cumulative

F.7 Deciding whether services or a referral are needed

What the task asks: Interpret assessment results to judge whether behavior-analytic services are warranted, whether another professional is needed, or both.

Behavior Assessment5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Assessment has to answer two questions before any goal is written. First, is there a socially significant problem that behavior-analytic services can address? Second, does part of the problem belong to someone else, such as a physician, psychologist, speech-language pathologist or occupational therapist?

The answer can be yes to both. A child with frequent self-injury and untreated ear pain needs a physician and a behavior analyst. Recognizing the limits of what behavior analysis, and you personally, can offer protects the client and keeps services honest.

Breaking it down

When behavior-analytic services are indicated

The data show behavior that matters in the client’s life and is sensitive to environmental variables, for example:

  • Behavioral excesses that cause harm, block learning or limit access to settings (aggression, self-injury, elopement)
  • Skill deficits that affect independence, communication or relationships, with a clear gap between current and needed performance
  • Behavior that persists after medical causes are treated, or that co-occurs with them

When services may not be indicated

  • The behavior is within the typical range for the person’s age and community, and neither the client nor the family is concerned.
  • The main need lies outside behavior analysis, such as a mental health crisis or an untreated medical condition.
  • Earlier behavioral services did not help, and nothing in the data suggests a different behavioral approach would.

When to refer, and to whom

Sign in the data or recordsPossible referral
Sudden change in behavior, signs of pain, sleep problems, seizures, weight loss, behavior that began after a medication changePhysician or other medical provider (Standard 2.12, Considering Medical Needs)
Coughing or choking while eating, a very restricted dietPhysician, plus a speech-language pathologist or occupational therapist with feeding expertise
Statements about self-harm, or signs of trauma, depression or psychosisLicensed mental health professional, urgently when there is risk
Articulation or voice concerns, or a need for an augmentative device evaluationSpeech-language pathologist
Fine motor, sensory or physical limits that affect daily tasksOccupational or physical therapist
Hearing or vision concernsAudiologist or eye-care specialist

Physical conditions often act as setting events: they do not trigger behavior directly but make it more likely, which is why they can hide behind what looks like a social function.

Scope of practice and scope of competence

Scope of practice is what the profession of behavior analysis covers, as defined by the field and, in many places, by law. Scope of competence is the narrower set of activities you personally can perform proficiently. A case can fall inside the first and outside the second, such as severe pediatric feeding problems for an analyst with no feeding training. Standard 1.05 (Practicing within Scope of Competence) requires you to get training, supervision or consultation first, or to refer. Standard 3.03 (Accepting Clients) adds that you accept only cases within your competence and available resources.

Making a good referral

A referral directs the client to another professional for a need you should not address alone. Standard 3.13 (Referrals) sets the expectations: base the referral on the client’s needs, offer more than one provider when available, disclose any relationship or financial incentive, document it and follow up. Share information only with consent (see E.4). When services continue during the referral, coordinate with the other provider (H.8).

Assessment data and records Signs of a medical, mental health or other non-behavioral need? Yes Refer; document and follow up (Standard 3.13) No Both can apply Socially significant behavior that is sensitive to the environment? No Not indicated: explain why, offer resources Yes Within your scope of competence? No Get training, supervision or consultation, or refer (Standard 1.05) Yes Provide services; coordinate with other providers (H.8)
The questions in order. A sign of another need is referred first, but a referral does not close the case: if a socially significant behavioral need remains, services can run alongside it, within your competence.

