cumulative

B.12 Recognizing stimulus control

What the task asks: Recognize examples of stimulus control, where a behavior occurs more often or differently in the presence of a particular antecedent stimulus because of a history of differential consequences.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

People do not do the same thing everywhere. You answer a ringing phone but not a silent one, go at green lights but not red ones, and tell different jokes to your grandmother than to your friends. When an antecedent stimulus changes how often, how quickly, how long or how forcefully a behavior occurs, that behavior is under stimulus control.

Stimulus control is not built into the stimulus. It comes from history: the behavior has been reinforced in the presence of one stimulus and not in the presence of another. Much of what teaching aims for, from reading a word to following a schedule, is the right behavior under control of the right stimulus.

Breaking it down

The three-term contingency

Operant behavior is analyzed as a three-term contingency: an antecedent stimulus, the behavior that occurs in its presence, and the consequence that follows. Stimulus control appears when the consequence depends on the antecedent, so that the same behavior pays off in one situation and not in another.

Discriminative stimulus

A discriminative stimulus (SD) is a stimulus in whose presence a behavior has been reinforced, and in whose absence it has not (or has been reinforced less). Because of that history, the behavior becomes more likely when the SD is present. The SD signals that reinforcement is available for that behavior.

An SD evokes behavior; it does not elicit it. A green light does not force a driver to go the way a puff of air forces a blink (see B.3). It makes going more likely because going has paid off in its presence.

S-delta

An S-delta (SΔ) is a stimulus in whose presence the behavior has not been reinforced. The behavior becomes less likely when the S-delta is present. An S-delta signals that reinforcement is unavailable; it does not signal punishment. A “Closed” sign is an S-delta for pushing on a shop door.

A third kind is sometimes added: a discriminative stimulus for punishment (SDp), in whose presence the behavior has been punished. For many drivers, a police car on the highway is an SDp for speeding.

How stimulus control develops

Stimulus control develops through differential reinforcement: the behavior is reinforced when the SD is present and not reinforced (extinction) when the S-delta is present. Over time the behavior occurs reliably in the presence of the SD and rarely in its absence. A behavior under this kind of control is a discriminated operant.

Control can show up in any dimension of behavior. In the presence of the SD, the response may occur more often, start sooner (shorter latency), last longer or be more forceful. How sharply responding differs between the SD and other stimuli is the subject of B.13 (discrimination), and responding to stimuli that resemble the SD is covered in B.14 (generalization).

Faulty stimulus control

Stimulus control can develop to the wrong stimulus. A learner who answers “red” correctly only when the teacher glances at the red card is under control of the glance, not the color. Checking that the intended stimulus, and only that stimulus, controls the response is part of good teaching (see G.6 and G.7).

Seeing it in practice

SettingAntecedentBehaviorWhy control exists
RoadGreen light vs. red lightDriving through the intersectionGoing has been reinforced on green and not on red
HomeOlder sister present vs. older brother presentA child asks to play video gamesThe sister has said yes; the brother has not
School“Raise your hand if you know”Hand-raisingHand-raising has been reinforced after that question
WorkplaceThe manager is in the office (SDp)An employee stops browsing social mediaBrowsing has been reprimanded when the manager was present
ClinicThe printed word catA learner says “cat”Saying “cat” has been reinforced in the presence of that word

A clinic example. Hiroshi, age 5, grabs toys from peers. His therapist teaches him to say “My turn, please.” At first he says it to everyone, including peers who are still busy playing and never hand anything over. The therapist arranges for peers to hand over a toy when they have finished with it and put it down, and not while they are still playing. Within a few weeks, Hiroshi asks mostly when a peer has put a toy down. A peer finishing with a toy has become an SD for asking. A peer in the middle of play has become an S-delta.

Antecedent Behavior Consequence Over time SD Peer put toy down "My turn, please" Gets toy Asks more SΔ Peer still playing "My turn, please" No toy Asks less
Differential reinforcement for Hiroshi. The request is the same in both rows; it produces a toy only when a peer has put the toy down, so that situation becomes an SD and a peer still playing becomes an S-delta.
Toy put down (SD)Still playing (S-delta)0255075100123456789101112SessionsAsked (% of chances)
Hiroshi's asking across training. At first he asks in both situations. As only requests to a finished peer pay off, asking stays high in the SD and drops away in the S-delta: stimulus control.

