cumulative

H.4 Planning for unwanted effects of reinforcement, extinction, and punishment

What the task asks: Anticipate the side effects that reinforcement, extinction and punishment procedures can produce, and build steps into the plan to prevent or reduce them.

Selecting and Implementing Interventions5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Every behavior-change procedure can have effects beyond the one you want. Reinforcement can lose its power or create dependence. Extinction can make behavior worse before it gets better. Punishment can suppress a behavior while teaching avoidance and aggression. None of this means the procedures should not be used. It means the plan should predict these effects and include steps to reduce them.

Standard 2.14 (Selecting, Designing, and Implementing Behavior-Change Interventions) asks behavior analysts to consider risks, benefits and side effects, and Standard 2.15 (Minimizing Risk of Behavior-Change Interventions) requires continual evaluation of restrictive or punishment-based procedures.

Breaking it down

Reinforcement

Unwanted effectWhat it looks likeMitigation
SatiationA reinforcer loses effectiveness after repeated or large amounts; responding slowsSmall amounts, varied reinforcers, frequent preference assessments, some items saved for teaching
Dependence on contrived reinforcersBehavior occurs only when tokens or edibles are availablePair with praise and natural consequences; thin schedules; shift to natural reinforcers (G.16)
Reinforcing the wrong behaviorA reinforcer follows problem behavior or a prompted response by accidentClear delivery rules, staff training, integrity checks (H.6)
Ratio strainResponding breaks down when the schedule is thinned too fastThin in small steps based on data
Acceptability concernsOthers see reinforcement as bribery or unfair to peersExplain the plan; consider classwide systems

Extinction

When the reinforcer that maintained a behavior is withheld, several effects are common:

  • Extinction burst: an initial increase in the frequency, duration or intensity of the behavior, sometimes with new forms. A child who used to whine may scream.
  • Extinction-induced aggression and other emotional responding: crying, anger or aggression that appears or increases during extinction.
  • Spontaneous recovery: the behavior reappears after a period without it, often at the start of a new session or day, usually briefly and at a lower level.
  • Resurgence of other behaviors that were reinforced in the past (H.5).
  • Accidental intermittent reinforcement: if a burst becomes too hard to tolerate and caregivers give in, the behavior is reinforced on an intermittent schedule and becomes more persistent.

Lerman, Iwata and Wallace (1999) found that bursts and aggression were common during extinction for self-injury, but less common when extinction was combined with other procedures, such as reinforcement for alternative behavior.

Mitigation:

  • Combine extinction with FCT, DRA or noncontingent reinforcement rather than using it alone.
  • Confirm the function first, so the reinforcer being withheld is the one that maintains the behavior.
  • Warn caregivers about bursts and spontaneous recovery, and plan how they will respond.
  • Make sure everyone can implement it consistently, in every setting.
  • Have a safety plan, and avoid extinction alone for dangerous behavior that cannot safely be allowed to escalate.

Punishment

Possible effects (see G.17 and G.18):

  • Emotional and aggressive reactions, including aggression toward the person delivering the punisher.
  • Escape and avoidance of the punisher, the setting or the task, sometimes by hiding, lying or refusing to attend.
  • Behavioral contrast: the behavior decreases where it is punished but increases where it is not.
  • Modeling: the client may imitate punishing actions with others.
  • Overuse by the punisher: punishment stops the behavior right away, which negatively reinforces the person who delivers it, so use can drift upward.
  • No new behavior taught: suppression alone does not show the client what to do instead.
04812SchoolBaselinePunishment at school04812Home12345678910111213DaysResponses per day
Behavioral contrast. When punishment starts at school, the behavior drops there but rises at home, where nothing changed. Generalization of the treatment effect would instead show a drop in both settings.

Mitigation: use punishment only as Standard 2.15 allows, always pair it with reinforcement for a replacement behavior (H.3), deliver it consistently and immediately at the planned intensity by trained staff, collect data on side effects as well as on the target behavior, and plan to fade it.

Seeing it in practice

Callum, 8, screams for attention at dinner. His parents start ignoring screams and praising quiet requests.

  • Day 2: screaming doubles and Callum throws his plate (extinction burst and aggression). The analyst warned the parents and planned for safety, so they stay consistent.
  • Day 6: screaming is rare; requests are frequent.
  • Day 9: screaming reappears briefly at the start of dinner (spontaneous recovery). The parents respond as before, and it fades.
0510150246810121416DinnersIgnore screams, praise requestsBurstSpontaneous recoveryScreams per dinner
Callum's screams per dinner. In the first days of extinction, screaming rises above baseline (the burst), then falls to near zero. A brief return on day 9 of treatment is spontaneous recovery, weaker than baseline, and it fades as the parents stay consistent.

