cumulative

A.4 Behaviorism, the experimental analysis of behavior, ABA, and practice

What the task asks: Tell apart the domains of behavior analysis (its philosophy, its basic science, its applied science and its practice) by what each one is for and what it produces.

Behaviorism and Philosophical Foundations4 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Behavior analysis is one field with several domains that do different jobs. Behaviorism is the philosophy. The experimental analysis of behavior (EAB) is the basic science. Applied behavior analysis (ABA) is the applied science. Professional practice guided by behavior analysis is the delivery of services to clients.

Moore and Cooper (2003) described EAB, ABA and service delivery as points along a continuum, with radical behaviorism as the philosophy that informs all three. The outline asks you to distinguish all four.

The domains depend on each other. Philosophy tells the science what counts as an explanation. Basic research discovers principles. Applied research turns principles into tested procedures. Practice uses those procedures to help people, and the problems practitioners meet send new questions back to researchers.

Behaviorism: the philosophy What counts as behavior and as an explanation informs all three EAB Basic science Finds principles ABA Applied science Tests procedures Practice Service delivery Helps clients principles procedures Translational research Problems met in practice raise new research questions
Radical behaviorism informs all three other domains. Principles flow from EAB to ABA, tested procedures flow from ABA to practice, and problems met in practice send new questions back to research.

Breaking it down

Behaviorism: the philosophy

Behaviorism is the philosophy of the science of behavior. It handles conceptual questions: what behavior is, what counts as an explanation, how to treat thoughts and feelings. Radical behaviorism, Skinner’s version, is the philosophy behind behavior analysis (see A.3). Work in this domain is mostly conceptual: theoretical papers, analyses of terms and arguments about explanation.

EAB: the basic science

The experimental analysis of behavior is basic research into the principles of behavior: how schedules of reinforcement shape responding, how stimulus control develops, how choice is distributed among options. Questions are chosen because they reveal how behavior works, not because the behavior matters to a particular person.

Much classic EAB research used nonhuman animals in controlled laboratory settings, and much EAB research today includes human participants. Skinner’s The Behavior of Organisms (1938) launched the domain, and the Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior began publishing in 1958.

ABA: the applied science

Applied behavior analysis uses the principles of behavior to improve socially significant behavior and shows experimentally that the procedures were responsible for the improvement. Two features make it ABA: the target matters to the person and their community, and the research demonstrates a functional relation (see the dimensions in A.5). The Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis began in 1968.

Research that bridges the two sciences, such as testing a laboratory finding with a clinical population, is often called translational research.

Professional practice: service delivery

Professional practice guided by behavior analysis is what practitioners do day to day: assess clients, design and run interventions, train caregivers and staff, and make data-based decisions. Its aim is to benefit the client, not to produce new knowledge. Practitioners still measure behavior and evaluate effects, but they are not expected to demonstrate a functional relation for every change, and they rely on EAB and ABA research to choose procedures.

Seeing it in practice

The same topic, reinforcing one behavior over another, can appear in all four domains.

DomainExampleMain question
BehaviorismA paper argues that choice is best understood as behavior distributed among available contingencies, not as an act of free will.What does it mean to explain a choice?
EABRats press two levers that pay off on different schedules, and the researcher varies the reinforcement rate on each.How is responding divided between sources of reinforcement?
ABAA study uses a reversal design to show that reinforcing hand-raising reduces call-outs for three students.Does this procedure produce socially significant change, and is the procedure responsible?
PracticeA behavior analyst writes a plan for Sam, a fourth grader, that reinforces hand-raising, then tracks call-outs weekly.Is Sam’s plan working well enough to keep?

Common mix-ups

  • Animals do not equal EAB, and people do not equal ABA. Purpose decides the domain. Basic research seeks principles; applied research seeks socially significant change with experimental control. An EAB study with human participants is still basic research.
  • ABA research vs. practice. Both target socially significant behavior. ABA research must demonstrate a functional relation and adds to the literature. Practice is judged by client outcomes and uses data to guide decisions about one person.
  • Behaviorism is not a technique. It produces no interventions directly. It is the set of assumptions and concepts the other domains rest on.
  • The domains are not ranked. Each needs the others. Practice cut off from the science drifts toward a set of tricks, and science cut off from practice may never reach the people it could help.

