The big idea
Every behavior-change procedure does more than change the target behavior. Extinction, punishment and restrictive procedures such as physical guidance or restraint often bring crying, aggression, agitation, and attempts to escape or avoid the people and places involved. Some of these effects are operant: behavior that has paid off before. Others are elicited: respondent reactions that aversive events produce directly (B.3).
These effects matter for two reasons. They can undermine the plan, because a learner who fears the therapist will avoid teaching. And they matter to the person. A plan that suppresses a target behavior while leaving the learner frightened or distressed is not a good outcome. Evaluating a procedure means measuring these effects alongside the target.
Breaking it down
Effects of extinction
When reinforcement for a behavior stops (B.11), several things are common early on:
- an extinction burst: a temporary increase in the rate, duration or intensity of the behavior
- extinction-induced aggression: aggression toward people or objects that appears, or increases, when reinforcement stops
- emotional behavior such as crying, yelling or agitation
- more variable responding, which may include other problem behaviors
- later, spontaneous recovery or resurgence (H.5)
Bursting and aggression are not universal, and they are less likely when extinction is combined with reinforcement for an alternative behavior or with noncontingent reinforcement. The practical lesson is to avoid extinction alone whenever you can.
Respondent effects of aversive stimulation
An aversive stimulus, such as a loud reprimand, physical guidance, restraint or pain, elicits respondent reactions: startle, crying, a racing heart, fear, and sometimes elicited aggression, an attack on whoever or whatever is nearby that does not depend on a history of reinforcement for aggression.
Through respondent conditioning, neutral stimuli paired with those events come to elicit similar reactions. The therapist, the therapy room, the work materials, even the sound of a timer can become conditioned aversive stimuli. Once that happens they also work operantly: the learner escapes or avoids them, and the therapist’s praise may lose value as a reinforcer.
Effects of punishment and restrictive procedures
Punishment procedures (G.17) and other restrictive procedures add further risks:
- Escape and avoidance: hiding, running, lying, or behaving well only when the punishing person is present.
- Aggression toward the person delivering punishment or toward others.
- Behavioral contrast: the target drops where punishment is used and rises elsewhere.
- Modeling: learners may copy the punishing behavior with peers.
- Overuse: a reprimand that stops behavior right away negatively reinforces the person delivering it, so punishment can creep upward.
- Injury and trauma: restraint and seclusion carry risks of physical harm and lasting distress.
Evaluating side effects
Measure them rather than guessing:
- write operational definitions for crying, aggression, negative vocalizations and other signs of distress, and record them with the target
- track approach and avoidance: does the learner come to the session area, stay and engage, or pull away?
- watch for signs that the learner is withdrawing assent, such as pushing materials away, turning away, saying “no” or trying to leave
- measure signs of positive affect too, such as smiling, laughing and relaxed engagement
- ask the learner and caregivers about acceptability, and when possible let the learner choose among treatment options
Minimizing side effects
- From the first day, reinforce a function-based alternative so the learner has a reliable way to get what the problem behavior used to get.
- Start with the least restrictive effective procedure, and add antecedent supports such as choice, demand fading and a rich schedule of reinforcement.
- Pair yourself and the setting with reinforcement before placing demands.
- Give the learner a way to pause, and treat assent withdrawal as a signal to stop and review the plan, not something to push through by default.
- Plan for safety and train staff for bursts.
- Set data-based rules for changing or ending a procedure.
This is the practical side of compassionate care: treatment that works, delivered in a way the learner can accept.
Seeing it in practice
- Feeding clinic. In a program that keeps the spoon at her lips until she takes the bite, Aiyana, 4, starts crying at the sight of the high chair. Her team mixes in preferred foods, shrinks portions of new foods, and records crying and approach to the chair. Within days she climbs into the chair on her own again.
- School. After being escorted to a time-out room several times, Marcus, 9, cries and refuses to walk down the hallway where the room is, even on the way to art. The team stops using exclusionary time-out, reinforces calm transitions in the hallway, and tracks his refusals.
Common mix-ups
- Extinction burst vs. extinction-induced aggression. A burst is more of the same behavior. Induced aggression is a new or increased response, such as hitting, that appears when reinforcement stops.
