cumulative

B.10 Concurrent, multiple, mixed, and chained schedules

What the task asks: Tell apart compound schedules (concurrent, multiple, mixed and chained, plus tandem) by whether their components run together or in sequence and whether each component is signaled.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Real environments rarely run one simple schedule at a time. A compound schedule combines two or more basic schedules (see B.9), including extinction. The compound schedules on the exam differ on just two questions:

  1. Do the components run at the same time (concurrent) or one after another (multiple, mixed, chained, tandem)?
  2. Is each component signaled by its own stimulus (multiple, chained) or unsignaled (mixed, tandem)?

Get those two questions right and the rest is detail.

Breaking it down

Concurrent schedules: at the same time

In a concurrent schedule, two or more schedules operate at the same time and independently, each for a different response or option, and the person can switch freely between them. In the lab, a pigeon might have two keys, one on VI 30 s and one on VI 60 s.

Concurrent schedules are how behavior analysts study choice. People tend to divide their responding among options in proportion to the reinforcement each provides, a relation described by the matching law (see B.23). In applied work, problem behavior and an appropriate alternative are almost always on concurrent schedules. If yelling gets attention faster than raising a hand, yelling tends to win.

Multiple and mixed schedules: taking turns

In a multiple schedule, two or more basic schedules alternate, usually in random order, and each is correlated with its own discriminative stimulus that is present while that component is in effect. Each component delivers its own reinforcement. For example, when a light is green, lever presses are reinforced on FR 10; when it is red, presses are on extinction. Responding becomes high under green and low under red, which is stimulus control (see B.12).

A mixed schedule is the same arrangement with no signals. The components still alternate, but nothing tells the person which one is in effect, so responding cannot track the change in conditions as well.

Multiple schedules are common in practice. After functional communication training (FCT), many teams use a signal, such as a colored card or wristband, to show when requests will be honored and when they will not. That arrangement helps a learner wait without returning to problem behavior.

Chained and tandem schedules: in sequence

In a chained schedule, two or more basic schedules occur in a fixed order, each signaled by its own stimulus. Completing one component produces the stimulus for the next, and the terminal reinforcer comes only after the final component. Each new stimulus does two jobs: it is a conditioned reinforcer for finishing the last component and a discriminative stimulus for the next one. Example: a pigeon pecks a red key 20 times (FR 20), which turns the key green; then the first peck after one minute on the green key (FI 1 min) produces food.

A tandem schedule is the same sequence with no signals. Each component must still be completed in order before reinforcement, but the stimulus never changes, so nothing marks progress.

Chained schedules are the schedule-level version of the behavior chains taught in G.12.

Two less common schedules

In a conjunctive schedule, reinforcement requires meeting two requirements, such as at least 10 responses and at least 2 minutes elapsed. In an alternative schedule, reinforcement follows whichever requirement is met first.

The comparison in one table

ScheduleComponents occurSignaled?Reinforcement
ConcurrentAt the same time, for different responsesNot the defining featureEach option has its own
MultipleIn alternationYesWithin each component
MixedIn alternationNoWithin each component
ChainedIn a fixed sequenceYesOnly after the final component
TandemIn a fixed sequenceNoOnly after the final component
Reinforcer Signal 1 Signal 2 No signal Concurrent Same time Key A: VI 30 s Key B: VI 60 s Multiple Take turns Green: FR 10 Red: EXT Green: FR 10 Red: EXT Mixed Take turns FR 10 EXT FR 10 EXT Chained In sequence Red key: FR 20 Green key: FI 1 min Tandem In sequence FR 20 FI 1 min
The same comparison on a timeline. Concurrent options run side by side; multiple and mixed components take turns, each on its own schedule; chained and tandem components run in order and pay off only at the end. Mixed and tandem look the same throughout because nothing signals the components.

Seeing it in practice

  • Classroom, concurrent. During free time, Jamal can build with blocks, color or chat with a friend. Each option produces reinforcement on its own schedule, and he spends the most time on the richest one.
  • Clinic, multiple. A therapist, Brooke, wears a green wristband when she is free to respond to requests and a red one when she is busy with paperwork. Requests are honored under green and not under red. Within a few sessions, the learner, Zoe, asks mostly when the band is green.
  • Same clinic, mixed. If the therapist alternates between free and busy with no wristband, Zoe’s asking cannot track the conditions. She may keep asking throughout and may return to problem behavior.
  • Workplace, chained. To be paid for a delivery, a driver loads the van until a checklist turns green, drives until the app shows “Arrived”, then collects a signature until the app shows “Delivered”. Each screen signals the next step, and payment comes only after the last.
  • Same workplace, tandem. The driver completes the same steps, but nothing confirms each one until payment arrives.

