The big idea
Teach a learner a few relations and, often, many more appear that nobody taught. An emergent relation is a relation between stimuli, or between stimuli and responses, that appears without direct training or reinforcement because other relations were taught. Generative performance is the broader outcome: the learner produces new, correct behavior that goes beyond what was trained.
Emergence is a large part of why language grows so fast: nobody teaches a child every sentence or every fact. Procedures for teaching emergent relations are in G.19.
Breaking it down
Stimulus equivalence
Murray Sidman’s research (Sidman, 1971; Sidman & Tailby, 1982) used matching-to-sample tasks, in which a learner selects one of several comparison stimuli in the presence of a sample. Teach A to B and B to C, then test relations that were never trained. Stimulus equivalence is shown when three properties emerge:
- Reflexivity: each stimulus is matched to itself (A to A), as in identity matching.
- Symmetry: a trained relation is reversed (B to A after training A to B).
- Transitivity: two trained relations that share a stimulus combine into a new one (A to C after training A to B and B to C).
A test of C to A needs symmetry and transitivity together, and it is often called the equivalence test. When all of these hold, the stimuli form an equivalence class: they are interchangeable even though they look nothing alike.
Take A as the numeral 5, B as the printed word FIVE and C as a picture of five dots. Teach 5 to FIVE and FIVE to the dots. Untaught, the learner matches FIVE to 5 (symmetry), 5 to the dots (transitivity) and the dots to 5 (equivalence). The payoff grows with class size: train three relations among four stimuli and nine more can emerge.
Relational frame theory
Relational frame theory (RFT) (Hayes, Barnes-Holmes, & Roche, 2001) treats equivalence as one case of a learned, generalized operant: relating stimuli to one another on the basis of cues that can be arbitrary. Relations include sameness, opposition, comparison (more or less), difference, hierarchy, time and perspective (I and you, here and there). RFT names three properties:
- Mutual entailment: a relation in one direction implies one in the other. If A is bigger than B, then B is smaller than A. This is the general form of symmetry.
- Combinatorial entailment: two relations combine to imply a third. If A is bigger than B and B is bigger than C, then A is bigger than C and C is smaller than A. This is the general form of transitivity.
- Transformation of stimulus function: the functions of one stimulus change the functions of related stimuli, in line with the relation. If a dog is scary and a learner is told that a new animal is much bigger and fiercer than a dog, the new animal may evoke more fear without ever being encountered.
Recombinative generalization
Recombinative generalization is the recombination of components of trained responses into new, correct combinations. Teach “push car” and “roll ball,” and the learner may say “push ball” and “roll car.” Matrix training arranges this on purpose by teaching a few combinations from a grid of actions and objects, then testing the rest.
Naming
Naming (Horne & Lowe, 1996) is a two-way relation between speaker and listener behavior. After a child learns to tact an object, the child can also pick it out when hearing its name without being taught, and the reverse. Many authors now call it bidirectional naming. Learners who do not yet show it need listener and speaker skills taught separately.
Accounts of why emergence happens differ. Sidman treated equivalence as a basic outcome of reinforcement contingencies, RFT treats it as learned relational responding, and naming accounts tie it to speaker and listener behavior. The exam focuses on recognizing the outcomes.
Seeing it in practice
| Example | Taught | Emerged | Process |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sofía learns to match the spoken word “perro” to a picture of a dog, and the picture to the printed word DOG. She then matches “perro” to DOG. | A to B, B to C | A to C | Transitivity |
| After learning to select the word JAPAN when shown Japan’s flag, a student selects the flag when shown the word. | A to B | B to A | Symmetry |
| Told “Sam is taller than you, and you are taller than your sister,” a child says the sister is shorter than Sam. | Two comparisons | A new comparison | Combinatorial entailment |
| Taught “red truck” and “blue ball,” a toddler says “blue truck” when shown one. | Two phrases | New combinations | Recombinative generalization |
| After learning to say “kiwi” when shown a kiwi, a learner picks the kiwi when asked to “find the kiwi.” | Tact | Listener response | Naming |
| Told a new snack is “like the chips you love,” a child reaches for it eagerly. | A sameness relation | New reinforcing function | Transformation of stimulus function |
Common mix-ups
- Equivalence is not generalization. Stimulus generalization depends on physical similarity. Members of an equivalence class can be completely unlike one another.
