The big idea
F.6 covers what the exam expects: the standard functional analysis (FA) conditions and the basic rationale for the interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis (IISCA). This guide covers how the IISCA is run, the treatment built on it, and an open research debate.
The IISCA (Hanley, Jin, Vanselow, & Hanratty, 2014) starts from a plain observation: in daily life, reinforcers often arrive together. When a child screams as tablet time ends, an adult may return the tablet, drop the request to come to dinner and offer comfort at once. The IISCA tests that combination against a matched control.
Hanley and colleagues call the interview plus analysis the practical functional assessment (PFA), and the treatment that follows skill-based treatment (SBT). Supporters value the speed, safety and fit to the person’s life. Critics worry that combining reinforcers produces false positives.
Breaking it down
The open-ended interview
The process begins with an open-ended caregiver interview (Hanley, 2012). Caregivers describe in their own words when problem behavior happens, what comes just before it, what adults do afterward, what the earliest signs of distress look like, and what the person enjoys. A brief observation can confirm the picture. The aim is one specific hypothesis: “It happens when we take the tablet and ask them to do something else, and it stops when we give it back and leave them be.”
Test and control conditions
| Control | Test | |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Everything the interview named is available: the tablet, no demands, the attention the person likes | Those reinforcers are removed or withheld at the same time |
| Consequence | None needed; the reinforcers are already present | All of them return together, briefly, after problem behavior or a precursor |
| Expected result | Little or no problem behavior | Problem behavior or its precursors |
Sessions are brief, often a few minutes each, and alternate between control and test. Across 30 applications, Jessel, Hanley, and Ghaemmaghami (2016) reported an average of about 25 minutes of analysis.
How it differs from a standard FA
A standard FA (Iwata et al., 1982/1994) isolates one contingency per test condition and compares each with a common play condition, so it can rule single reinforcers in or out. The IISCA trades some of that precision for conditions modeled on the person’s life, a matched control and, often, reinforced precursors. It asks “Is this combination responsible?” rather than “Which single reinforcer is?”
Skill-based treatment
SBT starts from the test condition and teaches, in order:
- Functional communication training (FCT). A simple request, sometimes an omnibus one such as “My way, please,” produces all the synthesized reinforcers at once. More specific requests (“All done,” “Play with me”) can be taught afterward (Ward et al., 2021).
- Tolerance responses. The person learns to accept “wait” or “not now” calmly, and that calm acceptance is reinforced.
- Contextually appropriate behavior. Over gradually longer periods, the person follows routines and instructions before the reinforcers return.
Thinning is contingency based: the next skill earns access, so the person always has a way to get what they want.
Safety, rapport and assent
A core aim of the model is that problem behavior is rarely evoked, and never repeatedly. Reinforce the first precursor instead of waiting for escalation, keep test sessions short, return to the control once the person is calm, and stop when control is shown. In treatment, demands grow gradually so the person succeeds first.
Recent work frames this as trauma-informed care, which assumes a person may have a trauma history and prioritizes safety, choice and shared control (Rajaraman et al., 2022, in JABA). In the enhanced choice model, learners can choose at any point to take part, to “hang out” with free access to preferred items, or to leave (Rajaraman et al., 2022, in Behavior Analysis in Practice). Building rapport first and honoring withdrawn assent fit Standard 2.11 (Obtaining Informed Consent), which covers assent, and Standard 2.13 (Selecting, Designing, and Implementing Assessments), which asks that assessments minimize risk of harm.
The debate
Findings that critics cite:
- Fisher et al. (2016): behavior was sensitive to individual contingencies for four of five participants, and none showed the pattern the IISCA assumes, in which reinforcers matter mainly in combination.
- Greer et al. (2020): a standard FA identified function for 11 of 12 participants, and the IISCA made errors similar to a standardized synthesized analysis built without any interview.
- Retzlaff et al. (2020): after a known function was trained for a harmless response, the standard FA identified it in all six cases, while the synthesized analysis added a new function in three.
- Holehan et al. (2020): with other design differences controlled, isolated FAs were differentiated for all five children, and treatments from either analysis worked about equally well.
Findings that supporters cite:
- Slaton, Hanley, and Raftery (2017): the IISCA was differentiated for all nine children, the standard FA for four (six once precursors were included), and treatment based on the IISCA worked for all four children compared, while treatment based on the standard FA worked for two.
- Jessel et al. (2018): 25 outpatient applications, each with a reduction of 90% or more and high caregiver ratings.
Supporters weigh treatment utility most: if the treatment works, an unneeded component costs little. They also question whether the field needs one standardized FA model (Jessel, Hanley, & Ghaemmaghami, 2020). Critics answer that extra components make plans harder to carry out and that creating a new function is a real cost. Tiger and Effertz (2021) compare the approaches on sensitivity, specificity and predictive validity.
Seeing it in practice
Malia, 6, screams and hits when her father takes her tablet and asks her to put on her shoes; he usually gives it back and stops asking. In the control, she has the tablet and no demands. In the test, he removes the tablet and asks for shoes, and at her first whine the tablet returns and the demand ends for 30 seconds. She shows no problem behavior in the control and whines within seconds of every test. Treatment then teaches “My way, please,” then “Okay” when told to wait, then putting on her shoes before the tablet returns, and her father learns each step.
