The big idea
There are two broad ways to arrange teaching. In trial-based teaching, the teacher decides when each learning opportunity happens and presents it as a separate trial with a clear start and finish. In free-operant teaching, the learner can respond at any time, and teaching happens inside ongoing activities, usually when the learner shows interest in something.
Neither is better across the board. Trials give many practice opportunities and tight control. Free-operant, naturalistic arrangements tend to produce more spontaneous and generalized behavior. Most good programs use both, and the exam asks you to pick the arrangement that fits a particular learner, skill and goal.
Breaking it down
Discrete trial teaching
Discrete trial teaching (DTT) presents instruction as a series of short trials. Each trial has the same parts:
- Antecedent (SD): a brief instruction or question, such as “Touch the cup,” with materials arranged.
- Prompt, if needed: help that makes the correct response likely (G.7).
- Response: the learner’s answer.
- Consequence: a reinforcer for a correct response, or an error-correction procedure.
- Intertrial interval (ITI): a brief pause before the next trial, used to record data and reset materials. Short ITIs tend to keep learners more engaged than long ones.
Because each response can occur only when a trial is presented, DTT data are reported as percentage correct or trials to criterion, not as rate.
Trials can be massed, with the same target presented many times in a row, or distributed, with target trials spread across the session or day and mixed with other targets and activities. Interspersing mastered tasks among new ones is a related tactic. Massed trials give concentrated practice. Distributed and interspersed trials make sessions less tedious and may help retention. Research findings are mixed, so check the learner’s own data.
Free-operant arrangements
A free operant is behavior the learner can emit at almost any time, without waiting for someone to present an opportunity, so it can be measured as rate. Free-operant teaching uses that: the learner’s own initiations create the teaching moments. The main naturalistic approaches are:
- Incidental teaching (Hart & Risley, 1975): the adult arranges the setting so preferred items are visible but out of reach. When the learner initiates by reaching, pointing or naming an item, the adult prompts a slightly more elaborate response and then gives the item. The learner picks the topic; the adult picks the target.
- Natural environment teaching (NET): teaching in the learner’s everyday settings and activities, built around current motivation. Teaching “push” at the swing, and pushing the swing when the learner says it, is NET.
- Pivotal response treatment (PRT): targets broad skills such as motivation, responding to multiple cues, self-initiation and self-management, on the view that gains there spread to many other behaviors. Its motivational components include learner choice, interspersing maintenance tasks with new ones, reinforcing reasonable attempts, and natural reinforcers tied directly to the response.
- Naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions (NDBIs): an umbrella term for approaches that combine behavioral teaching with developmental science, delivered in play and routines with shared control between adult and child. PRT is one example. Others include the Early Start Denver Model and JASPER.
Strengths and limits
| Feature | Trial-based (DTT) | Free-operant and naturalistic |
|---|---|---|
| Learning opportunities | Many per hour | Fewer, depending on initiations |
| Control over targets and stimuli | High | Lower |
| Data collection | Simple, trial by trial | Harder |
| Motivation | Often contrived reinforcers | Learner’s interests and natural reinforcers |
| Generalization and spontaneity | Often need extra programming | Built in more often |
| Risks | Prompt dependence, rote answers, escape-maintained problem behavior | Missed targets, uneven teaching across staff |
| Good fit | New discriminations, early skills, precise teaching | Mands, play and social skills, generalizing skills learned in trials |
Choosing an arrangement
Ask whether the skill is new or being generalized, whether the learner initiates often enough to create opportunities, and whether daily life naturally offers chances to practice it (requests and play do; matching letters may not). A common blend is to build a tact or listener response in brief trials, then move practice into play and routines (G.15).
Seeing it in practice
- Clinic table. Priya, 3, is learning to identify body parts. Her technician runs 10 trials of “Touch nose,” “Touch ears” and so on, mixed with two mastered tasks, with a 2-second ITI. Accuracy is graphed each session.
- Preschool snack. Priya’s preschool teacher puts crackers in a clear container Priya cannot open. When she pushes it toward the teacher, the teacher models “open,” waits, and opens it when Priya says “op.” That is incidental teaching, and the cracker is the natural reinforcer.
- Home. Eli’s father uses PRT during block play. Eli picks the blocks, his father models “big tower,” and he hands Eli the block he wanted when Eli says “big tow.”
