cumulative

B.4 Positive vs. negative reinforcement

What the task asks: Classify a consequence as positive or negative reinforcement by asking whether a stimulus was added or removed and whether the behavior then became more frequent.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Reinforcement is the process in which a behavior is followed by a consequence and, as a result, occurs more often in the future. Nearly every teaching procedure in ABA relies on it in some way.

Reinforcement comes in two kinds, and their labels trip up more candidates than almost anything else on the exam. Positive and negative do not mean good and bad. They work like plus and minus signs. Positive reinforcement adds a stimulus. Negative reinforcement removes one. In both, the behavior increases.

Breaking it down

Defined by the effect

A consequence counts as reinforcement only if the behavior it follows becomes more frequent in the future under similar conditions. The stimulus change that has this effect is a reinforcer. Nobody’s intention matters, and neither does how pleasant the consequence looks. A reprimand that makes a student’s calling out more frequent is a reinforcer for that student, whatever the teacher intended.

Two more features matter. Reinforcement works best when the consequence follows the behavior immediately. And its effect depends on current motivation: a snack is a weaker reinforcer right after lunch (see B.16).

The two questions

To classify any consequence, ask two questions in order:

  1. Was a stimulus added or removed right after the behavior?
  2. Did the behavior increase or decrease in the future?
Stimulus added Stimulus removed Behavior increases Behavior decreases Positive reinforcement Praise follows a raised hand. Hand-raising happens more. Negative reinforcement Buckling up stops the chime. Buckling up happens sooner. Positive punishment A reprimand follows calling out. Calling out happens less. Negative punishment Screen time is lost after hitting. Hitting happens less.
The four basic contingencies. Positive and negative only say whether a stimulus was added or removed; reinforcement and punishment say what happened to the behavior afterward.

Reinforcement is the top row. The bottom row, punishment, is covered in B.5. Added includes making something more intense, and removed includes making it less intense: turning down a blaring TV counts as removal. Some theorists, beginning with Michael (1975), argue the two kinds are hard to separate because every consequence changes one condition into another, but the exam expects the standard distinction.

Positive reinforcement

In positive reinforcement, a stimulus appears or increases after the behavior, and the behavior becomes more frequent. A child says “Cookie, please” and gets a cookie. An employee submits a report early and the manager thanks them. A learner hits a peer and an adult rushes over with concern. Each is positive reinforcement if the behavior increases, including the hitting.

Negative reinforcement: escape and avoidance

In negative reinforcement, a stimulus is removed, reduced or postponed after the behavior, and the behavior becomes more frequent. The stimulus taken away is usually one the person would act to get rid of: noise, pain, a hard task, a nagging reminder.

It takes two forms:

  • Escape: the behavior ends a stimulus that is already present. Buckling a seat belt stops the warning chime. A student tears a worksheet and is sent out of the room, ending the task.
  • Avoidance: the behavior prevents or postpones a stimulus before it arrives. Paying a bill early avoids a late fee. A student who asks to see the nurse before every spelling test avoids the test.

Avoidance can be signaled, with a warning stimulus coming first (discriminated avoidance), or unsignaled, with each response simply putting off the stimulus (free-operant avoidance).

Seeing it in practice

ScenarioAdded or removed?Behavior that changedContingency
A child screams in a store until a parent buys candy; screaming in stores increases.Candy addedThe child’s screaming increasesPositive reinforcement (child)
Buying the candy stops the screaming; the parent gives in more often.Screaming removedThe parent’s giving in increasesNegative reinforcement, escape (parent)
A client pushes materials away and the therapist ends the trial; pushing increases.Task removedPushing increasesNegative reinforcement, escape
A nurse double-checks charts before rounds and is never questioned by the attending physician; checking increases.Questioning preventedChecking increasesNegative reinforcement, avoidance
A team lead thanks a staff member for covering a shift; the staff member volunteers more often.Thanks addedVolunteering increasesPositive reinforcement

The store example shows why you should always name whose behavior you are analyzing. One event can reinforce two people’s behavior in two different ways.

