The big idea
A cookie is a strong reinforcer before lunch and a weak one after a large meal. The cookie did not change. The learner’s current condition did. A motivating operation (MO) is an environmental variable that does two things at once: it changes how effective some stimulus is as a reinforcer (or punisher), and it changes how often behavior that has produced that stimulus occurs right now.
The concept comes from Jack Michael’s work and was refined by Laraway, Snycerski, Michael and Poling (2003). It explains why the same contingency works on Monday and fails on Tuesday. It also lets behavior analysts treat “motivation” as something in the environment that can be observed and arranged, not a trait inside the person.
Breaking it down
Two effects of every MO
| Effect | Increase | Decrease |
|---|---|---|
| Value-altering effect (on the consequence) | Reinforcer-establishing effect | Reinforcer-abolishing effect |
| Behavior-altering effect (on current behavior) | Evocative effect | Abative effect |
The value-altering effect changes how effective the consequence is. The behavior-altering effect changes the current frequency of all behavior that has been followed by that consequence. The behavior-altering effect is immediate: it is about what the person does right now, not about learning.
MOs act on punishers too. Being hungry, for example, makes losing a snack a more effective punisher.
Establishing and abolishing operations
An establishing operation (EO) increases the effectiveness of a consequence and evokes behavior that has produced it. Deprivation is the usual example. An abolishing operation (AO) decreases the effectiveness of a consequence and abates behavior that has produced it. Satiation is the usual example.
A note on terms: older papers, including Michael’s, used “establishing operation” for every MO. Laraway et al. (2003) made “motivating operation” the umbrella term, with EO and AO as its two directions. The exam uses the 2003 terms.
Unconditioned MOs
An unconditioned motivating operation (UMO) has a value-altering effect that does not depend on learning. Michael listed deprivation of food, water, sleep, activity, oxygen and sex, becoming too warm, becoming too cold, and an increase in painful stimulation. Reversing each one (eating, drinking, resting, warming up) works as an AO.
The value-altering effect of a UMO is unlearned, but the behavior it evokes is learned. Every hungry person values food; whether they say “I’m hungry,” sign EAT or open the fridge depends on their history.
Conditioned MOs
A conditioned motivating operation (CMO) has a value-altering effect that depends on a learning history. There are three kinds:
- Surrogate CMO (CMO-S): a stimulus that has been paired with another MO comes to have that MO’s effects. If Joaquín has often been cold while waiting at one bus stop, standing there may make his jacket more valuable even on a mild day. Evidence for this type in people is limited, and some authors doubt how often it operates.
- Reflexive CMO (CMO-R): a stimulus that has reliably preceded some worsening makes its own removal reinforcing and evokes behavior that has removed it. A demand that has come before hard work is the classic case, and it is central to escape-maintained problem behavior.
- Transitive CMO (CMO-T): a stimulus that makes another stimulus effective as a reinforcer, usually because that second stimulus is needed to get something else. A locked door makes the key valuable. Mand training often arranges CMO-Ts on purpose (G.5).
How MOs differ from discriminative stimuli is the subject of B.17.
Seeing it in practice
| Scenario | MO | Type | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lunch is late, and Carlos asks for snacks over and over. | Food deprivation | UMO, EO | Food is more valuable; asking for it is evoked. |
| After a long recess in 90-degree heat, students line up at the fountain. | Becoming too warm, water deprivation | UMO, EO | Water and cool air are more valuable. |
| After a holiday dinner, Hannah ignores the dessert she usually asks for. | Food satiation | UMO, AO | Dessert is less valuable; asking is abated. |
| When the therapist says “Table time,” Sam, whose table work has often been hard, pushes the materials away. | Demand paired with difficult work | CMO-R | Removing the demand is valuable; escape is evoked. |
| A painter finds a sealed paint can and asks a coworker for a flathead screwdriver. | The sealed lid | CMO-T | The screwdriver is valuable; asking for it is evoked. |
Common mix-ups
- The MO is not the reinforcer. The MO changes the value of the reinforcer. The reinforcer is what follows the behavior.
- An AO is not extinction. After satiation, the reinforcer is still available but worth less. In extinction, it is no longer delivered.
- Behavior-altering is not learning. An MO changes how often behavior occurs right now. Reinforcement changes future behavior through history.
- CMO-R vs. CMO-T. A CMO-R makes its own removal valuable. A CMO-T makes something else valuable.
- A UMO’s behavior is still learned. Only the value-altering effect is unlearned.
Exam tip: Ask whether something changed how effective a consequence is right now. If yes, you are looking at an MO. Then classify it: increase (EO) or decrease (AO); unlearned (UMO) or learned (CMO); and if learned, whether it borrows another MO’s effect (CMO-S), makes its own removal valuable (CMO-R) or makes another item valuable (CMO-T).
Quick recap
- An MO alters the value of a consequence and the current frequency of behavior that has produced it.
- Value-altering: establishing or abolishing. Behavior-altering: evocative or abative.
- EOs increase value and evoke; AOs decrease value and abate.
- UMOs work without learning (deprivation, temperature, pain); CMOs depend on history.
- The three CMOs are surrogate, reflexive and transitive.
Further reading
- Laraway, S., Snycerski, S., Michael, J., & Poling, A. (2003). Motivating operations and terms to describe them: Some further refinements. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 36(3), 407-414.
- Michael, J. (1993). Establishing operations. The Behavior Analyst, 16(2), 191-206.
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 16.
Key terms
- Motivating operation (MO)
- An environmental variable that temporarily changes how effective a stimulus is as a reinforcer or punisher (the value-altering effect) and changes how often behavior that has produced that stimulus occurs (the behavior-altering effect).
- Establishing operation (EO)
- A motivating operation that increases the reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus and evokes behavior that has produced that stimulus in the past.
- Abolishing operation (AO)
- A motivating operation that decreases the reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus and abates behavior that has produced that stimulus in the past.
- Value-altering effect
- The effect of a motivating operation on how effective a consequence is. A reinforcer-establishing effect makes the consequence more effective; a reinforcer-abolishing effect makes it less effective.
- Behavior-altering effect
- The effect of a motivating operation on the current frequency of behavior that has been followed by the relevant consequence. An evocative effect increases that behavior right now; an abative effect decreases it.
- Unconditioned motivating operation (UMO)
- A motivating operation whose value-altering effect does not depend on a learning history. Examples include deprivation of food, water, sleep, activity, oxygen or sex, becoming too warm or too cold, and painful stimulation. The behavior it evokes is still learned.
- Conditioned motivating operation (CMO)
- A motivating operation whose value-altering effect depends on a learning history. The three types are surrogate (CMO-S), reflexive (CMO-R) and transitive (CMO-T).
Check yourself
4 questions on B.16. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: B. Food deprivation makes food more effective as a reinforcer without any learning history and increases behavior that has produced food, so it is an unconditioned establishing operation. It is not an SD: snacks are not more available on those days, just more valuable.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Because the direction has preceded something aversive, its own removal (and escape from what follows) has become reinforcing, and it evokes escape behavior. That is a reflexive CMO. A transitive CMO would make some other item valuable, and the effect here depends on learning, so it is not unconditioned.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Satiation has lowered the value of game time (reinforcer-abolishing) and reduced asking to play (abative). This is not extinction, because game time is still available when he asks; it simply is not worth much to him right now.
Show the answer
Answer: B. The step makes a different stimulus, the hex key, effective as a reinforcer because the key is needed to finish the job. That is a transitive CMO. It does not signal that a key is available (the roommate's presence does that), so it is not an SD.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.