The big idea
An assessment usually turns up more possible goals than anyone can work on at once. Prioritizing means deciding which to address first, and with which procedures, based on what will make the biggest difference in the client’s life.
Three ideas run through this task. Goals should be socially significant: changing them improves the person’s life in ways that they and the people around them value. They should be client-informed: the client, as far as possible, and the family help choose them. And they should be culturally responsive: they fit the client’s community, language and values (F.2). Standard 2.09 (Involving Clients and Stakeholders) asks behavior analysts to involve clients and stakeholders in selecting goals and designing interventions.
Breaking it down
Questions that guide priority
Cooper et al. (2020) offer a set of practical questions for ranking targets. In our words:
- Safety: Does the behavior endanger the client or others? Danger comes first.
- Opportunity: How often will the person have a chance to use the new skill?
- History: Is the problem long-standing, or likely to fade on its own?
- Access to reinforcement: Will the change let the person contact more reinforcement in daily life?
- Future learning: Is it a prerequisite for other important skills?
- Others: Will it reduce stigma or negative attention, or improve life for the people the client lives with?
- Feasibility: How likely is success, and what will it cost in time and effort?
Behavioral cusps and pivotal behaviors
A behavioral cusp (Rosales-Ruiz & Baer, 1997) is a behavior change that opens access to new environments, reinforcers, contingencies and learning. Learning to walk, read or use a communication device changes what a person can contact far beyond the skill itself.
A pivotal behavior is one that, once learned, produces changes in other untaught behaviors. Examples from pivotal response treatment research by Koegel and colleagues include motivation, responding to multiple cues, self-initiation and self-management. Teaching a child to start interactions, for example, can increase many social behaviors at once.
Both concepts point to the same strategy: favor goals with wide effects.
The relevance of behavior rule
The relevance of behavior rule (Ayllon & Azrin, 1968) says to target behaviors that will continue to be reinforced in the person’s natural environment after intervention ends. A skill that no one in the client’s life will reinforce is unlikely to last.
Social validity of goals
Social validity (Wolf, 1978) asks whether goals are significant, procedures acceptable and results important to the people affected. At the goal-setting stage, ask the client and family directly, look at what competent peers do in the same setting, and check that the goal matches the family’s own priorities.
Client input and assent
Assent is a client’s own indication, through words or actions, of willingness to take part, from someone who cannot legally give informed consent. Even when caregivers consent, watch for assent and its withdrawal, such as approaching the work area or turning away and crying, and adjust. When a client can state goals, include them: a teenager may care more about texting friends than about the next item on a curriculum checklist.
Building as well as reducing
When a goal is to reduce a behavior, pair it with a goal to increase an alternative that meets the same need (H.3). Priority usually goes to skills that make problem behavior unnecessary.
Seeing it in practice
Assessment for Nia, 6, identifies several possible goals. The team ranks them with her parents.
| Possible goal | Priority | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Stop at the curb instead of running into the street | 1 | Immediate danger |
| Request help and breaks with a picture system | 2 | Opens access to many reinforcers; replaces the screaming that ends tasks |
| Start interactions with peers | 3 | A pivotal behavior: self-initiation tends to spread to other social behavior |
| Use utensils at meals | 4 | Family priority; daily opportunities |
| Sort colors at a table | Later | Few natural opportunities; little effect on daily life |
| Sleep alone in her own room | Discussed, not selected | The family shares sleeping space and does not see it as a need |
Common mix-ups
- Cusp vs. pivotal behavior. A cusp is defined by the new environments and contingencies it opens. A pivotal behavior is defined by the untaught behaviors that change with it. Some behaviors are both.
- Prioritizing is not just ranking deficits. The lowest score on an assessment is not automatically the most important goal.
- Client-informed does not mean caregiver-only. Include the client’s own preferences and attend to assent wherever possible.
- Social validity is not popularity. A goal that mainly makes a classroom quieter may not benefit the student. Ask who benefits.
Exam tip: When several goals compete in a question, choose the one that addresses danger first. Among safe options, pick the one that opens the most access to reinforcement and future learning for the client.
Quick recap
- Prioritize safety, then goals with the widest benefit to the client.
- Behavioral cusps open new environments; pivotal behaviors produce change in untaught behaviors.
- The relevance of behavior rule favors goals that natural contingencies will maintain.
- Involve the client and family, check social validity and attend to assent.
- Fit goals to the client’s culture and daily life.
Further reading
- Rosales-Ruiz, J., & Baer, D. M. (1997). Behavioral cusps: A developmental and pragmatic concept for behavior analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 30(3), 533-544.
- Wolf, M. M. (1978). Social validity: The case for subjective measurement or how applied behavior analysis is finding its heart. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 11(2), 203-214.
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 3.
Key terms
- Social validity
- The extent to which the goals, procedures and outcomes of an intervention are acceptable, important and useful to the people it affects, such as clients, caregivers and supervisees. It is usually measured with surveys, interviews or rating scales.
- Behavioral cusp
- A behavior change that gives the person access to new environments, reinforcers, contingencies and learning opportunities, with effects that reach well beyond the behavior itself (Rosales-Ruiz & Baer, 1997).
- Pivotal behavior
- A behavior that, once learned, produces changes in other untrained behaviors. Examples studied in pivotal response treatment include motivation, responding to multiple cues, self-initiation and self-management.
- Relevance of behavior rule
- A guideline for selecting target behaviors: choose behaviors that will continue to be reinforced in the person's natural environment after intervention ends (Ayllon & Azrin, 1968).
- Assent
- A learner's ongoing agreement to take part in services, shown in words or behavior such as approaching, engaging and staying with activities. It complements the informed consent given by a parent or other legally authorized representative. Signs of assent withdrawal, such as pushing materials away or trying to leave, signal a need to pause and review the plan.
Check yourself
5 questions on F.8. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Behavior that puts the client or others in danger is the first priority. The lowest score on an assessment is not automatically the most important target, and waiting is useful but carries no immediate risk.
Show the answer
Answer: A. A behavioral cusp is defined by the new environments, reinforcers and contingencies it opens up, which is what the scenario describes. A pivotal behavior is defined by changes it produces in other, untaught behaviors. Some behaviors are both, but the scenario emphasizes access.
Show the answer
Answer: A. The rule says to choose behaviors that the natural environment will keep reinforcing after intervention ends, so the change lasts. A skill that occurs only with a therapist, or that is chosen only because it comes next on a list, may not be maintained.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Assent is the client's own indication of willingness, and it can be shown or withdrawn through actions. Consent from parents does not cancel the need to attend to it. The usual response is to pause and change the session, for example by adding choices or easier tasks, not to end services entirely.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Social validity asks whether a goal matters to the people affected, and above all whether it benefits the client. A goal that mainly makes a classroom quieter may not help the student. Leaving the teacher out ignores a stakeholder whose support the plan will need.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.