cumulative

I.5 Performance management procedures

What the task asks: Identify and use evidence-based, culturally responsive procedures for improving supervisee performance, including training, antecedent strategies such as task clarification and reduced response effort, and consequences such as feedback and reinforcement.

Personnel Supervision and Management6 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Performance management is the use of behavior-analytic procedures to improve how people perform at work. It grows out of organizational behavior management, the branch of behavior analysis that studies workplaces. Supervisors change supervisee behavior with the same tools behavior analysts use with clients: arrange antecedents so the right behavior is likely, teach skills directly, and follow performance with consequences that strengthen it.

The Ethics Code asks for supervision procedures that are evidence based and emphasize positive reinforcement (Standard 4.06, Providing Supervision and Training), along with timely praise and feedback (Standard 4.08, Performance Monitoring and Feedback).

Which procedure to use depends on why performance falls short. A supervisee who has never learned a skill needs training. One who knows the skill but does not use it may need clearer expectations, easier materials or different consequences. I.6 covers finding the cause; this guide covers the tools.

Breaking it down

Behavioral skills training

Behavioral skills training (BST) is a training package with four components:

  1. Instructions: describe the skill and why it matters, ideally with a written summary.
  2. Modeling: show the skill, live or on video.
  3. Rehearsal: the supervisee practices, usually in role-play first.
  4. Feedback: praise for correct steps and correction for errors, followed by more practice.

The cycle repeats until the supervisee meets a mastery criterion, then continues in the real setting (in situ training) so the skill carries over to sessions. BST has strong research support for teaching new skills to staff. Instructions alone, the main ingredient of a lecture or a reading packet, seldom change on-the-job performance.

Repeat until criterion Instructions Say what, why Modeling Show it Rehearsal Role-play it Feedback Praise, correct A lecture with a demonstration stops here Criterion met In situ training Feedback in real sessions
BST runs instructions, modeling, rehearsal and feedback, then cycles through rehearsal and feedback until the skill meets criterion and moves into real sessions. A lecture with a demonstration stops after the first two steps.

Antecedent strategies

Antecedent strategies make correct performance more likely before it happens.

  • Task clarification specifies exactly what the job requires: the steps, the standard and when to do it. Many performance problems shrink once the supervisee knows precisely what is expected.
  • Job aids, such as checklists, flowcharts and cue cards placed where the work happens, prompt the steps at the moment they are needed.
  • Goal setting names a specific, measurable level of performance to reach by a set time. Goals work best when they are challenging but attainable, set with the supervisee’s input and paired with feedback on progress.
  • Manipulating response effort makes the desired behavior easier and the undesired behavior harder.

Response effort is the physical or cognitive work a response takes. People tend to choose the lower-effort option, so small changes in effort can produce large changes in performance. If recording data means walking across the room for a clipboard, staff will skip it. Putting the data sheet on the teaching table raises the rate of recording.

Consequence strategies

Performance feedback is information about past performance used to improve future performance, and it is one of the most widely used tools in performance management. It varies along several dimensions:

DimensionOptionsNotes
TimingImmediate or delayedImmediate suits new skills; feedback just before the next opportunity can also work
FormVerbal, written or graphicGraphs let supervisees see their trend against a goal
SourceSupervisor, peer or selfSelf-monitoring can maintain skills between observations
ContentPraise, correction or bothSpecific, behavior-focused content is most useful
SettingPrivate or publicCorrect in private; ask before praising in public

Reviews of organizational research find that feedback works most consistently when combined with other components, such as goal setting or reinforcement.

Reinforcement follows good performance with something the supervisee values: specific praise, recognition, preferred tasks, schedule flexibility or tangible rewards. What functions as a reinforcer differs from person to person, so ask or assess rather than guess. Reprimands and write-ups may suppress behavior briefly, but they damage the relationship and belong at the end of the list, not the start.

Before: antecedents Behavior After: consequences Task clarification Job aids Goal setting Lower response effort On-the-job performance Performance feedback Reinforcement Make it likely to happen Strengthen it afterward
Where each tool acts. Antecedent tools come before the performance and make it more likely; feedback and reinforcement come after it and strengthen it.

Culturally responsive delivery

The same procedure can land very differently with different people. Public praise motivates some supervisees and embarrasses others. Direct correction feels respectful to some and harsh to others. Ask each supervisee how they prefer to receive feedback and recognition, choose role-play scenarios that reflect the families they serve, provide materials in a language they read fluently, and check whether they find the procedures acceptable (see I.7).

Seeing it in practice

A supervisor, Kwame, oversees technicians at a clinic.

  • A new technician cannot yet run a preference assessment: BST with role-play to criterion, then feedback during real sessions.
  • Technicians skip graphing because the template is buried in a shared drive: reduce response effort by putting a link on each session tablet’s home screen.
  • A technician is unsure which programs to run on which days: task clarification with a written daily schedule and a checklist.
  • Integrity is acceptable but slipping: goal setting plus weekly graphic feedback and specific praise.

