cumulative

B.2 Stimulus and stimulus class

What the task asks: Tell a single stimulus apart from a stimulus class, and recognize the ways stimuli are grouped: by form, timing or function, and as feature or arbitrary classes.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Behavior always happens in an environment, and behavior analysts break that environment into stimuli: specific energy changes a person can detect. A stimulus class is a group of stimuli that belong together because they share something.

Stimulus classes are the mirror image of response classes (see B.1). Many different responses can count as one unit, and many different stimuli can work as one. That is why a child who learns to say “dog” to the family beagle can also say it to a poodle at the park, and why a learner can treat the numeral 5 and the word five as the same thing.

Breaking it down

Stimulus

In plain terms, a stimulus is anything in or around a person that their senses can pick up: something seen, heard, smelled, tasted or felt, including changes inside the body. A ringing phone, a teacher saying “Line up”, the smell of coffee and a growling stomach are all stimuli.

Stimuli are also described by when they occur relative to behavior:

  • An antecedent is a stimulus or condition present before the behavior.
  • A consequence is a stimulus change that follows the behavior.

These are positions, not kinds of stimuli. A classmate’s laugh is a consequence of one joke and an antecedent for the next.

Consequence of joke 1 Joke 1 Laugh Joke 2 Laugh Antecedent for joke 2
The same laugh sits in two positions at once: it follows the first joke as a consequence and comes before the second as an antecedent.

Stimulus class

A stimulus class is a group of stimuli that share common elements along one or more of three dimensions:

  • Formal: shared physical features, such as color, size, shape or loudness. All the red objects on a shelf form a formal class.
  • Temporal: shared position in time relative to a behavior. All the antecedents of a behavior form one temporal class, and all its consequences form another.
  • Functional: shared effect on behavior. Every stimulus that evokes a child’s stopping belongs to one functional class, whether it is a red octagon, a raised hand or the word stop.

The functional dimension matters most in practice. Stimuli in a functional class can look nothing alike, and stimuli that look alike can have different functions.

Feature and arbitrary stimulus classes

Stimulus classes can also be sorted by how membership arises. This distinction comes from the study of stimulus control and concept learning (see B.12 and B.21).

A feature stimulus class has members that share physical features or a common relation. Dogs, trees, the letter A in every font, and anything “larger than” something else are feature classes. Because the features define the class, it has an open-ended number of members, and a learner can respond correctly to new members without being taught each one.

An arbitrary stimulus class has members that evoke the same response but share no physical features. The numeral 3, the printed word three, the spoken word “three” and a picture of three apples look and sound nothing alike. They belong together only because of learning, often through equivalence relations, and the class has a limited number of members.

Feature class Members share physical features Says "car" New cars join without teaching Arbitrary class Members share no physical features cat "cat" Picks the toy cat Linked only by learning
Cars of any make share features, so a new car can join the class without teaching. A picture of a cat, the printed word cat and the spoken word share nothing physical and belong together only through learning.

Seeing it in practice

ExampleStimulus or classDimension or type
The school bell ringing at 3:00 todayA single stimulusOne energy change
A red apple, a red ball and a red crayonStimulus classFormal (shared color)
Everything that follows a learner’s scream: a sigh, “What’s wrong?”, a pat on the backStimulus classTemporal (all consequences)
A raised palm, the word wait and a “wait” card, each of which evokes waitingStimulus classFunctional
Cars of every make, color and size, all of which a child calls “car”Feature stimulus classShared physical features
A photo of a cat, the printed word cat and the spoken word “cat”Arbitrary stimulus classLinked by learning, no shared form

A classroom example ties these together. Ms. Okafor is teaching Rafael to identify coins. At first, Rafael calls every round silver coin “nickel”. He is responding to a feature class (round and silver) that is too broad. Teaching narrows the class until “nickel” is evoked only by nickels. Later, Ms. Okafor teaches Rafael to match a nickel to the printed word nickel and to the label 5 cents, building an arbitrary class. The coins never change; Rafael’s history with them does.

