cumulative

B.18 Rule-governed vs. contingency-shaped behavior

What the task asks: Tell apart behavior controlled by verbal descriptions of contingencies from behavior shaped by direct contact with consequences, and recognize each in an example.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

There are two ways to learn not to touch a hot stove. You can touch it, or someone can tell you, “Don’t touch that, it’s hot.” The first is contingency-shaped behavior: behavior acquired and maintained through direct contact with its consequences. The second is rule-governed behavior: behavior controlled by a verbal description of a contingency (Skinner, 1969).

Rules are why people can profit from other people’s experience. They let someone save for retirement, follow a recipe or wear a seatbelt without ever having crashed. They also carry a known cost: people who follow a rule often keep following it after the world has changed.

Breaking it down

Rules as contingency-specifying stimuli

A rule is a verbal stimulus that describes a contingency: some or all of the antecedent, the behavior and the consequence. Skinner called rules contingency-specifying stimuli. “If you finish your homework, you can play outside” names a behavior and a consequence. “When the light turns green, cross” names an antecedent and a behavior. Rules can come from other people (instructions, advice, laws, signs) or from the person’s own verbal behavior, as with the self-rule “If I study for an hour tonight, I’ll be ready.”

Rules do not work exactly like SDs. “When the timer beeps, take the bread out” gives the beep a function it did not have, and the listener may respond to the beep hours later without ever having been reinforced in its presence. Schlinger and Blakely (1987) call this a function-altering effect.

Contingency-shaped behavior

Contingency-shaped behavior is learned from the consequences themselves: riding a bike, the timing of a joke, the feel of a good free throw. The person often cannot describe the contingency in words. Most behavior of nonhuman animals and young children is contingency-shaped.

Why rules matter

Rules help most when the natural consequences:

  • are delayed (exercise, saving money),
  • are small but cumulative (one cigarette, one extra snack),
  • are improbable but serious (seatbelts, smoke alarms), or
  • would be dangerous to learn by experience (traffic, electricity).

They are also fast. One instruction can replace dozens of trials of trial and error.

Insensitivity to changing contingencies

Rule-governed behavior tends to be less sensitive to changes in the actual contingencies. In laboratory studies, people given instructions about how to respond often kept responding as instructed after the schedule changed, while people whose responding had been shaped adjusted more readily. In practice, a staff member keeps using a procedure the supervisor described two years ago, or a person following the rule “If I go to the party, it will be awful” stays home and never contacts the real consequences. This is a tendency, not a law. It depends on the person’s history with rules.

010203040506070051015202530MinutesSchedule changesFollowed instructionsShaped by consequencesResponses per minute
Illustrative data in the style of those laboratory studies. When the schedule changes so that fast responding no longer pays off, responding shaped by consequences slows down, while instructed responding carries on as before.

Why people follow rules: pliance and tracking

Hayes and colleagues, working within relational frame theory, describe types of rule following:

  • Pliance: following a rule because of socially mediated consequences for doing what the rule says. The rule giver checks, praises or reprimands.
  • Tracking: following a rule because the rule has matched the way the world actually works. “Take the side road; it’s faster” is followed because it gets you there faster.

Seeing it in practice

ExampleTypeWhy
A new behavior technician delivers a token within three seconds of each correct response because the written protocol says to.Rule-governedControlled by a written description of the contingency
A veteran therapist, Rania, slows her pace when a learner shows subtle signs of fatigue, but cannot say exactly what cues she uses.Contingency-shapedShaped by years of consequences; hard to verbalize
A teen hears that texting while driving causes crashes and stops texting at the wheel.Rule-governed (tracking)Controlled by a description of a rare, serious consequence
Yusuf, age 7, wipes his feet at the door because his father checks and praises him for it.Rule-governed (pliance)Controlled by the father’s consequences for following the rule
A cook learns how much salt a soup needs by tasting it.Contingency-shapedShaped by the taste of each batch
A driver keeps following a navigation app’s directions onto a road closed for construction.Rule-governedShows insensitivity to the changed contingency

Common mix-ups

  • Rule-governed behavior is still operant behavior. People follow rules because following rules has been reinforced in the past. The difference is what controls the behavior right now.
  • Self-rules count. A rule does not have to come from someone else.
  • Not every SD is a rule. A rule is verbal and describes a contingency. A red light is an SD; “stop at red lights” is a rule.
  • Neither type is better. Rules are fast and safe; shaped behavior is fine-tuned and adjusts to change.
  • Behavior can switch types. A learner driver starts with rules (“check your mirror before you signal”) and, with practice, the behavior comes under control of its consequences.

