cumulative

B.7 Unconditioned, conditioned, and generalized reinforcers

What the task asks: Tell apart reinforcers that work without learning, reinforcers that gained their effect through pairing, and conditioned reinforcers backed by many other reinforcers.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Reinforcers (see B.4) differ in where their power comes from. Some work because of biology: food, water and warmth strengthen behavior in every human without any learning. Others work because of history: a smile, a gold star or a paycheck has no value until it has been linked with other reinforcers.

Knowing the difference tells you what to do when a learner has few reinforcers. You cannot teach someone to need water, but you can teach them to value praise, tokens or a high five by pairing those stimuli with things that already work.

Breaking it down

Unconditioned reinforcers

An unconditioned reinforcer (also called a primary or unlearned reinforcer) works without any prior learning. Its effect comes from the evolutionary history of the species. Examples include food, water, oxygen, warmth and sexual stimulation. The removal of painful stimulation works the same way for negative reinforcement.

Unconditioned does not mean always effective. Food is a strong reinforcer for a hungry person and a weak one right after a big meal. The effectiveness of every reinforcer depends on motivating operations such as deprivation and satiation (see B.16).

Conditioned reinforcers

A conditioned reinforcer (also called a secondary or learned reinforcer) was once neutral. It gained its reinforcing effect through stimulus-stimulus pairing: it was repeatedly presented together with, or just before, an unconditioned reinforcer or an established conditioned reinforcer. Praise, a thumbs-up, grades, a notification sound and the click in clicker training are conditioned reinforcers for people with the right history.

Two practical points follow:

  • They depend on the person’s history. A sticker chart that motivates one child may mean nothing to another who has never had stickers paired with anything.
  • They can lose their effect. If a conditioned reinforcer stops being paired with its backup reinforcers, it gradually weakens. Tokens that can no longer be exchanged stop working.

Many everyday reinforcers, such as a favorite show or a particular toy, owe at least part of their effect to learning, even when some of the stimulation they produce may be unconditioned.

Generalized conditioned reinforcers

A generalized conditioned reinforcer is a conditioned reinforcer that has been paired with many different reinforcers. Because so many back it up, it keeps working across a wide range of motivating conditions. It does not depend on the person being hungry, thirsty or bored in one particular way.

Money is the textbook example: it buys food, rent, music and travel, so it stays effective right after a meal. Tokens in a well-designed token economy (see G.4), exchangeable for many backup items and activities, work the same way. Attention and approval are generalized for most people, because they have come before a huge variety of other reinforcers across a lifetime.

The practical advantage is resistance to satiation. A learner may tire of crackers after twenty trials, but tokens exchangeable for crackers, bubbles, a song or a break keep their value much longer.

Conditioned One backup reinforcer Token buys Candy Works only while candy is wanted Generalized conditioned Many backup reinforcers Points Snacks Games Outings Free time Keeps working when any one backup loses value
A token that buys only candy is a conditioned reinforcer, and its value rises and falls with the learner's interest in candy. Points backed by many reinforcers are generalized and keep working when the learner tires of any one of them.

Seeing it in practice

StimulusTypeWhy
Water after a long runUnconditionedWorks with no learning, given deprivation
A coach’s “Great hustle!”Conditioned (often generalized)Gained value through pairing with other good outcomes
A token that buys only one brand of candyConditioned, not generalizedBacked by a single reinforcer
Points exchangeable for snacks, games, outings or free timeGeneralized conditionedBacked by many reinforcers
A paycheckGeneralized conditionedExchangeable for almost anything

Building a conditioned reinforcer in a clinic: Nia, age 4, is new to services and responds only to edible items. During play, her therapist says “Yes!” in an excited voice and immediately gives her a small piece of a preferred snack, many times across several sessions. Then the therapist tests it. Does “Yes!” alone, delivered right after Nia stacks a block, increase stacking? When it does, praise has become a conditioned reinforcer, and the team can begin relying less on snacks.

1. Pair, many times "Yes!" "Yes!" "Yes!" Praise, then a piece of snack 2. Test it alone Stacks block "Yes!" Does stacking increase? If so, praise is a reinforcer
Building praise into a conditioned reinforcer for Nia. "Yes!" is first paired with a snack many times, then delivered alone after stacking; it counts as a reinforcer only if stacking increases.

