cumulative

B.1 Behavior, response, and response class

What the task asks: Tell apart behavior in general, a single response and a response class, and recognize which one a description refers to.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Behavior analysts use three related words with precision. Behavior is what organisms do. A response is one occurrence of it. A response class is a group of responses that count as the same unit because they share a form or, more often, a function.

The distinction matters because every later step depends on it. You count responses. You define, measure and change response classes. And when you try to reduce problem behavior, you are usually working with a functional response class: target the wrong member and the others may take its place.

Breaking it down

Behavior

In the technical sense, behavior is the part of an organism’s interaction with its environment that involves movement of some part of the body and produces a measurable change in the environment. Talking, writing, reaching and crying all qualify. Private events such as thinking are also treated as behavior in radical behaviorism (see A.3), even though no one else can observe them directly.

A useful check: if the person does it and it can be counted or timed, it is a candidate for behavior. Labels such as lazy, frustrated or defiant are not behavior. They summarize behavior, and they hide what the person actually did.

The word works at different scales. Behavior can mean everything a person does, or one kind of activity (“her hand-raising”). The full set of behavior a person can perform is their repertoire, and the word also names a smaller set of skills tied to a task, such as a reading repertoire.

Response

A response is a single, specific instance of behavior. When Omar raises his hand five times in a lesson, that is five responses. Responses are the units you count when you measure count or rate (see C.3).

Every response has a topography: its physical form, including the body parts involved, the movement and where it happens. (How forceful a response is, its magnitude, is usually measured as a separate dimension.) Every response also has a function: the effect it has on the environment. Keeping those two ideas apart is most of this task.

Response class

A response class is a group of responses treated as one unit. There are two ways to group them.

  • A topographical response class groups responses that share a form. All the ways a child hits with an open hand belong to one, whatever each hit achieves.
  • A functional response class groups responses that produce the same effect on the environment, however different they look. Saying “help”, handing over a jar and pushing an adult’s hand toward the lid form one class if each gets the jar opened.

Most behavior-analytic writing, including Cooper, Heron and Heward (2020), uses response class in the functional sense, and that is the sense that matters most in practice. Members of a functional class tend to change together. Reinforce one and similar members may increase too, which is part of what B.14 calls response generalization. Put one on extinction or block it, and another member may appear.

The two kinds overlap without being the same. Responses that look alike may serve different functions (a scream for attention and a scream to escape a task), and responses that look nothing alike may serve the same one.

Different forms, same function Hits Pushes Screams Peer drops the toy One functional response class Same form, different functions Screams Gets attention Escapes a task Two functional response classes
Function, not form, defines the class. Ana's hitting, pushing and screaming are one functional class because each gets a peer to drop a toy, while two screams that look alike can belong to different classes.

Seeing it in practice

A preschool teacher is concerned about a child, Ana, during recess.

ObservationWhat it isWhy
The teacher counts 12 times that Ana hits a peer.12 responsesEach hit is one instance.
“Hitting” is defined as any contact of Ana’s hand with a peer’s body.A topographical response classThe definition groups responses by form.
Ana hits, pushes and screams, and each gets a peer to drop a toy.A functional response classDifferent forms, same effect.
Ana can climb, name colors, take turns and ask for help.Part of her repertoireThe behavior she is able to perform.

A workplace example. A new employee, Kwame, wants help with spreadsheets. He emails his supervisor, walks over to the supervisor’s desk, and sighs loudly at his screen until a coworker leans over. If each of these responses gets him help, they form one functional response class. If the supervisor answers emails quickly but the team stops responding to sighs, emailing is likely to grow and sighing to fade, because reinforcement now favors one member of the class over the others.

EmailsSighs02468All forms get helpEmails answered fast, sighs ignored123456789101112131415WorkdaysRequests per day
Kwame's requests for help. Once sighs stop getting help and emails get quick answers, emailing grows and sighing fades: the members of one functional class shift with reinforcement.

The same logic drives function-based treatment (see F.6). If a learner’s head-hitting, screaming and dropping to the floor all produce escape from tasks, a plan that addresses only head-hitting may just shift responding to the other members of the class.

Common mix-ups

  • A response is not behavior in general. A response is one instance. If a question asks what was counted, the answer is usually responses.
  • A response class is not a list of similar-looking actions. Unless the question says topographical, assume the class is defined by function.
  • Same form does not mean same function. Two children who both throw toys may do it for different reasons, and their throwing belongs to different functional classes.
  • Labels are not behavior. Noncompliant and aggressive summarize behavior. They must be replaced with observable responses before anything can be measured (see C.1).
  • A response class is not the repertoire. The repertoire is everything a person can do. A response class is one group within it.

Exam tip: When a scenario lists several different-looking actions that all produce the same outcome (attention, escape, an item), the answer is almost always a functional response class.

Quick recap

  • Behavior is what organisms do; a response is one instance; a response class is a group of responses treated as one unit.
  • Topography is the form of a response. Function is its effect on the environment.
  • Topographical response classes share form. Functional response classes share an effect, and that is the default meaning.
  • Members of a functional class tend to change together, so plans should address the whole class.
  • The repertoire is all the behavior a person can perform.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 2.
  • Johnston, J. M., & Pennypacker, H. S. (2009). Strategies and tactics of behavioral research (3rd ed.). Routledge.

Key terms

Behavior
The activity of living organisms: the part of an organism's interaction with its environment that involves movement of some part of the body and produces a measurable change in the environment. The word often names a type of activity (hand-raising), while a single instance of it is a response.
Response
A single, specific instance of behavior. Responses are the units that get counted when behavior is measured.
Response class
A group of responses treated as one unit because they share something. Members of a functional response class produce the same effect on the environment, however different they look; members of a topographical response class share the same form. Used without a qualifier, the term usually means a functional class.
Topography
The physical form or shape of a response: what it looks like, including the body parts involved, the movement and where it occurs. The force of a response is usually treated as a separate dimension, magnitude. Responses with different topographies can serve the same function, and the same topography can serve different functions.
Repertoire
All the behavior a person can perform, or the set of skills relevant to a particular task or setting. A response is in someone's repertoire if they can emit it under suitable conditions.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.1. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1During a 30-minute session, a technician makes a tally mark each time a learner, Jun, taps the table. The session ends with 18 marks. What does each tally mark represent?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Each tap is one instance of behavior, which is a response, and responses are what get counted. A response class is a group of responses, so it would be the set of all taps (or of everything that serves the same function), not one mark.

  2. Question 2When Mira wants a break from schoolwork, she sometimes says 'Break, please', sometimes puts her head on the desk and sometimes tears her worksheet. Each of these reliably ends the task for a few minutes. How are these responses best described?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The three responses look nothing alike but produce the same effect (escape from the task), so they form a functional response class. A topographical class would require them to share a form, which they do not.

  3. Question 3A plan targets a learner's hand-biting, which produces attention from staff. Staff begin blocking hand-biting, and over the next week head-rubbing and yelling increase. Both of those also get attention. What best explains this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Members of a functional response class produce the same reinforcer, so when one member is blocked, others that still produce attention tend to increase. The responses do not share a form, which rules out a topographical class, and they were already in the learner's repertoire.

  4. Question 4Which statement about topography and function is accurate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Topography is the form of a response, and function is its effect. Very different forms can produce the same effect, and the same form can produce different effects for different people. Response classes are usually defined by function, not form.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.