Isolated conditions earn their extra sessions when an unneeded treatment component would be costly or hard for staff. When a standard FA is undifferentiated, interview-informed conditions or the strategies in J.3 come next.
Common mix-ups
- The IISCA is not an indirect assessment. An interview informs it, but the analysis manipulates contingencies and includes a control.
- Synthesized is not standardized. The IISCA combines the reinforcers this caregiver describes. A standardized synthesized analysis uses the same common reinforcers for everyone.
- The control is not the standard play condition. It is matched to the test, with the same reinforcers freely available.
- SBT is more than FCT. Tolerance and contextually appropriate behavior are planned steps.
Exam tip: The exam expects the standard FA conditions and the idea that the IISCA combines suspected reinforcers in one test compared with a matched control (F.6). The details of SBT and the comparison studies go beyond it.
Quick recap
- The IISCA tests the combination of reinforcers a caregiver describes against a control in which they are freely available.
- The PFA is the interview plus the analysis. SBT teaches communication, then tolerance, then contextually appropriate behavior.
- Safety comes from short sessions, reinforced precursors and never evoking problem behavior repeatedly.
- Critics report false positives and induced functions. Supporters report fast analyses and effective treatments.
Further reading
- Hanley, G. P., Jin, C. S., Vanselow, N. R., & Hanratty, L. A. (2014). Producing meaningful improvements in problem behavior of children with autism via synthesized analyses and treatments. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 47(1), 16-36.
- Fisher, W. W., Greer, B. D., Romani, P. W., Zangrillo, A. N., & Owen, T. M. (2016). Comparisons of synthesized and individual reinforcement contingencies during functional analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 49(3), 596-616.
- Rajaraman, A., Austin, J. L., Gover, H. C., Cammilleri, A. P., Donnelly, D. R., & Hanley, G. P. (2022). Toward trauma-informed applications of behavior analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 55(1), 40-61.
Key terms
- Interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis
- A functional analysis format in which an open-ended interview and brief observation identify the conditions that evoke a behavior, and a single test condition combines all the suspected reinforcers, compared with a matched control condition in which those reinforcers are freely available (Hanley et al., 2014).
- Practical functional assessment
- A functional assessment process described by Hanley and colleagues that combines an open-ended caregiver interview, a brief observation and an interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis. Its results feed directly into skill-based treatment.
- Skill-based treatment
- A treatment model that follows a synthesized analysis and teaches, in order, a functional communication response, tolerance responses to delays and denials, and contextually appropriate behavior such as following routines. Reinforcement is thinned by making access depend on the next skill rather than on elapsed time.
- Functional analysis
- An assessment in which the analyst systematically arranges antecedents and consequences, such as attention, escape from demands and access to items, and compares responding with a control condition to demonstrate which variables maintain a behavior.
- Functional communication training
- A form of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior in which a communicative response (a word, sign, picture exchange or device press) produces the reinforcer that maintained the problem behavior, while the problem behavior no longer produces it.
- Precursor functional analysis
- A functional analysis in which consequences are delivered for a precursor, a less dangerous behavior that reliably comes before the target behavior, so that function can be identified with fewer occurrences of the dangerous behavior. It assumes the precursor and the target share a function.
- Assent
- A learner's ongoing agreement to take part in services, shown in words or behavior such as approaching, engaging and staying with activities. It complements the informed consent given by a parent or other legally authorized representative. Signs of assent withdrawal, such as pushing materials away or trying to leave, signal a need to pause and review the plan.
- Rapport
- A working relationship in which one person's presence, attention and feedback have become reinforcing rather than aversive to the other. In supervision it is built by keeping commitments, giving frequent specific praise and showing interest in the supervisee's goals, all within professional boundaries.
Check yourself
4 questions on J.1. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: B. The IISCA test condition sets up all the motivating operations the interview described (no phone, chores) and delivers all the reinforcers together after problem behavior or a precursor. A break from chores alone is a standard demand condition that tests one contingency. Free phone access with no chores describes the matched control, not the test.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Because the test combines several reinforcers, it can come out positive when only one of them matters, so treatment may include unneeded parts (Fisher et al., 2016; Retzlaff et al., 2020). Behavior failing to appear in the test would be a false negative. High rates in both conditions would be an undifferentiated result.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Skill-based treatment moves from the functional communication response to tolerance responses, then to contextually appropriate behavior such as following instructions. Thinning is contingency based: the next skill earns access, rather than waiting out a fixed time with no way to get what she wants. Extinguishing the new request would undo the replacement skill.
Show the answer
Answer: C. Reinforcing a reliable precursor keeps dangerous behavior rare while still showing that the test contingency controls responding, which is central to the model's safety logic. Waiting for head hitting exposes Lin to avoidable injury. An interview alone cannot demonstrate function, so ending the analysis gives up the evidence the treatment needs.