Common mix-ups

  • Formal is not the same as functional. Stimuli that look alike may control different behavior (a red apple and a red stop sign), and stimuli that look different may control the same behavior.
  • Feature is not the same as arbitrary. If the members share a physical property or relation, it is a feature class. If they are linked only by learning, it is arbitrary.
  • Antecedent and consequence are positions, not types. The same event can be either, depending on when it occurs relative to the behavior.
  • A functional class belongs to a learner. A teacher may group pictures on a worksheet, but they form a functional class for a learner only if they actually control the same behavior for that learner.
  • Stimulus is the general term. Reinforcers, punishers, discriminative stimuli and conditioned stimuli are all stimuli with particular functions.

Exam tip: If the stimuli in a question share a physical feature, think formal or feature class. If they control the same response but share no physical features, think arbitrary class. If they are grouped only by when they occur, think temporal.

Quick recap

  • A stimulus is an energy change detected through the senses.
  • A stimulus class is a group of stimuli sharing formal, temporal or functional elements.
  • Antecedents come before behavior; consequences follow it.
  • Feature classes share physical features or relations and have open-ended membership.
  • Arbitrary classes share no physical features and are built through learning, such as equivalence relations.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 2 and 17.
  • Sidman, M., & Tailby, W. (1982). Conditional discrimination vs. matching to sample: An expansion of the testing paradigm. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 5-22.

Key terms

Stimulus
An energy change that affects an organism through its receptor cells (its senses). Stimuli can arise outside the body, such as a sound or a spoken word, or inside it, such as a stomachache, and they can come before a behavior (antecedents) or after it (consequences).
Stimulus class
A group of stimuli that share common elements along at least one dimension: formal (shared physical features such as color, size or shape), temporal (they all occur before, or all occur after, a behavior) or functional (they all have the same effect on behavior).
Feature stimulus class
A stimulus class whose members share physical features or a common relation, such as 'larger than' or 'on top of'. Because membership depends on shared features, the class is open-ended, and a learner can respond correctly to members they have never encountered.
Arbitrary stimulus class
A stimulus class whose members evoke the same response but share no physical features or relations. Membership comes from learning, often through equivalence relations, and the class has a limited number of members.
Antecedent
A stimulus or environmental condition that is present or occurs before a behavior. Antecedents can evoke or abate operant behavior because of past consequences (discriminative stimuli, motivating operations) or elicit respondent behavior.
Consequence
A stimulus change that follows a behavior. Some consequences change the future frequency of the behavior they follow (reinforcers and punishers), especially when they are immediate; others have little or no effect.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.2. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A teacher lists everything that happens right after a student calls out: classmates laugh, the teacher says the student's name and the aide walks over. Grouping these events by when they occur relative to the call-out describes which kind of stimulus class?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The events are grouped because they all follow the behavior, which is a temporal dimension. They do not share physical features, so the grouping is not formal or feature-based. They might also turn out to share a function, but that is not how the stem says they were grouped.

  2. Question 2A learner reliably says 'seven' when shown the numeral 7, the printed word seven and a card with seven dots. These three stimuli are best described as:
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The three stimuli evoke the same response but share no physical features, so they form an arbitrary stimulus class built through learning. A feature or formal class would require the members to look or sound alike in some way.

  3. Question 3A toddler has only ever seen the family's orange cat. On a visit to the library, the toddler points to a black cat, a cat in a picture book and a cat statue and says 'kitty' each time. What does this show?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The new cats share physical features with the family cat, and feature classes are open-ended, so the toddler responds correctly to members never seen before. An arbitrary class would contain members with no shared features, such as the printed word cat.

  4. Question 4Which statement about stimuli is accurate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Antecedent and consequence describe position in time relative to a behavior, so a classmate's laugh can follow one joke and come before the next. Stimuli can arise inside the body, and stimuli that look alike can have different functions.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.