- Elicited vs. emitted. Startle, fear and pain-elicited aggression are respondent. Escape and avoidance are operant. Aversive procedures can produce both at once.
- “It’s working” is not enough. A drop in the target alongside rising distress or avoidance is a problem to solve, not a success.
- Side effects are not limited to punishment. Extinction, escape extinction, restrictive procedures and even fast schedule thinning can produce them.
Exam tip: When a scenario describes crying, aggression or avoidance of a person or setting after a new procedure starts, the best answer usually adds reinforcement for an alternative and measures the side effect. It is rarely to continue unchanged or to add punishment.
Quick recap
- Extinction can produce bursts, aggression, emotional behavior and variability. Combining it with reinforcement reduces these.
- Aversive stimulation elicits respondent reactions, and pairing can turn people and places into conditioned aversive stimuli.
- Punishment and restrictive procedures add escape, avoidance, aggression, contrast, modeling and overuse.
- Measure distress, avoidance, assent withdrawal and positive affect alongside the target.
- Reduce side effects with function-based reinforcement, the least restrictive effective procedure and attention to assent.
Further reading
- Azrin, N. H., Hutchinson, R. R., & Hake, D. F. (1966). Extinction-induced aggression. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 9(3), 191-204.
- Lerman, D. C., Iwata, B. A., & Wallace, M. D. (1999). Side effects of extinction: Prevalence of bursting and aggression during the treatment of self-injurious behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 32(1), 1-8.
- Taylor, B. A., LeBlanc, L. A., & Nosik, M. R. (2019). Compassionate care in behavior analytic treatment: Can outcomes be enhanced by attending to relationships with caregivers? Behavior Analysis in Practice, 12(3), 654-666.
Key terms
- Extinction burst
- An immediate, usually temporary increase in the frequency, duration or intensity of a behavior when extinction begins. Bursts are common but do not always occur, and giving in during a burst reinforces the more intense behavior.
- Extinction-induced aggression
- Aggressive or emotional behavior that appears or increases when a previously reinforced behavior is placed on extinction. It is a known side effect of extinction to plan for, along with the extinction burst and extinction-induced variability.
- Elicited aggression (Pain-elicited aggression, Respondent aggression)
- Aggression produced directly by aversive stimulation, such as pain or physical restraint, rather than by a history of reinforcement for aggression. It is one of the respondent side effects of aversive procedures.
- Aversive stimulus
- A stimulus whose removal after a behavior functions as reinforcement, or whose presentation after a behavior functions as punishment. It can also evoke behavior that has ended it in the past. In everyday terms it is unpleasant, but technically it is defined by these effects on behavior.
- Respondent conditioning (Classical conditioning, Pavlovian conditioning)
- Learning in which a neutral stimulus is paired with an unconditioned stimulus until the formerly neutral stimulus elicits a similar response on its own. The neutral stimulus becomes a conditioned stimulus, and the response it now elicits is a conditioned response.
- Assent
- A learner's ongoing agreement to take part in services, shown in words or behavior such as approaching, engaging and staying with activities. It complements the informed consent given by a parent or other legally authorized representative. Signs of assent withdrawal, such as pushing materials away or trying to leave, signal a need to pause and review the plan.
Check yourself
4 questions on G.18. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Crying, aggression and avoidance of the clinic door are emotional and elicited effects, and the door is becoming a conditioned aversive stimulus. Adding a reinforced alternative, easing demands and measuring distress and approach address them directly. Calling it a burst ignores the growing avoidance, and a reprimand adds another aversive event.
Show the answer
Answer: C. Through respondent conditioning, a person repeatedly paired with aversive events can come to elicit fear and to function as a conditioned aversive stimulus that Greta now avoids. The avoidance is specific to that staff member, which fits this explanation. Nothing suggests reinforcement has been withheld, so an extinction burst does not fit.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Bursting and aggression are less common when extinction is combined with reinforcement for an alternative or with noncontingent reinforcement, because the child still has access to attention. Ignoring only some screams puts screaming on intermittent reinforcement, which makes it more persistent. A reprimand delivers attention and adds an aversive event.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Side effects are evaluated the same way as the target: with operational definitions and direct, ongoing measurement. Monthly impressions and caregiver complaints come late and are unreliable, and a drop in the target can hide rising distress or avoidance.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.