Seeing it in practice

Client and dataDecision
Hana, 5: FA shows hitting maintained by access to a tablet; no medical concerns in recordsServices indicated; begin function-based treatment
Victor, 8: night waking and new head hitting; he pulls at his earsRefer to his pediatrician first; continue assessment once pain is ruled out or treated
Adele, 15: occasional homework procrastination; grades and family relationships are goodLittle need for services; explain why and offer simple resources
Sam, 23: self-advocacy goals; also reports weeks of low mood and hopelessnessRefer to a licensed mental health professional; behavioral services may continue for agreed goals
Liya, 4: severe food selectivity and weight lossMedical and feeding evaluation; an analyst without feeding training seeks consultation or refers

Common mix-ups

  • Referring is not abandoning. A referral can run alongside behavioral services. What matters is that each need is addressed by someone competent.
  • Medical before experimental analysis. If records or observations suggest pain or illness, a medical check comes before a functional analysis, which would otherwise test the wrong variables.
  • Scope of practice is not scope of competence. The first is about the profession; the second is about you.
  • Funding is not need. An authorization for hours does not show that services are warranted, and a lack of funding does not show that they are not.
  • Diagnosing medical or psychiatric conditions is outside behavior-analytic practice. Describe what you observe and refer.

Exam tip: When a scenario hints at a biological cause (sudden onset, pain behavior, sleep or medication changes), pick the answer that refers to a medical professional and documents the referral, not the one that launches straight into a behavioral intervention.

Quick recap

  • Decide whether there is a socially significant, behavior-related need, and whether any part of it belongs to another discipline.
  • Medical concerns are referred first, under Standard 2.12.
  • Stay within your scope of competence (Standard 1.05); seek training or consultation, or refer, when a case falls outside it.
  • Good referrals follow Standard 3.13: based on need, more than one option, relationships disclosed, documented and followed up.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 31.

Key terms

Referral
Directing a client to another professional or service for needs outside the behavior analyst's scope of practice or competence, such as medical, mental health, speech-language or occupational therapy services, with consent, documentation and follow-up.
Scope of competence
The professional activities that an individual behavior analyst can consistently perform well, based on their education, training and supervised experience. It is narrower than the profession's scope of practice.
Scope of practice
The range of activities that a profession as a whole, or a licensing law, recognizes as belonging to that profession. An activity can fall within behavior analysis's scope of practice and still lie outside a particular practitioner's scope of competence.
Setting event
A condition or event, often earlier in time or ongoing, that changes how likely a behavior is in a later situation, for example by altering how effective a consequence is. Many behavior analysts now analyze these effects as motivating operations.

Check yourself

5 questions on F.7. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Victor, 8, began hitting his head two weeks ago. His parents report that he now wakes often at night and pulls at his ears. What should the behavior analyst do first?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Sudden onset, sleep disruption and ear pulling together suggest a possible medical cause such as ear pain, so a medical referral comes first under Standard 2.12. A functional analysis would test social consequences while the likely driver went unaddressed.

  2. Question 2A behavior analyst trained only in early intervention is asked to treat a teenager with severe food refusal and weight loss. No consultant with feeding expertise is available. What best fits the Ethics Code?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Feeding problems can fall within behavior analysis, but this analyst lacks the competence, and weight loss raises medical risk. Standard 1.05 calls for training, supervision or consultation first, or a referral. Declining without helping the family find appropriate care leaves the need unmet.

  3. Question 3Which statement best describes the difference between scope of practice and scope of competence?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Scope of practice describes the activities that belong to the profession, often defined in law. Scope of competence is narrower: what you personally can perform proficiently. A case can be inside the first and outside the second.

  4. Question 4A behavior analyst is referring a family to a speech-language pathologist. Under Standard 3.13 (Referrals), which action is expected?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Referrals should be based on the client's needs, include multiple providers when available, and disclose any relationships or incentives, with documentation and follow-up. Sending records first would breach confidentiality, because consent is needed before information is shared.

  5. Question 5At intake, a parent requests services because their 6-year-old interrupts adults during phone calls a few times a week. The child does well at school, and assessment shows no other concerns. What is the best interpretation?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The behavior is mild, infrequent and within a typical range for the child's age, so the data do not show a need for intensive services. Recommending comprehensive services or a full functional analysis would not match what the assessment found.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.