Common mix-ups

  • Conditioned does not mean weak. Money and approval can control adult behavior more powerfully than food.
  • Unconditioned does not mean always effective. Every reinforcer depends on motivating operations.
  • Generalized needs many backups. A token exchanged for only one item is a conditioned reinforcer, but not a generalized one.
  • Tangible is not a type in this task. Toys and snacks are described by how they got their effect (learning or biology), not by whether you can hold them.
  • Pairing must be checked. Pairing praise with snacks does not guarantee that praise becomes a reinforcer, and researchers still debate which pairing arrangements work most reliably. Test whether the stimulus increases behavior on its own.

Exam tip: Ask where the stimulus got its power. Biology alone: unconditioned. Pairing with one or a few reinforcers: conditioned. Pairing with many reinforcers, so it works regardless of current deprivation: generalized conditioned.

Quick recap

  • Unconditioned reinforcers work without learning, but their effect still depends on motivating operations.
  • Conditioned reinforcers gain their effect through stimulus-stimulus pairing and can lose it if pairing stops.
  • Generalized conditioned reinforcers are backed by many reinforcers and resist satiation.
  • Money, tokens with varied backups, and social approval are common generalized conditioned reinforcers.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 11.
  • Hackenberg, T. D. (2009). Token reinforcement: A review and analysis. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 91(2), 257-286.

Key terms

Reinforcer
A stimulus change that follows a behavior and increases its future frequency. Whether a stimulus works as a reinforcer depends on the person, the behavior and current motivating operations, so something that works today may not work after satiation.
Unconditioned reinforcer (Primary reinforcer, Unlearned reinforcer)
A stimulus that functions as a reinforcer without any learning history, because of the evolutionary history of the species. Examples include food, water, oxygen, warmth and sexual stimulation. Its effectiveness still depends on motivating operations such as deprivation and satiation.
Conditioned reinforcer (Secondary reinforcer, Learned reinforcer)
A formerly neutral stimulus that functions as a reinforcer because it has been paired with unconditioned reinforcers or with other conditioned reinforcers. Its effect comes from the person's learning history, and it weakens if the pairing is not maintained.
Generalized conditioned reinforcer (Generalized reinforcer)
A conditioned reinforcer that has been paired with many other reinforcers, so it works across a wide range of motivating operations rather than depending on deprivation of any one thing. It resists satiation better than a reinforcer backed by a single item.
Stimulus-stimulus pairing (Pairing)
Presenting a neutral stimulus together with, or just before, a stimulus that already has a function, so that the neutral stimulus acquires a similar function. Pairing establishes conditioned stimuli, conditioned reinforcers and conditioned punishers. The same name is also used for a specific procedure that pairs an adult's speech sounds with preferred items to increase a child's vocalizations.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.7. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Teens in a vocational program earn points they can exchange for snacks, music time, phone time or outings. The points keep working even right after lunch. The points are best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The points were not valuable until they were paired with backup reinforcers, and because they are backed by many different ones, they keep working whatever the teens currently want. That makes them generalized conditioned reinforcers. A conditioned reinforcer with a single backup would lose its effect when the person was satiated on that one item.

  2. Question 2A therapist repeatedly says 'Awesome!' just before giving a learner a bite of a favorite snack. Later, saying 'Awesome!' alone right after the learner points to a picture increases pointing. What gave 'Awesome!' its effect?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The word was presented just before an established reinforcer until it acquired a reinforcing effect of its own, which is how conditioned reinforcers are built. Generalization would require the word to resemble the snack, which it does not.

  3. Question 3A client who has just finished a large bottle of water no longer works for sips of water during a session. What does this show?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Water is an unconditioned reinforcer, but satiation temporarily reduces its effectiveness. Unconditioned means its effect needs no learning history, not that it works under all conditions. The effect will return when the client is thirsty again.

  4. Question 4Which stimulus is most likely an unconditioned reinforcer for a typical adult?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Warmth works as a reinforcer without any learning, especially after exposure to cold. Praise in a text, a star rating and a certificate are conditioned: each gained its value through pairing with other reinforcers over the person's history.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.