At a group home, staff using response cost for swearing notice that a resident now avoids the staff member who usually removes points. The analyst adds frequent positive interactions with that staff member and reviews whether response cost is still needed.

Common mix-ups

  • A burst is not a sign that extinction failed. It is a common, temporary effect. Stopping at the peak of a burst teaches the person that more intense behavior works.
  • Spontaneous recovery is not a full relapse. It is a brief return after time away, typically weaker, that fades if extinction continues.
  • Behavioral contrast is not generalization. Generalization spreads the treatment effect; contrast is a change in the opposite direction in an untreated setting.
  • Satiation is not extinction. Under satiation, the reinforcer still follows the behavior but has lost value for now. Under extinction, the reinforcer no longer follows.

Exam tip: If a scenario describes behavior getting worse right after extinction begins, the best answer is almost always to stay consistent and keep reinforcing the alternative, not to abandon the plan.

Quick recap

  • Reinforcement can produce satiation, dependence on contrived reinforcers and accidental reinforcement of the wrong behavior.
  • Extinction can produce bursts, aggression, emotional responding, spontaneous recovery and resurgence.
  • Punishment can produce aggression, escape and avoidance, behavioral contrast, modeling and overuse.
  • Plan ahead: pair procedures with reinforcement for alternatives, train implementers, prepare caregivers and track side effects with data.

Further reading

  • Lerman, D. C., Iwata, B. A., & Wallace, M. D. (1999). Side effects of extinction: Prevalence of bursting and aggression during the treatment of self-injurious behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 32(1), 1-8.
  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 14 and 24.

Key terms

Satiation
A temporary reduction in the effectiveness of a reinforcer after recent, repeated or plentiful access to it. Satiation usually functions as an abolishing operation.
Extinction burst
An immediate, usually temporary increase in the frequency, duration or intensity of a behavior when extinction begins. Bursts are common but do not always occur, and giving in during a burst reinforces the more intense behavior.
Extinction-induced aggression
Aggressive or emotional behavior that appears or increases when a previously reinforced behavior is placed on extinction. It is a known side effect of extinction to plan for, along with the extinction burst and extinction-induced variability.
Spontaneous recovery
The reappearance of an extinguished behavior after time has passed, often at the start of a later session, even though reinforcement is still withheld (or, in respondent extinction, the unconditioned stimulus is still absent). The recovered behavior is usually weaker and briefer than before and fades if extinction continues.
Behavioral contrast
A change in behavior in one setting or schedule component, in the opposite direction to a change produced by altering the contingencies in another setting or component. For example, behavior that decreases where it is punished may increase where it is not.

Check yourself

5 questions on H.4. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Two days after staff stop giving attention for a client's yelling, the yelling becomes louder and more frequent. The plan also reinforces polite requests. What is the best response?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A temporary increase soon after extinction begins is an extinction burst, which is common and usually passes if the plan is followed. Stopping now, or giving attention some of the time, would reinforce louder yelling on an intermittent schedule and make it more persistent.

  2. Question 2A token system works well for Priya, 9, for three weeks. Then her work completion drops, even though tokens still follow correct work. She has exchanged her tokens for the same snack every day. What is the most likely cause?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Daily access to the same backup item reduces its value, so the tokens buy something less worth working for. That is satiation. Extinction would mean the tokens stopped following correct work, which is not the case here.

  3. Question 3After response cost reduces a student's swearing in math class, the same student's swearing increases in art class, where no response cost is used. This is an example of:
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Behavioral contrast is a change in the opposite direction in a setting where the contingencies did not change. Generalization would mean the decrease spread to art class, which is the reverse of what happened.

  4. Question 4Why does the use of punishment tend to increase over time for the person who delivers it?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Punishment often stops the problem behavior right away, which removes an aversive situation for the person delivering it. That negative reinforcement strengthens their use of punishment, which is one reason its use must be monitored closely. Punishment does not teach a replacement behavior; it only suppresses the one it follows, so reliance on it cannot come from what it teaches.

  5. Question 5Before starting extinction for a child's head hitting, which step best reduces the risk of unwanted effects?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Combining extinction with reinforcement for an alternative that meets the same need makes bursts and aggression less likely. Telling caregivers to expect immediate improvement sets them up to give in during a burst, which would strengthen the behavior.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.