cumulative

G.17 Positive and negative punishment procedures

What the task asks: Design and evaluate positive and negative punishment procedures, including when they are justified, how to make them effective, and the safeguards they require.

Behavior-Change Procedures5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Punishment procedures reduce behavior by changing what follows it. In positive punishment, a stimulus is added after a response; in negative punishment, a stimulus is removed. In both, the behavior becomes less likely in the future. B.5 covers the concepts; this guide covers the procedures and when, if ever, they belong in a plan.

Punishment is never the first tool. It is considered only after reinforcement-based and antecedent strategies have failed or when risk is high, and it always needs a reinforcement component, consent, monitoring and a fading plan.

Breaking it down

Positive punishment procedures

  • Reprimands: brief statements of disapproval. They work best delivered immediately, firmly and at close range, paired with redirection.
  • Response blocking: physically intervening to stop a response before it is completed, such as putting a hand between a learner’s hand and mouth during pica. It can work as punishment or as extinction, depending on the function.
  • Contingent exercise: requiring physical movement unrelated to the behavior, such as standing up and sitting down 10 times.
  • Overcorrection: requiring effortful behavior directly related to the problem behavior. Restitutional overcorrection restores the environment to a better state than before (a student who writes on one desk cleans every desk in the row). Positive practice overcorrection requires repeated practice of the correct behavior (walking the hall correctly several times after running).

Negative punishment procedures

Time-out from positive reinforcement (time-out) is the loss of access to positive reinforcement for a set time, contingent on the behavior.

  • Nonexclusionary time-out: the learner stays in the setting but loses access to reinforcement. Versions include planned ignoring, withdrawing a specific reinforcer (pausing a video), a time-out ribbon removed to signal no reinforcement, and contingent observation, in which the learner moves to the edge of an activity and watches without taking part.
  • Exclusionary time-out: the learner is removed from the setting, for example to a separate area or behind a partition. It is more restrictive, and once it becomes seclusion it is regulated or banned in many settings.

Time-out works only if the time-in environment is rich in reinforcement. Keep it brief, and do not end it during problem behavior.

Response cost removes a specific amount of a reinforcer the learner already has, such as tokens, points or minutes of screen time, contingent on the behavior. Set fines in advance, keep them proportionate, and make sure the learner never goes into debt. In bonus response cost, the learner receives a pool of extra reinforcers up front and fines come only from that pool, leaving earned reinforcers untouched.

Time-out access is lost for a period of time pushes peer time-in 2 min time-in watches from the sideline Response cost a set amount is lost Before After hitting two tokens removed, three kept
Two negative punishment procedures from the table below. In Ravi's time-out, access to reinforcement stops for 2 minutes and then time-in resumes. In Valentina's response cost, two tokens are taken away and she keeps the rest.

What makes punishment effective

  • Immediacy: right after the behavior, not minutes later.
  • Intensity: strong enough to suppress the behavior from the start. Starting mild and slowly increasing can produce habituation.
  • Schedule and consistency: punishing every occurrence works best at first. Intermittent punishment is weaker.
  • Reinforcement for the problem behavior: if the behavior still produces its reinforcer, punishment competes with it. Reduce that reinforcement based on the function (F.6).
  • Reinforcement for alternatives: punishment works better, with fewer side effects, when an alternative that meets the same need is reinforced (G.2).

Ethical safeguards

Standard 2.14 (Selecting, Designing, and Implementing Behavior-Change Interventions) directs behavior analysts to prioritize positive reinforcement. Standard 2.15 (Minimizing Risk of Behavior-Change Interventions) reserves restrictive or punishment-based procedures for cases where less intrusive means have failed or the risk of harm from the behavior outweighs the risk of the procedure, with any required review and ongoing evaluation. In practice:

  • try and document less restrictive alternatives first, and obtain informed consent after describing the procedure and its risks (Standard 2.11, Obtaining Informed Consent)
  • write a clear protocol, train staff, measure integrity, and collect data on the target, the alternative and side effects (G.18)
  • change or stop a procedure that is not working, and plan from the start to fade it

The least restrictive alternative is weighed against the client’s right to effective treatment: a milder procedure that leaves dangerous behavior in place for months is not automatically more humane.

Seeing it in practice

ScenarioProcedureType
Tremaine, 5, knocks over a peer’s tower; he rebuilds it and tidies the block areaRestitutional overcorrectionPositive punishment
Jerome, 10, runs in the hall; he returns and walks it correctly three timesPositive practice overcorrectionPositive punishment
Ravi, 12, pushes a peer during soccer; he sits at the sideline watching for 2 minutesContingent observationNegative punishment (nonexclusionary time-out)
Valentina, 8, hits her brother during a board game; she loses two tokens from her boardResponse costNegative punishment
Marguerite, 14, throws a chair in class; she spends 3 minutes in a separate quiet roomExclusionary time-outNegative punishment

Common mix-ups

  • Response cost vs. time-out. Response cost takes away a set amount of a reinforcer the learner has. Time-out removes access to reinforcement for a period of time.
  • Positive practice vs. contingent exercise. Positive practice repeats the correct form of the behavior. Contingent exercise is unrelated effort.
  • Negative punishment vs. negative reinforcement. Both remove something. Negative reinforcement removes an aversive and the behavior increases; negative punishment removes a reinforcer and the behavior decreases.
  • Time-out from a poor time-in. If the setting being left offers little reinforcement, time-out costs nothing and may even be an escape. Enrich time-in first.
  • Reprimands that work as attention. For attention-maintained behavior, a reprimand can reinforce. If the behavior rises with reprimands, change the consequence.