- Middle school. Ms. Haddad teaches new vocabulary with quick structured trials, then has students use the words during group projects and praises correct use as it happens.
Common mix-ups
- DTT is not the same thing as ABA. It is one teaching format. Naturalistic methods are behavior analytic too.
- Naturalistic does not mean unstructured. Incidental teaching, NET and PRT specify targets, prompts and consequences. Only the timing follows the learner.
- Measurement follows the arrangement. Rate fits free operants. Percentage correct fits discrete trials.
- Massed vs. distributed. Massed means the same target over and over. Distributed means spread out and mixed with other work.
- An ITI is not a prompt delay. The ITI comes after the consequence. A prompt delay (G.8) is the wait between the SD and the prompt.
Exam tip: Ask who starts the learning opportunity. If the teacher presents an instruction and the trial ends with a consequence, it is trial-based. If the learner’s initiation or interest starts it, it is free-operant or naturalistic.
Quick recap
- A discrete trial has an SD, an optional prompt, a response, a consequence and an intertrial interval.
- Massed trials repeat one target. Distributed trials spread targets across the session.
- Incidental teaching, NET and PRT teach during natural activities using the learner’s own motivation.
- PRT is an example of an NDBI, which blends behavioral and developmental methods.
- DTT offers practice and control. Naturalistic teaching offers motivation and generalization. Most programs blend them.
Further reading
- Hart, B., & Risley, T. R. (1975). Incidental teaching of language in the preschool. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 8(4), 411-420.
- Schreibman, L., Dawson, G., Stahmer, A. C., et al. (2015). Naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions: Empirically validated treatments for autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 45(8), 2411-2428.
Key terms
- Discrete trial teaching (DTT, Discrete trial training)
- Instruction delivered as a series of brief, separate trials, each made up of an SD, an optional prompt, the learner's response, a consequence and an intertrial interval. The teacher decides when each learning opportunity occurs.
- Intertrial interval (ITI)
- The brief pause between the consequence of one trial and the antecedent of the next in discrete trial teaching, used to record data and reset materials. Short intervals tend to keep learners more engaged than long ones.
- Free operant
- Behavior a person can emit at almost any time, without waiting for someone to present an opportunity, and that takes little time to complete, so it can occur at a wide range of rates. Free-operant teaching builds learning opportunities around the learner's own initiations.
- Natural environment teaching (NET, Naturalistic teaching)
- Teaching that takes place in the learner's everyday settings and activities, built around the learner's current motivation, with consequences that follow naturally from the response.
- Incidental teaching
- A naturalistic procedure in which the adult arranges the setting so preferred items are visible but not freely available, waits for the learner to initiate, prompts a slightly more elaborate response, and then provides the item the learner wanted.
- Pivotal response treatment (PRT)
- A naturalistic developmental behavioral intervention that targets broad skills such as motivation, responding to multiple cues, self-initiation and self-management. Its motivational components include learner choice, interspersed maintenance tasks, reinforcement of reasonable attempts and natural reinforcers tied directly to the response.
- Naturalistic developmental behavioral intervention (NDBI)
- A family of early intervention approaches that combine behavioral teaching procedures with findings from developmental science. Teaching happens in play and daily routines, with shared control between adult and child and natural consequences.
Check yourself
4 questions on G.13. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: A. The pause after the consequence and before the next SD is the intertrial interval, used to record data and reset materials. Latency is the time from the SD to the learner's response. A prompt delay is the wait between the SD and a prompt, inside the trial.
Show the answer
Answer: D. The child's initiation starts the opportunity, the teacher prompts a slightly more elaborate response, and the item Kai asked for is the reinforcer, which defines incidental teaching. In discrete trial teaching the adult presents the SD and decides when each trial happens. Chain interruption breaks into a learned sequence, which is not happening here.
Show the answer
Answer: C. The skill is under narrow control of the table setting and one instructor. Practicing in natural settings, with varied people and natural consequences, brings the answer under control of the stimuli where it is needed. More massed trials at the table would strengthen the same narrow stimulus control.
Show the answer
Answer: D. PRT reinforces reasonable attempts, not only perfect responses, and uses the item the child wanted as the reinforcer, which keeps motivation high. Requiring an exact imitation is the opposite of the attempts rule. Interspersal is a real PRT component, but no mastered tasks are involved here.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.