Common mix-ups

  • Negative reinforcement is not punishment. Reinforcement always increases behavior. If the behavior goes down, it is punishment, whatever was added or removed.
  • Positive does not mean pleasant. A reprimand, or a peer’s laugh at a rude joke, is positive reinforcement if the behavior increases.
  • Intent does not decide. A teacher sends a student to the hallway “as punishment”, and disruption increases. For that student, leaving class is negative reinforcement (escape).
  • Escape vs. avoidance. Escape ends something already present; avoidance stops something from starting. Check whether the aversive stimulus was there when the behavior occurred.

Exam tip: Ignore words like pleasant, unpleasant, reward and punishment in a stem. Ask only whether something was added or taken away, then whether the behavior went up.

Quick recap

  • Reinforcement increases future behavior and is defined by that effect alone.
  • Positive means a stimulus was added. Negative means one was removed. Neither means good or bad.
  • Negative reinforcement includes escape (ending a present stimulus) and avoidance (preventing one).
  • Negative reinforcement is not punishment.
  • One event can reinforce two people’s behavior in different ways.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 11 and 12.
  • Iwata, B. A. (1987). Negative reinforcement in applied behavior analysis: An emerging technology. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 20(4), 361-378.
  • Michael, J. (1975). Positive and negative reinforcement, a distinction that is no longer necessary; or a better way to talk about bad things. Behaviorism, 3(1), 33-44.

Key terms

Reinforcement
A process in which a behavior is followed by a stimulus change that increases the future frequency of that behavior under similar conditions. It is defined by its effect: if the behavior does not increase, reinforcement has not occurred, however pleasant the consequence seemed or whatever anyone intended.
Reinforcer
A stimulus change that follows a behavior and increases its future frequency. Whether a stimulus works as a reinforcer depends on the person, the behavior and current motivating operations, so something that works today may not work after satiation.
Positive reinforcement (SR+)
Reinforcement in which a stimulus is added, or increased in intensity, right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs more often in the future. Positive means added, not good.
Negative reinforcement (SR-)
Reinforcement in which a stimulus is removed, reduced in intensity or postponed right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs more often in the future. It includes escape and avoidance. Negative means taken away, not bad, and negative reinforcement is not punishment.
Escape contingency (Escape)
A form of negative reinforcement in which a response ends a stimulus that is already present. The behavior becomes more frequent because it has terminated that stimulus in the past.
Avoidance contingency (Avoidance)
A form of negative reinforcement in which a response prevents or postpones a stimulus that has not yet occurred. In discriminated avoidance a warning signal comes first; in free-operant avoidance there is no signal, and each response simply delays the stimulus.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.4. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1During math, Selena puts her head down and says 'I can't.' Her teacher takes the worksheet away and lets her sit quietly. Over the next month, Selena puts her head down during math more and more often. Which contingency is most likely operating?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The worksheet was removed after the behavior, and the behavior increased, which is negative reinforcement (an escape contingency). Negative punishment also involves removal, but it decreases behavior, and Selena's head-down behavior went up.

  2. Question 2Malik finishes his reports the night before every staff meeting where late reports are criticized. Since he started, his manager has never once criticized him in a meeting, and finishing early has become a firm habit. This is best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Finishing early prevents criticism that has not yet happened, and the behavior has increased, so this is avoidance. Escape would require the criticism to be already under way when Malik responded, and nothing in the scenario adds praise.

  3. Question 3A teacher says 'Chloe, stop that!' every time Chloe taps her pencil loudly. Over the following weeks, pencil-tapping becomes more frequent. For Chloe, the reprimand is functioning as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A stimulus (the reprimand) was added after the behavior, and the behavior increased, so the reprimand is a positive reinforcer for Chloe. The teacher meant it as punishment, but the effect on behavior, not the intent, decides the label.

  4. Question 4Which statement about negative reinforcement is accurate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. All reinforcement increases behavior, and negative means a stimulus is taken away or reduced. The two decrease options describe negative and positive punishment, and pleasantness plays no part in the definition.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.