Exam tip: When a punishment procedure is not working, check two things first: whether the problem behavior still produces its reinforcer (time-out providing escape, for example), and whether the consequence is delivered immediately and consistently.

Quick recap

  • Positive punishment: reprimands, blocking, contingent exercise and overcorrection. Negative punishment: time-out (nonexclusionary or exclusionary) and response cost.
  • Effectiveness depends on immediacy, intensity, consistency and reinforcement for alternatives.
  • Standards 2.14 and 2.15 put reinforcement first and reserve punishment for cases where milder procedures failed or risk is high.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 14 and 15.
  • Lerman, D. C., & Vorndran, C. M. (2002). On the status of knowledge for using punishment: Implications for treating behavior disorders. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 35(4), 431-464.
  • Van Houten, R., Axelrod, S., Bailey, J. S., Favell, J. E., Foxx, R. M., Iwata, B. A., & Lovaas, O. I. (1988). The right to effective behavioral treatment. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21(4), 381-384.

Key terms

Positive punishment (Type I punishment)
Punishment in which a stimulus is added, or increased in intensity, right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs less often in the future. Positive means added, not good.
Negative punishment (Type II punishment)
Punishment in which a stimulus, usually a reinforcer the person already has or access to one, is removed or reduced right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs less often in the future. Response cost and time-out from positive reinforcement are the two main procedures.
Overcorrection
A positive punishment procedure that requires effortful behavior directly related to the problem behavior. Restitutional overcorrection has the person restore the environment to a better state than before. Positive practice overcorrection has the person repeatedly practice the correct form of the behavior.
Response blocking
Physically intervening as soon as a person begins a target response so the response cannot be completed. Depending on the behavior's function, blocking can work as extinction, because the response no longer produces its reinforcer, or as punishment.
Time-out from positive reinforcement (Time-out)
A negative punishment procedure in which access to positive reinforcement is withdrawn for a set period, contingent on a behavior. It can be nonexclusionary (the person stays in the setting) or exclusionary (the person leaves it), and it works only if the time-in environment is reinforcing.
Exclusionary time-out
Time-out in which the person is removed from the setting where reinforcement is available, for example to a separate area or behind a partition, for a brief period. It is more restrictive than nonexclusionary time-out and is regulated or prohibited in many settings.
Nonexclusionary time-out
Time-out in which the person stays in the setting but loses access to reinforcement for a brief period, as in planned ignoring, withdrawal of a specific reinforcer, a time-out ribbon or contingent observation.
Response cost
A negative punishment procedure in which a specific amount of a reinforcer (tokens, points, money or minutes of an activity) is removed contingent on a response, which decreases the future frequency of that response.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.17. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Each time Kemal swears during PE, the coach has him do 10 push-ups before rejoining the game. Swearing in PE has decreased. Which procedure is the coach using?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Push-ups have nothing to do with swearing, so this is contingent exercise, a positive punishment procedure. Positive practice overcorrection would require repeated practice of the correct form of the behavior, such as using acceptable words. Nothing is taken away from Kemal, so it is not response cost.

  2. Question 2Each time Ana, 9, tears up her math worksheet, she is sent to sit in the hallway for 5 minutes. Tearing has increased over three weeks, and a functional analysis shows the behavior is maintained by escape from tasks. What is the best change?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. For escape-maintained behavior, time-out removes the task, so it negatively reinforces tearing. A longer or duller time-out only provides more escape. A function-based plan teaches an appropriate way to get a break and stops tearing from producing escape, while response cost leaves that escape in place.

  3. Question 3Group-home staff are told to reprimand a resident each time the resident grabs food from other people's plates. Records show staff reprimand about one grab in four, often several minutes later. Grabbing has not changed. Which change to how the reprimand is delivered is most likely to improve its effect?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Punishment works best when it follows every occurrence right away, at least at first. One reprimand in four, minutes later, is both intermittent and delayed, while every grab still produces food. A harsher reprimand does not fix the timing and raises the risk of side effects. The plan should also reinforce an alternative, such as asking for more food.

  4. Question 4A BCBA is considering adding contingent exercise to a teen's plan for property destruction. Under Standard 2.15 (Minimizing Risk of Behavior-Change Interventions), which condition best supports considering it?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The standard limits restrictive or punishment-based procedures to cases where less intrusive means have not produced the needed change, or where the risk of harm from the behavior outweighs the risk of the procedure, and it requires any mandated review and ongoing evaluation. Caregiver preference, local habit and a single published study do not meet that bar on their own.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.