Common mix-ups

  • Multiple vs. mixed. Same alternating structure. The only difference is whether a stimulus signals each component.
  • Chained vs. tandem. Same fixed sequence. The only difference is whether a stimulus signals each component.
  • Multiple vs. chained. In a multiple schedule, each component produces its own reinforcement and the order is usually random. In a chained schedule, the order is fixed and only the last component ends in the terminal reinforcer.
  • Concurrent vs. multiple. Concurrent options are available together; multiple components take turns.
  • Chained here is a schedule, not a teaching method. Forward, backward and total-task chaining are covered in G.12.

Exam tip: Look for the signal and the sequence. Options available together: concurrent. Components taking turns, each with its own reinforcer: multiple (signaled) or mixed (unsignaled). A fixed sequence ending in one reinforcer: chained (signaled) or tandem (unsignaled).

Quick recap

  • Concurrent: two or more schedules at once, for different responses; the basis of choice.
  • Multiple: alternating components, each with its own discriminative stimulus. Mixed: the same, unsignaled.
  • Chained: a fixed sequence, each component signaled, reinforcement only at the end. Tandem: the same, unsignaled.
  • Conjunctive schedules require both requirements; alternative schedules require whichever comes first.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 13.
  • Hanley, G. P., Iwata, B. A., & Thompson, R. H. (2001). Reinforcement schedule thinning following treatment with functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 34(1), 17-38.

Key terms

Compound schedule
A schedule that combines two or more basic schedules, such as FR, VI or extinction. Concurrent, multiple, mixed, chained and tandem schedules are compound schedules; they differ in whether the components run at the same time or in sequence, and in whether each component is signaled.
Concurrent schedule (conc)
A compound schedule in which two or more schedules operate at the same time and independently, each for a different response or option. Concurrent schedules arrange choice, and the way responding is divided among the options is described by the matching law.
Multiple schedule (mult)
A compound schedule in which two or more basic schedules alternate, usually in random order, and each one is correlated with its own discriminative stimulus that is present while that component is in effect. Each component delivers its own reinforcement.
Mixed schedule (mix)
A compound schedule that works like a multiple schedule, with two or more basic schedules alternating (usually in random order), except that no stimulus signals which component is in effect.
Chained schedule (chain)
A compound schedule in which two or more basic schedules occur in a fixed order, each signaled by its own stimulus. Completing one component produces the stimulus for the next, which acts as a conditioned reinforcer, and the terminal reinforcer is delivered only after the final component.
Tandem schedule (tand)
A compound schedule that works like a chained schedule, with two or more basic schedules in a fixed order and reinforcement only after the last one, except that no stimuli signal the components.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.10. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1In a lab, a red light means lever presses are reinforced on FR 5, and a blue light means presses are on extinction. The two conditions alternate in random order. Which schedule is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Two basic schedules alternate, each with its own signal, and each delivers its own reinforcement (or none), which defines a multiple schedule. Without the lights it would be a mixed schedule, and a chained schedule would require a fixed order ending in one terminal reinforcer.

  2. Question 2A rat must complete 10 lever presses and then press once more after 30 seconds have passed to receive food. No light, sound or other stimulus changes between the two requirements. Which schedule is in effect?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Two requirements must be met in a fixed order before reinforcement, and nothing signals the change from one to the next. That is a tandem schedule. If a stimulus marked each component, it would be a chained schedule.

  3. Question 3During recess, Diego can play basketball with peers or swing by himself. Each activity produces reinforcement on its own schedule, and he can switch between them at any time. This arrangement is best described as a:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Two schedules operate at the same time, independently, for two different responses, and Diego chooses between them. That is a concurrent schedule. In a multiple schedule the components take turns rather than being available together.

  4. Question 4After functional communication training, Mr. Adeyemi puts a green card on his desk when he will respond to requests for attention and a red card when he will not. Compared with alternating the two conditions without any cards, what do the cards change?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Alternating conditions with no signal is a mixed schedule. Adding a distinct stimulus for each component turns it into a multiple schedule, which lets the learner's requests come under stimulus control. The conditions still alternate, so nothing about order or simultaneous options has changed.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.