- Symmetry vs. transitivity. Symmetry reverses one trained pair. Transitivity links two trained pairs through a shared stimulus.
- Emergent means untaught. If the relation was trained or reinforced directly, it is not emergent.
- Equivalence vs. RFT. Equivalence names a set of outcomes. RFT is a theory that includes equivalence and many other relations, such as more than and opposite to.
Exam tip: Line up what was taught and what was tested. A reversed pair is symmetry. A new pair through a shared middle stimulus is transitivity. Reversed and linked is the equivalence test. Words like more, less, opposite or before point to RFT terms. New word combinations point to recombinative generalization.
Quick recap
- Emergent relations appear without direct teaching, as a result of other relations being taught.
- Stimulus equivalence is shown by reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity.
- RFT generalizes these as mutual entailment, combinatorial entailment and transformation of stimulus function.
- Recombinative generalization produces new combinations of trained parts.
- Naming links speaker and listener behavior in both directions.
Further reading
- Sidman, M., & Tailby, W. (1982). Conditional discrimination vs. matching to sample: An expansion of the testing paradigm. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 5-22.
- Hayes, S. C., Barnes-Holmes, D., & Roche, B. (Eds.). (2001). Relational frame theory: A post-Skinnerian account of human language and cognition. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
- Horne, P. J., & Lowe, C. F. (1996). On the origins of naming and other symbolic behavior. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 65(1), 185-241.
Key terms
- Emergent relation (Derived relation)
- A relation between stimuli, or between stimuli and responses, that appears without direct teaching or reinforcement as a result of other relations that were taught.
- Stimulus equivalence
- The emergence of untaught relations among stimuli after some relations have been taught, shown by reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity. Stimuli that pass these tests form an equivalence class and are interchangeable even when they share no physical features.
- Reflexivity
- A property of stimulus equivalence in which each stimulus is matched to itself (A to A) without specific training. It is usually tested with identity matching.
- Symmetry
- A property of stimulus equivalence in which a trained relation is reversed without training: after learning A to B, the learner also matches B to A.
- Transitivity
- A property of stimulus equivalence in which two trained relations that share a stimulus combine into an untrained one: after learning A to B and B to C, the learner matches A to C.
- Relational frame theory (RFT)
- A behavior-analytic account of language and cognition that treats relating stimuli to one another as a learned, generalized operant. Its core properties are mutual entailment, combinatorial entailment and transformation of stimulus function, and it covers relations such as sameness, opposition, comparison and hierarchy, not only equivalence.
- Recombinative generalization
- The production of new, correct combinations of components from responses that were taught separately. Matrix training arranges teaching to promote it.
- Naming (Bidirectional naming, BiN)
- A two-way relation between speaker and listener behavior. After learning to tact an object, a person can also select it as a listener when hearing its name, and the reverse, without separate teaching.
Check yourself
4 questions on B.21. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Two trained relations that share a stimulus (the map color) have combined into a new one, A to C. That is transitivity. Symmetry would be reversing a trained pair, such as matching a color to its department name. Generalization depends on physical similarity, and a department name and a room number look nothing alike.
Show the answer
Answer: B. Ken reversed the direction of a single trained relation, which is symmetry. Transitivity needs two trained relations linked by a shared stimulus. Reflexivity would be matching the picture to an identical picture.
Show the answer
Answer: B. Because the new game was related to a reinforcing one through a frame of sameness, it took on some of that game's reinforcing function without any direct contact. That is transformation of stimulus function. Mutual entailment would be deriving the reverse relation (the card game is like the new game), which does not by itself explain the change in her behavior.
Show the answer
Answer: A. The child combined parts of two trained phrases into new, correct combinations, which is recombinative generalization. Stimulus equivalence and symmetry concern relations among stimuli in matching tasks, and naming concerns the link between speaker and listener behavior.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.