Exam tip: Ask what the person was in contact with: a verbal description of the contingency, or the consequences themselves. Words like told, instructed, read, the sign said or reminded herself point to rules. Words like after many tries, gradually or by trial and error point to contingency shaping.

Quick recap

  • Contingency-shaped behavior comes from direct contact with consequences.
  • Rule-governed behavior is controlled by contingency-specifying stimuli (rules).
  • Rules help most when consequences are delayed, small, rare or dangerous.
  • Rule-governed behavior can be insensitive to changes in the actual contingencies.
  • Pliance follows rules for social consequences; tracking follows rules because they describe the world accurately.

Further reading

  • Skinner, B. F. (1969). Contingencies of reinforcement: A theoretical analysis. Appleton-Century-Crofts.
  • Hayes, S. C. (Ed.). (1989). Rule-governed behavior: Cognition, contingencies, and instructional control. Plenum Press.
  • Schlinger, H., & Blakely, E. (1987). Function-altering effects of contingency-specifying stimuli. The Behavior Analyst, 10(1), 41-45.

Key terms

Rule-governed behavior
Behavior controlled by a verbal description of a contingency (a rule) rather than by direct experience with the consequences. It can be acquired quickly but may persist after the actual contingencies change.
Contingency-shaped behavior
Behavior that has been selected and maintained by direct contact with its consequences, rather than by a verbal description of them.
Rule (Contingency-specifying stimulus)
A verbal description of a contingency: a behavior, its consequence and often the conditions in which it applies. Rules can control behavior that the listener has never contacted directly.
Pliance
Rule following controlled by socially mediated consequences for doing what the rule says, such as praise or reprimands from the person who gave the rule. The term comes from relational frame theory.
Tracking
Rule following controlled by the match between the rule and the way the world actually works, rather than by social consequences for compliance. The term comes from relational frame theory.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.18. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Amani, a new driver, steers smoothly around curves only after weeks of practice in which oversteering led to jolts and corrections. Asked how she knows how far to turn the wheel, she says, 'I just feel it.' Her steering is best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Her steering was shaped by direct contact with its consequences over many trials, and she cannot state the contingency, which is typical of contingency-shaped behavior. Pliance and tracking are both kinds of rule following, and no rule is controlling her steering.

  2. Question 2A clinic director tells staff, 'Parents read emails sent on Fridays.' Staff send updates on Fridays for months. When parents start replying much faster to Monday emails, staff keep sending on Fridays. What does this illustrate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. The staff's behavior is controlled by the director's rule, and it has not adjusted to the new pattern of parent replies. Rule-governed behavior is often less sensitive to changing contingencies than behavior shaped by those contingencies. Nothing about the behavior has extinguished: it is still occurring.

  3. Question 3Which situation most clearly calls for teaching with a rule instead of relying on direct contact with consequences?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Rules are most useful when natural consequences are delayed, improbable, small but cumulative, or dangerous to learn by experience. A rare but serious injury fits. Immediate, harmless consequences can shape behavior directly, and fine timing is usually learned through practice.

  4. Question 4Hailey follows her coach's rule 'Stretch before every run' because the coach watches and benches anyone who skips it. Her brother Connor follows the same rule because he has found he gets fewer cramps when he stretches. Which pair is correct?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Pliance is rule following controlled by socially mediated consequences for following the rule, such as a coach who checks. Tracking is rule following controlled by the rule's match with how the world actually works, such as fewer cramps. The same rule can be followed for either reason.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.