cumulative

J.4 Cultural humility, responsiveness and competence in depth

In this guide: Separates cultural humility, responsiveness and competence, then shows what each looks like in assessment, goals, family work, supervision and responses to autistic critics of ABA.

Beyond the Exam6 min read4 practice questionsNot on the exam

The big idea

E.9, E.10 and E.11 cover what the exam asks: humility as a stance, responsiveness as action, and bias as something you check in yourself. This guide goes further: where the terms came from, how they differ, what the 2022 ethics code changed, and harder questions such as language access and criticism from autistic self-advocates.

One way to hold the three terms: cultural competence is what you know and can do, cultural humility is how you hold that knowledge, and cultural responsiveness is what you actually change for the person in front of you. Knowledge without humility turns into stereotype. Humility without skill helps no one. Responsiveness without either is guesswork.

Breaking it down

Where the terms come from

Competence frameworks from counseling psychology describe awareness of your own values, knowledge of other worldviews and skills for working across them (Sue, Arredondo, & McDavis, 1992). Tervalon and Murray-García (1998) argued that treating competence as mastery of a finite body of knowledge was the wrong goal for physician training. They proposed cultural humility instead: lifelong self-evaluation, redressing power imbalances between professional and patient, and partnership with communities. In behavior analysis, Fong et al. (2016) described culture as contingencies that shape everyone, including the analyst, and offered practical steps for building cultural awareness. Wright (2019) adapted a social work self-reflection framework into a self-management routine.

What the 2022 code changed

The earlier code dealt with differences mainly by banning discrimination and by calling for training, consultation or referral when differences affected the work. The current code, in effect since January 1, 2022, asks for active, ongoing behavior:

  • Standard 1.07 (Cultural Responsiveness and Diversity): professional development in cultural responsiveness, evaluating your own biases and ability to serve diverse needs, and evaluating the same in supervisees and trainees.
  • Standard 1.08 (Nondiscrimination): equitable and inclusive conduct, with a longer list of characteristics that now names immigration status and gender expression or identity.
  • Standard 1.10 (Awareness of Personal Biases and Challenges): awareness that bias may interfere, steps to resolve it, and documentation of what was done.
  • Standard 4.07 (Incorporating and Addressing Diversity): diversity topics actively built into supervision and training.

The core principle on competence also names cultural responsiveness, and the code’s decision-making steps include considering your own learning history and biases.

Self-assessment

Evaluating your own biases needs concrete behavior, not a feeling of open-mindedness:

  • Write a short cultural self-description: your family’s rules about eye contact, independence, food, discipline, disability and outside help. Notice which ones feel “normal” rather than “ours.”
  • Audit your own records: which families get which goals, whose behavior you label “noncompliance,” and how often you close cases for different groups.
  • Use a published self-assessment checklist and discuss it with a supervisor or peer.
  • Ask families and supervisees for candid feedback through a safe channel.

Beaulieu, Addington, and Almeida (2019) surveyed BCBAs and found that most rated diversity training as important and felt reasonably skilled, yet most reported little formal training. Self-assessment is where that gap tends to show.

Responsive assessment and goals

  • Ask about routines before choosing targets: who feeds whom, where the child sleeps, what independence looks like at each age in this family.
  • Build preference assessments from the family’s foods, music and games.
  • Read behavior in context: quiet deference to adults, or avoiding eye contact with elders, may be expected in a family, not a deficit.
  • Choose goals with the family and the client (Standard 2.09, Involving Clients and Stakeholders), and measure social validity rather than assume it.

Language access and work with families

  • Use qualified interpreters, not children or untrained relatives, for intake, consent and training.
  • Brief the interpreter on technical terms beforehand, and speak to the caregiver, not to the interpreter.
  • Check understanding with teach-back: the caregiver explains the plan in their own words (Standard 2.08, Communicating About Services).
  • Give written materials in the family’s language, in plain words.
  • Learn how the family makes decisions and who should be in the room, which may include grandparents or other relatives.
  • Name the power you hold, such as reports and funder contacts, and invite disagreement.

Dennison et al. (2019) offer practical guidance for home-based work with linguistically diverse families.

Neurodiversity and autistic critiques

The neurodiversity paradigm treats autism as natural human variation, with much of the disability arising from a poor fit between person and environment (Pellicano & den Houting, 2022). Many autistic adults criticize ABA. Common points:

  • goals aimed at looking “indistinguishable” from peers, such as suppressing harmless stimming or requiring eye contact;
  • compliance training that teaches people to override their own discomfort;
  • intensive hours that leave little time for ordinary childhood;
  • past use of aversive procedures, and little autistic input into research and practice.

Anderson (2023) interviewed seven autistic adults who had ABA as children. They recalled distressing experiences and lasting harm alongside some benefits, and urged practitioners to listen to autistic people. Leaf et al. (2022) examined common concerns and argued that many reflect poor or outdated practice. Veneziano and Shea (2023) concluded that concerns about indistinguishability as a goal have legitimacy. Mathur, Renz, and Tarbox (2024) proposed ways to bring the neurodiversity paradigm into ABA.

A fair reading: some critiques target practices the field now rejects, some describe problems that still happen, and the people who received services know things no credential replaces. Neurodiversity-affirming practice usually means choosing goals that improve quality of life and self-determination rather than how typical someone looks, leaving harmless stimming alone, teaching self-advocacy and refusal, monitoring assent, and involving autistic people in planning.

