern daily living and community skills, so a functional living skills assessment, checked by observing her in the community, fits best. Repeating an early-learner tool would measure skills she has already mastered and miss the ones her family cares about.

  5. Question 5A published checklist scores Omar, 9, as able to ask for help. At school, staff report that he never asks for help and leaves his seat instead when work is hard. What should the analyst conclude?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. A skill shown in a structured assessment may not occur where it is needed. Direct observation at school is the way to find out, and the skill may need teaching there. Discarding the checklist ignores useful information about what Omar can do under some conditions.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.