Common mix-ups

  • SD vs. conditioned stimulus. A conditioned stimulus elicits a respondent because of pairing. An SD evokes an operant because of differential reinforcement.
  • S-delta vs. SDp. An S-delta signals no reinforcement; an SDp signals punishment. Both make the behavior less likely, for different reasons.
  • SD vs. motivating operation. An SD signals that a reinforcer is available. A motivating operation changes how valuable that reinforcer is (see B.16 and B.17).
  • Stimulus control is a relation, not a stimulus. It describes the link between a stimulus and a behavior, and it exists only when responding actually differs with the stimulus.
  • Not every antecedent is an SD. A stimulus earns that label only after the behavior has been reinforced more in its presence than in its absence.

Exam tip: Look for a difference across conditions. If the behavior happens with one person, place or cue and not with another, and the difference comes from past consequences, it is stimulus control.

Quick recap

  • Stimulus control: a behavior changes in the presence of an antecedent stimulus because of past differential consequences.
  • SD: the behavior has been reinforced in its presence. S-delta: the behavior has not been reinforced in its presence.
  • Differential reinforcement builds stimulus control.
  • SDs evoke operant behavior; conditioned stimuli elicit respondents.
  • Faulty stimulus control occurs when an unintended stimulus gains control.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 17.
  • Michael, J. (1982). Distinguishing between discriminative and motivational functions of stimuli. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 149-155.

Key terms

Stimulus control
A relation in which the rate, latency, duration or intensity of a behavior changes in the presence of a particular antecedent stimulus. It develops when the behavior has been reinforced in the presence of that stimulus and not reinforced, or reinforced less, in its absence.
Discriminative stimulus (SD, S-dee)
A stimulus in whose presence a particular behavior has been reinforced and in whose absence it has not been reinforced, or has been reinforced less. Because of that history, the behavior is more likely when the stimulus is present. A discriminative stimulus evokes behavior; it does not elicit it.
S-delta (SΔ, Stimulus delta)
A stimulus in whose presence a particular behavior has not been reinforced. Because of that history, the behavior is less likely when the S-delta is present. It signals that reinforcement is unavailable; it does not signal punishment.
Three-term contingency (A-B-C contingency)
The basic unit of operant analysis: an antecedent stimulus, the behavior that occurs in its presence, and the consequence that follows the behavior. Stimulus control develops when the consequence differs depending on the antecedent.
Discriminated operant
An operant behavior that occurs more often in the presence of a particular discriminative stimulus than in its absence, because of a history of differential reinforcement. In other words, an operant under stimulus control.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.12. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Rania, age 9, often asks her older sister Camila to play video games with her but almost never asks her brother Yusuf. Camila usually says yes, and Yusuf always says no. For asking to play, Camila is functioning as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Asking has been reinforced in Camila's presence and not in Yusuf's, so Camila's presence evokes asking. That makes her a discriminative stimulus, and Yusuf an S-delta. A motivating operation would change how much Rania wants to play, not where asking pays off.

  2. Question 2At a coffee shop, customers rarely push the door when a 'Closed' sign is showing, because pushing has never opened the door while the sign was up. The 'Closed' sign is best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Pushing has not been reinforced in the sign's presence, so the sign makes pushing less likely: it is an S-delta. A discriminative stimulus for punishment would signal that pushing had been punished, but pushing a locked door simply does not work.

  3. Question 3Which observation best shows that a learner's labeling of colors is under the intended stimulus control?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Intended stimulus control means the color itself controls the response, whoever presents it and whatever else is happening. Answering only when the teacher glances at the card shows faulty stimulus control by the glance, and saying 'blue' to every card shows no discrimination.

  4. Question 4An employee works steadily when the supervisor is in the room and checks a phone often when the supervisor leaves. Phone-checking has been reprimanded only when the supervisor was present. What does this show?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The behavior differs depending on an antecedent (the supervisor's presence) because of a history of different consequences in that stimulus's presence. Here the supervisor's presence works as a discriminative stimulus for punishment of phone-checking. That is stimulus control, not a change in how valuable the phone is.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.