The big idea
Behavior rarely stays exactly where you taught it. It spreads, and it can spread in two directions.
- Stimulus generalization: the trained response occurs in the presence of new stimuli that resemble the ones present during training. Same response, new antecedent.
- Response generalization: new, untrained responses appear that serve the same function as the trained one. New response, often the same antecedent.
A short way to hold it: stimulus generalization changes when and where the taught behavior happens. Response generalization changes what the learner does.
Nobody can teach every response under every condition. Generalization is what lets a skill taught at a table with one therapist show up at home with a parent, in slightly different forms. It can also be a problem when it spreads to places it does not belong. How to plan for it is covered in G.15.
Breaking it down
Stimulus generalization
Stimulus generalization is the tendency for a response that has been reinforced in the presence of one stimulus to occur in the presence of other stimuli that share some of its physical features. The more a new stimulus resembles the training stimulus, the more likely the response. Plotting that relation gives the generalization gradient described in B.13.
In applied work, Cooper, Heron and Heward call the most common form setting or situation generalization: the target behavior shows up with people, places or materials that were not part of training. Lena learns to say “hi” to her therapist at the clinic and then says “hi” to the receptionist and to her teacher at school.
When generalization reaches stimuli where the response is wrong, it is often called overgeneralization. A child who calls every man “Daddy” is an example. The fix is discrimination training.
Response generalization
Response generalization is the extent to which a learner emits untrained responses that are functionally equivalent to the trained one. The new responses belong to the same response class (B.1): they differ in form but produce the same effect. A child taught to say “Can I have a turn?” also starts saying “My turn, please?” An employee trained to wipe tables in circles also starts using side-to-side strokes that get the table just as clean.
Nothing about the antecedent has to change. What is new is the form of the behavior.
How both relate to discrimination
Stimulus generalization and stimulus discrimination are opposite ends of one continuum. The less a learner’s responding changes across different stimuli, the more generalization; the more it changes, the more discrimination. Response generalization is about responses, not stimuli, so it is not the opposite of discrimination.
Both at once
A single event can include both. A learner taught to say “thank you” to a therapist who later says “thanks” to a cashier shows a new response in a new setting. When an item describes both changes, name both. When it asks which is shown, look for the one that changed while the other stayed the same.
Seeing it in practice
| Scenario | What is new | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Dev learned to tie his own sneakers and now ties his sister’s shoes and his hiking boots. | Shoes (stimuli); tying is the same | Stimulus generalization |
| A paraprofessional trained to say “Nice job sitting” also starts saying “I love how you’re sitting” and giving thumbs-ups. | Forms of praise (responses) | Response generalization |
| Amira learned to order lunch at one restaurant and orders at a different one with a different menu board. | Setting and materials | Stimulus generalization |
| A child taught to say “car” for cars now says “car” for buses and trucks. | Stimuli, and the response is now wrong | Stimulus generalization (overgeneralization) |
| After learning “I want juice,” Mia also says “Juice, please” and “Can I have juice?” | Response forms, same function | Response generalization |
Common mix-ups
- A new setting does not automatically mean stimulus generalization. Candidates spot a new place and stop reading. If the learner also uses a new form of the response there (says “thanks” instead of the trained “thank you”), response generalization is involved too. Check separately whether the antecedent is new and whether the response is new.
- Response generalization is not shaping. In shaping you reinforce each new approximation directly. Response generalization shows up without being trained.
- Generalization is not maintenance. Behavior lasting over time after the intervention ends is response maintenance (B.15). Some authors fold time into generalization, but the exam treats them separately.
- Generalization is not always good. Overgeneralization is a real teaching problem, and so is problem behavior that spreads to new settings.
- “Generalization” alone usually means stimulus generalization. Read the item closely before assuming.
Exam tip: Write down the trained pair: trained stimulus plus trained response. Compare the new event to it. New stimulus with the same response is stimulus generalization. The same situation with a new response that has the same function is response generalization.
Quick recap
- Stimulus generalization: the trained response occurs with new, similar stimuli.
- Response generalization: new, untrained responses with the same function occur.
- Stimulus generalization is the opposite of stimulus discrimination; response generalization concerns members of a response class.
- Overgeneralization is stimulus generalization to stimuli where the response is incorrect.
- Generalization is across stimuli or responses; maintenance is across time.
Further reading
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 30.
- Stokes, T. F., & Baer, D. M. (1977). An implicit technology of generalization. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 10(2), 349-367.
Key terms
- Stimulus generalization
- The occurrence of a trained response in the presence of stimuli that were not part of training but share features with the training stimuli. The more a new stimulus resembles the training stimulus, the more likely the response.
- Response generalization
- The occurrence of untrained responses that serve the same function as a trained response. The new responses differ in form but belong to the same response class.
- Generalization gradient
- A graph showing how often a trained response occurs across test stimuli that differ from the training stimulus along one dimension, such as color or pitch. A steep gradient shows strong discrimination; a flat one shows broad stimulus generalization.
- Stimulus discrimination (Discrimination)
- Responding differently in the presence of different stimuli. It results from a history in which a response was reinforced in the presence of one stimulus and not reinforced, or reinforced less, in the presence of another.
- Response class
- A group of responses treated as one unit because they share something. Members of a functional response class produce the same effect on the environment, however different they look; members of a topographical response class share the same form. Used without a qualifier, the term usually means a functional class.
Check yourself
4 questions on B.14. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: C. The response is the same one Rosa was taught, and it now occurs with a new person, a new item and a new setting. That is stimulus generalization. Response generalization would require a new form of the response, such as 'thanks, Grandma.'
Show the answer
Answer: C. The situation (customers arriving) is the same, but Marcus now emits new, untrained responses that serve the same greeting function. That is response generalization. Stimulus generalization would be the same phrase, 'Welcome in,' said in new situations.
Show the answer
Answer: D. One trained response is occurring in the presence of new stimuli that share a feature (roundness) with the training stimulus, which is stimulus generalization. Here it has gone too far, which is often called overgeneralization, and discrimination training would narrow it. The response form has not changed, so this is not response generalization.
Show the answer
Answer: B. In stimulus generalization the trained response appears in the presence of untrained stimuli. In response generalization untrained responses with the same function appear. The passage of time after intervention ends is response maintenance (B.15), not either form of generalization.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.