Seeing it in practice

SituationCompetenceHumilityResponsiveness
Rosa’s grandmother, her main caregiver, speaks TagalogKnows how to work well with an interpreterAsks what she wants for RosaBooks a qualified interpreter and translates the plan
A teen objects to an eye-contact goalKnows eye-contact norms varyListens to their reasonsDrops the goal, and teaches other listening signals if they want them
A supervisee never disagrees in meetingsKnows power differentials suppress feedbackAsks whether supervision feels safeAdds an anonymous feedback form and invites dissent
A supervisee writes “reduce hand flapping”Knows the social validity literatureAsks who wants it changed, and whyRewrites the goal around what the client values

Common mix-ups

  • Competence is not a certificate. A course is a start, not a finish line.
  • Humility is not passivity. You still bring expertise and data, and you still act on risk to the client.
  • Responsiveness is not stereotyping. Adapt to this family, not to a description of their group.
  • Neurodiversity-affirming does not mean no goals. Communication, safety, health and self-care skills remain priorities, chosen with the person.
  • Listening to critics is not agreeing with every claim. It means weighing their reports as data, including first-person accounts.

Exam tip: The exam tests the stance and the standards (E.9 to E.11). Choose answers in which the behavior analyst asks, reflects, involves the family and documents. The history of the terms and the neurodiversity debate go beyond it.

Quick recap

  • Competence is knowledge and skill, humility is the ongoing stance, and responsiveness is the change you make.
  • Standards 1.07, 1.08, 1.10 and 4.07 require active development, self-evaluation, documentation and diversity in supervision.
  • Use qualified interpreters, teach-back and goals chosen with the family and client.
  • Take autistic self-advocates’ critiques seriously and judge goals by the client’s quality of life.

Further reading

  • Tervalon, M., & Murray-García, J. (1998). Cultural humility versus cultural competence: A critical distinction in defining physician training outcomes in multicultural education. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 9(2), 117-125.
  • Fong, E. H., Catagnus, R. M., Brodhead, M. T., Quigley, S., & Field, S. (2016). Developing the cultural awareness skills of behavior analysts. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9(1), 84-94.
  • Wright, P. I. (2019). Cultural humility in the practice of applied behavior analysis. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 12(4), 805-809.
  • Mathur, S. K., Renz, E., & Tarbox, J. (2024). Affirming neurodiversity within applied behavior analysis. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 17(2), 471-485.

Key terms

Cultural humility
An ongoing stance of self-reflection and openness in which a professional treats their own cultural perspective as one among many, recognizes the limits of what they know about other people's cultures, and keeps learning from the people they serve and work with.
Cultural responsiveness
Adapting assessment, goals, procedures, communication and supervision so they fit the culture, values, language and circumstances of the people involved. Standard 1.07 (Cultural Responsiveness and Diversity) requires ongoing professional development in it.
Cultural competence
The knowledge and skills needed to work effectively with people whose cultures differ from one's own. Treating it as something to master can imply a finish line and invite generalizations about groups, which is why many writers pair it with cultural humility.
Culture
In behavioral terms, the practices, values and verbal behavior shared by a group and passed on through the group's contingencies. Everyone belongs to at least one culture, including the behavior analyst, and culture includes religion, language, disability, region and class as well as ethnicity.
Power differential
A difference in authority between two people, such as when a supervisor controls a supervisee's hours, evaluations, references or employment. It can make it hard for the person with less power to refuse requests, raise concerns or admit mistakes.
Social validity
The extent to which the goals, procedures and outcomes of an intervention are acceptable, important and useful to the people it affects, such as clients, caregivers and supervisees. It is usually measured with surveys, interviews or rating scales.
Neurodiversity-affirming practice
Services that treat autism and other neurological differences as natural human variation. In behavior analysis this usually means choosing goals that improve quality of life and self-determination rather than how typical someone looks, leaving harmless behavior such as stimming alone, teaching self-advocacy, monitoring assent and involving autistic people in planning.
Culturally responsive supervision
Supervision that adapts its goals, examples and delivery to the supervisee's cultural and linguistic background, and that teaches the supervisee to serve clients from diverse backgrounds. It starts by asking the individual rather than assuming preferences from group membership.

Check yourself

4 questions on J.4. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Which statement best captures the distinction Tervalon and Murray-García (1998) drew between cultural humility and cultural competence?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. They argued that treating competence as mastery of a finite body of knowledge was the wrong goal, and proposed humility: ongoing self-evaluation, attention to power imbalances and partnership with communities. Humility does not mean giving up professional judgment, and it is the opposite of relying on facts about groups.

  2. Question 2Through a qualified interpreter, a BCBA explains a new toileting plan to Mrs. Nguyen. Which step best confirms that she understood it?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Teach-back shows comprehension directly, which Standard 2.08 (Communicating About Services) requires. Many people say they have no questions out of politeness or deference to a professional, especially when a power differential is present. A signature records receipt, not understanding, and the interpreter's impression is not the caregiver's own report.

  3. Question 3Eli, 14, is autistic. He tells his BCBA that working on a goal to reduce his hand flapping makes school harder, because he has to concentrate on not flapping. The flapping causes no injury and does not disrupt class. What is the most defensible response?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. A goal that targets harmless behavior and costs the client effort and comfort has weak social validity from the client's own perspective, and his report is meaningful data. Standard 2.09 (Involving Clients and Stakeholders) includes the client in goal selection. Consent at intake does not settle the matter once the client raises a concern.

  4. Question 4Under the current ethics code, which of the following is part of Standard 1.07 (Cultural Responsiveness and Diversity)?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Standard 1.07 asks behavior analysts to build knowledge and skill in cultural responsiveness, evaluate their own biases and ability to serve diverse needs, and evaluate the same in supervisees and trainees. The code does not require referral or matching by background. Standard 4.07 asks supervisors to raise diversity topics actively, not wait to be asked.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.