Common mix-ups

  • BST is not a lecture with a demonstration. Without rehearsal and feedback it is incomplete.
  • Task clarification is an antecedent; feedback is a consequence. Clarification tells staff what to do next. Feedback tells them how they did.
  • Response effort is not the same as motivation. If staff skip a step, check whether the step is harder than it needs to be before assuming they do not care.
  • One-size-fits-all reinforcement often fails. What reinforces one supervisee may be neutral or even aversive for another.

Exam tip: Match the procedure to the problem. A supervisee who cannot perform the skill needs training (BST). A supervisee who can perform it but does not needs an antecedent or consequence change. When a scenario says the skill was performed correctly in role-play, rule out more training first.

Quick recap

  • BST means instructions, modeling, rehearsal and feedback, repeated to mastery and then in the real setting.
  • Antecedent tools: task clarification, job aids, goal setting and reduced response effort.
  • Feedback can be immediate or delayed and verbal, written or graphic, and it works best combined with other components.
  • Reinforcement should be frequent and individualized; punitive steps are a last resort.
  • Deliver every procedure in a way that fits the supervisee’s preferences and culture.

Further reading

  • Parsons, M. B., Rollyson, J. H., & Reid, D. H. (2012). Evidence-based staff training: A guide for practitioners. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 5(2), 2-11.
  • Alvero, A. M., Bucklin, B. R., & Austin, J. (2001). An objective review of the effectiveness and essential characteristics of performance feedback in organizational settings (1985-1998). Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 21(1), 3-29.
  • Daniels, A. C., & Bailey, J. S. (2014). Performance management: Changing behavior that drives organizational effectiveness (5th ed.). Performance Management Publications.

Key terms

Performance management
The use of behavior-analytic procedures, such as task clarification, goal setting, feedback and reinforcement, to improve how people perform at work. It is a core application within organizational behavior management.
Behavioral skills training (BST)
A training package made up of instructions, modeling, rehearsal and feedback, repeated until the learner performs the skill to a mastery criterion. It is a well-supported way to teach new skills to staff, caregivers and clients.
Task clarification
An antecedent intervention that specifies exactly what a job requires: the steps to perform, the standard to meet and when to do it. It is often delivered with a written checklist or job aid.
Goal setting
A performance management procedure that specifies a measurable level of performance to reach within a set time. Goals tend to work best when they are specific, challenging but attainable, set with the person's input and combined with feedback on progress.
Performance feedback (Feedback)
Information given to a person about their past performance so they can maintain or improve it. It can be verbal, written or graphic, immediate or delayed, and can include praise, correction or both. It works best when it is specific and combined with goals or reinforcement.
Response effort
The physical or cognitive work a response requires. Because people tend to choose lower-effort options, making a desired response easier, or an undesired one harder, can change how often each occurs.
Job aid
A prompt placed where the work happens, such as a checklist, flowchart or step-by-step card, that tells a person what to do at the moment they need to do it, so they rely less on memory.

Check yourself

5 questions on I.5. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A supervisor teaches a new technician to run a multiple-stimulus preference assessment. The supervisor explains the steps, demonstrates them and hands over a summary sheet. The technician still makes errors with a client. Which part of behavioral skills training is missing?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. The supervisor gave instructions and modeling but no chance to practice with feedback, which BST requires before the skill is used with a client. More description or another demonstration repeats components already delivered. A quiz checks knowledge, not performance.

  2. Question 2Technicians at a center often fail to record data because the data binders are kept in an office down the hall. Which intervention most directly addresses the problem?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The barrier is the effort of reaching the data sheets, so moving them to where the behavior happens makes recording easier and more likely. Retraining fixes a skill deficit, but nothing suggests the technicians cannot record data. Reminders and reprimands leave the effort in place.

  3. Question 3Which example is task clarification?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Task clarification is an antecedent strategy that specifies what the job requires, and a step-by-step checklist does exactly that. Praise, graphed feedback and rewards are consequences that follow performance. They combine well with clarification but are not clarification themselves.

  4. Question 4Arjun implements a token system with 70% integrity. His supervisor sets a target of 90% within a month and shows him a graph of his weekly scores at each meeting. Which description fits this package?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. A specific performance target by a set date is goal setting, and a graph of past performance is graphic feedback. The pairing is common because feedback works most consistently when combined with other components. Nothing in the scenario involves modeling or rehearsal, so it is not BST.

  5. Question 5A supervisor praises staff publicly at team meetings. One supervisee, Mei, looks uncomfortable when recognized, and her performance does not improve afterward. What is the most culturally responsive next step?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. What functions as a reinforcer differs between people, and public recognition can be aversive for some. Asking her avoids assumptions and keeps praise in the plan in a form that works for her. Assuming a preference from her background is a stereotype, not responsiveness.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.