Exam tip: Ask what the person is trying to produce. A clearer concept points to behaviorism. A general principle points to EAB. A tested procedure for a socially important behavior points to ABA. A better outcome for one client points to practice.

Quick recap

  • Behaviorism: the philosophy (radical behaviorism) that defines the subject matter and what counts as an explanation.
  • EAB: basic research that discovers principles, with targets chosen for what they reveal.
  • ABA: applied research that improves socially significant behavior and shows the procedure was responsible.
  • Practice: service delivery that uses the science to benefit individual clients.

Further reading

  • Moore, J., & Cooper, J. O. (2003). Some proposed relations among the domains of behavior analysis. The Behavior Analyst, 26, 69-84.
  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 1.
  • Baer, D. M., Wolf, M. M., & Risley, T. R. (1968). Some current dimensions of applied behavior analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1(1), 91-97.

Key terms

Behaviorism
The philosophy of the science of behavior. It addresses conceptual questions such as what behavior is, what counts as an explanation and how to treat thoughts and feelings. Radical behaviorism is the version that underlies behavior analysis.
Radical behaviorism
Skinner's philosophy of the science of behavior. It treats everything a person does, including private events such as thinking and feeling, as behavior, and explains behavior by its relations to the environment across evolutionary history, learning history and the current situation.
Experimental analysis of behavior (EAB)
The basic science of behavior analysis: research that discovers and clarifies the fundamental principles of behavior, with questions chosen for what they reveal about how behavior works rather than for their social importance.
Applied behavior analysis (ABA)
The science in which principles of behavior are used to improve socially significant behavior, and experiments show that the procedures used were responsible for the improvement. Baer, Wolf and Risley (1968) described its seven defining dimensions.
Professional practice guided by behavior analysis (Service delivery, Behavior-analytic practice)
The delivery of behavior-analytic services to clients: assessment, intervention, caregiver and staff training, and data-based decision making. Its goal is to benefit the client rather than to produce new knowledge, and it draws on research from the experimental analysis of behavior and applied behavior analysis.

Check yourself

5 questions on A.4. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A researcher arranges different reinforcement schedules for pigeons pecking a key to see how each schedule affects the pattern of responding. The key-pecking itself matters to no one outside the lab. Which domain does this work belong to?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. The work seeks a general principle about how schedules control behavior, and the behavior was chosen for what it reveals, not for its social importance. That is basic research, the experimental analysis of behavior. Applied behavior analysis would target a behavior that matters to the participant.

  2. Question 2A behavior analyst at a clinic designs a toilet-training plan for Amira, age 5, coaches her parents to use it, and reviews the data each week to decide whether to adjust it. No experimental design is used. Which domain best describes this activity?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The aim is to benefit one client, using data to guide decisions, not to demonstrate a functional relation or add to the research literature. That is service delivery. Applied research would also target socially significant behavior but would use a design to show the procedure caused the change.

  3. Question 3A research team uses a multiple-baseline design to show that a self-monitoring package increases on-task behavior for three high school students, and publishes the results in a journal. Which domain is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. The behavior is socially significant, and the design shows experimentally that the package produced the change. Both features mark applied behavior analysis. It is not basic research, because the target was chosen for its importance to the students.

  4. Question 4What is the main purpose of behaviorism as a domain of behavior analysis?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Behaviorism is the philosophy of the science. It addresses what behavior is and what counts as an explanation. Discovering principles is the job of the experimental analysis of behavior, and showing that procedures improve socially significant behavior is the job of applied behavior analysis.

  5. Question 5A student says, 'Any study with human participants is applied behavior analysis, and any study with animals is the experimental analysis of behavior.' What is the best correction?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. The domains are defined by their purpose. Basic research with human participants is still the experimental analysis of behavior, and applied research is defined by its focus on socially significant behavior with experimental control, not by species or setting.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.