The big idea
Skinner (1957) treated language as behavior and called it verbal behavior: behavior reinforced through the actions of a listener whose responses have been shaped by a verbal community. Verbal behavior is classified by function, not form. The word “water” can be four different operants depending on what controls it.
Each elementary verbal operant is defined by three things: the antecedent that controls it (an MO, a nonverbal stimulus or a verbal stimulus), how the response relates to any verbal stimulus, and the kind of consequence that follows. Learn the controlling variables and the categories sort themselves.
Breaking it down
Two tools for verbal stimuli
- Point-to-point correspondence: the beginning, middle and end of the response match the beginning, middle and end of the verbal stimulus. Hearing “cat” and saying “cat” has it. So does hearing “cat” and writing C-A-T.
- Formal similarity: the stimulus and the response are in the same sense mode (both heard, both seen, both signed) and physically resemble each other. Hearing “cat” and saying “cat” has it. Seeing CAT and saying “cat” does not.
The operants
- Mand: controlled by an MO and reinforced by the specific consequence it specifies. A thirsty child says “juice” and gets juice. The mand is the only operant that directly benefits the speaker in this way.
- Tact: controlled by a nonverbal stimulus (an object, action, property or event, including private events such as pain) and reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcement such as praise. A child sees a plane and says “airplane!”
- Echoic: controlled by a vocal verbal stimulus, with point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity. The therapist says “banana” and the learner says “banana.”
- Intraverbal: controlled by a verbal stimulus without point-to-point correspondence. “How are you?” evokes “Fine.” “Twinkle, twinkle, little…” evokes “star.” Answering questions and conversation are mostly intraverbal.
- Textual: controlled by a written verbal stimulus, with a vocal response. Point-to-point correspondence, no formal similarity. This is reading aloud, and it does not require understanding what is read.
- Transcription: controlled by a spoken verbal stimulus, with a written, typed or finger-spelled response. Point-to-point correspondence, no formal similarity. Taking dictation and spelling a dictated word are transcription.
- Copying a text: controlled by a written verbal stimulus, with a written response. Point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity. Copying the homework assignment off the board is an example.
Every operant except the mand is usually reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcers, not by the specific thing named. Jack Michael later grouped the operants with formal similarity (echoic, copying a text) as duplics and those with point-to-point correspondence but no formal similarity (textual, transcription) as codics.
The autoclitic, briefly
An autoclitic is secondary verbal behavior that depends on the speaker’s own verbal behavior and modifies how the listener reacts to it. “I think it’s raining” tells the listener something different from “It’s raining.” Qualifiers, negation and grammatical ordering all have autoclitic functions. For the exam, recognizing the term is usually enough.
Listener behavior is something else
Touching the ball when told “touch the ball” is listener behavior (often called receptive language). It is a discrimination, not one of the speaker operants above.
Seeing it in practice
One word, many operants. Ava, age 4, says “dog” in each row.
| What happens | Controlling antecedent | Consequence | Operant |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ava wants her stuffed dog, which is in her room, and says “dog.” Dad brings it. | MO | The stuffed dog | Mand |
| On a walk, Ava sees a dog and says “dog.” Dad says, “Yes, a big dog!” | Nonverbal stimulus | Praise | Tact |
| The therapist says “dog,” and Ava says “dog.” | Vocal stimulus; point-to-point and formal similarity | Praise | Echoic |
| The therapist asks, “What says woof?” Ava says “dog.” | Verbal stimulus; no point-to-point correspondence | Praise | Intraverbal |
| Ava sees the printed word DOG in a book and says “dog.” | Written stimulus; no formal similarity | Praise | Textual |
| The teacher says “dog,” and Ava writes D-O-G. | Spoken stimulus; written response | Praise | Transcription |
| Ava writes DOG after seeing it on the whiteboard. | Written stimulus; written response | Praise | Copying a text |
Common mix-ups
- Function, not form. The same word can be any operant. Find the antecedent and the consequence.
- Mand vs. tact with the item present. If the item is visible and the response produces the item, an MO is probably involved. Many real responses are controlled by both (see B.20).
- Echoic vs. intraverbal. Both are controlled by verbal stimuli. Point-to-point correspondence makes it echoic.
- Textual is not comprehension. Reading words aloud correctly says nothing about whether the reader understood them.
- Transcription vs. copying a text. Transcription starts with a spoken stimulus; copying starts with a written one.
- Receptive responding is not a speaker operant. “Show me the cup” tests a listener discrimination.
Exam tip: Start with the antecedent. An MO alone points to a mand. A nonverbal thing points to a tact. A verbal stimulus means checking correspondence: same words in the same mode is echoic or copying; same words in a different mode is textual or transcription; different words is intraverbal.
Quick recap
- Verbal operants are classified by controlling variables, not by the words used.
- Mand: MO and specific reinforcement. Tact: nonverbal stimulus and generalized reinforcement.
- Echoic and copying a text have point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity.
- Textual and transcription have point-to-point correspondence without formal similarity.
- Intraverbals are controlled by verbal stimuli without point-to-point correspondence.
- Autoclitics modify the listener’s reaction to the speaker’s other verbal behavior.
Further reading
- Skinner, B. F. (1957). Verbal behavior. Appleton-Century-Crofts.
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 18.
Key terms
- Mand
- A verbal operant controlled by a motivating operation and reinforced by the specific consequence it specifies. Mands let a speaker get what they want or get rid of what they do not want.
- Tact
- A verbal operant controlled by a nonverbal stimulus, such as an object, action, property or event, and reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcement. Private events such as pain can also be tacted.
- Echoic
- A verbal operant controlled by a vocal verbal stimulus, in which the response has point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity with the stimulus. It is reinforced by generalized conditioned reinforcement.
- Intraverbal
- A verbal operant controlled by a verbal stimulus with which the response has no point-to-point correspondence. Answering questions, filling in the words of songs and most conversation are intraverbal.
- Textual (Textual behavior, Reading aloud)
- A verbal operant controlled by a written verbal stimulus, with a vocal response that has point-to-point correspondence but no formal similarity with the text. Textual behavior does not require comprehension.
- Transcription (Taking dictation)
- A verbal operant controlled by a spoken verbal stimulus, with a written, typed or finger-spelled response that has point-to-point correspondence but no formal similarity with the stimulus.
- Point-to-point correspondence
- A relation between a verbal stimulus and a response in which the beginning, middle and end of the response match the beginning, middle and end of the stimulus. Echoics, textual behavior, transcription and copying a text have it; intraverbals do not.
- Formal similarity
- A relation in which a stimulus and a response share the same sense mode (both heard, both seen or both signed) and physically resemble each other. It is a feature of echoics, copying a text and imitation.
Check yourself
4 questions on B.19. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: C. No nonverbal or verbal stimulus is controlling the response, and it produces the specific item it names. That points to control by an MO, which makes it a mand. A tact would need popcorn (or something about popcorn) to be present.
Show the answer
Answer: C. The verbal stimulus is spoken and the response is written. The two correspond point to point but are in different sense modes, so there is no formal similarity. That is transcription. Copying a text would require a written stimulus.
Show the answer
Answer: D. The response is controlled by a nonverbal stimulus (the picture) and followed by generalized conditioned reinforcement (praise), which defines a tact. Aaron does not receive the car, so it is not a mand, and no verbal stimulus was presented, so it is neither an echoic nor an intraverbal.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Both echoics and intraverbals are controlled by verbal stimuli. An echoic matches the stimulus point to point ('go' to 'go'), while an intraverbal does not ('go' to 'ready, set'). Both are vocal here, so the sense mode does not separate them.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.