cumulative

G.8 Fading stimulus and response prompts

What the task asks: Plan and carry out the gradual removal of stimulus and response prompts so the natural SD controls the response, and adjust the fading plan from the data.

Behavior-Change Procedures5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

A prompt gets the right response to happen. Fading gets it to happen without the prompt. The goal is transfer of stimulus control: moving control from the prompt to the natural SD, so the learner reads the word rather than the picture beside it, and starts washing hands at the sink rather than when the therapist points.

Fading is a balancing act. Remove help too fast and errors pile up. Remove it too slowly and the learner comes to depend on it. Good fading plans use small steps, set rules for moving forward and back, and rely on data from every trial.

Breaking it down

Fading response prompts

Most-to-least prompting (see G.7) is itself a fading system: help steps down from more to less intrusive across sessions as criteria are met.

Graduated guidance fades physical help moment to moment within a trial. The instructor gives only as much guidance as the learner needs and lightens it as the learner moves independently, often shifting the point of contact from hand to wrist to elbow to shoulder, then shadowing with hands close but not touching. If the learner stops or starts to err, guidance increases immediately.

Prompt delay (time delay) fades by time instead of by type. The instructor presents the SD and waits before prompting, which gives the learner a chance to respond first.

  • Constant time delay (CTD): a few trials or sessions at 0 seconds (SD and prompt together), then one fixed delay, such as 4 seconds, on every trial.
  • Progressive time delay (PTD): start at 0 seconds and lengthen the delay gradually, for example by 1 second every few trials or sessions, up to a set maximum.
012345612345678SessionsConstant (June)Progressive (Felipe)Prompt delay (s)
The two delay plans from the table below. June's constant delay jumps from 0 to 4 seconds after one session and stays there. Felipe's progressive delay holds at 0 for two sessions, then climbs 1 second per session to a 5-second maximum.

Correct answers before the prompt are reinforced, often more richly than prompted ones. Wrong answers before the prompt suggest the delay is growing too fast or the learner needs to be taught to wait when unsure.

Fading stimulus prompts

Stimulus fading gradually changes a feature of the prompt, such as its color, size or intensity, until it is gone or matches everything else. A bold red outline around the correct answer becomes pink, then pale, then absent.

Stimulus shaping gradually changes the shape or form of the stimulus itself. A drawing of a fish changes step by step until only the printed word FISH remains.

Both are usually errorless: each step is small enough that the learner keeps responding correctly.

Rules for moving through steps

Write the criteria before you start:

  • Advance after a set level of success, such as two consecutive sessions at 80 percent correct or better at the current step.
  • Step back after a set number of errors, such as two in a row.
  • Set a terminal criterion for responding to the natural SD alone.

Prompt dependence

Prompt dependence means the learner waits for a prompt even when they can make the response alone. Common causes:

  • prompts that are never faded, or are faded too slowly;
  • prompted and independent responses earning the same reinforcer;
  • prompting too quickly, before the learner has a chance to respond;
  • accidental prompts such as glances, pauses or leaning toward the correct answer.

Prevent it by planning the fade from the first session, using a prompt delay and differentially reinforcing independent responses: a better reinforcer, or more of it, for unprompted correct answers than for prompted ones.

Evaluating the fade

Graph unprompted correct responses separately from prompted ones. A rising line of unprompted responding shows transfer. A flat line with high prompted responding shows dependence. A jump in errors right after a step shows the step was too big.

Seeing it in practice

LearnerSkillMethodPlan
Felipe, 6Saying “help” when stuckProgressive time delay0 s for 2 sessions, then add 1 s per session up to 5 s
June, 8Naming coinsConstant time delay0 s for 1 session, then 4 s on every trial
Abdi, 22Folding towels at workGraduated guidanceHand over hand, then wrist, then shadowing, then no contact
Lena, 5Reading “dog”Stimulus shapingA drawing of a dog changes in six steps into the printed word
Chloe, 9Finding her bus stop on a mapStimulus fadingA bold outline around the stop lightens over five steps

Across eight sessions, June’s unprompted correct responses rise from 10 percent to 85 percent while her prompted correct responses fall. Control has transferred to the coins.

Unprompted correctPrompted correct025507510012345678SessionsPercent of trials
June's coin naming, with unprompted and prompted correct responses graphed separately. The unprompted path rises as the prompted path falls: control is moving from the prompt to the coins.

Common mix-ups

  • Stimulus fading versus stimulus shaping. Fading changes the intensity or presence of a feature; shaping changes the form of the stimulus.
  • Stimulus shaping versus shaping behavior. Shaping in G.11 reinforces successive approximations of a response. Stimulus shaping changes the stimulus, not the response.
  • Constant versus progressive delay. Constant jumps from 0 seconds to one fixed delay; progressive climbs in small steps.
  • Fading is not stopping. Removing a prompt all at once is not fading. It is a gamble.

Exam tip: If a learner “can do it but waits for help,” the answer involves a prompt delay, richer reinforcement for independent responses or a faster fade. If errors jumped right after a fading step, step back.

Quick recap

  • Fading aims at transfer of stimulus control to the natural SD.
  • Response prompts fade through most-to-least, graduated guidance and constant or progressive time delay.
  • Stimulus prompts fade through stimulus fading (intensity, size, color) or stimulus shaping (form).
  • Write advance, step-back and terminal criteria before you begin.
  • Prevent prompt dependence with planned fading, delays and better reinforcement for independent responses.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 17.
  • Touchette, P. E. (1971). Transfer of stimulus control: Measuring the moment of transfer. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 15(3), 347-354.
  • Touchette, P. E., & Howard, J. S. (1984). Errorless learning: Reinforcement contingencies and stimulus control transfer in delayed prompting. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 17(2), 175-188.

Key terms

Transfer of stimulus control
The shift of control over a response from a prompt to the natural SD, achieved by gradually removing the prompt. Transfer is complete when the response occurs reliably to the SD alone.
Stimulus fading
Gradually changing a feature of a stimulus prompt, such as its intensity, size or color, until it is gone or matches the other stimuli, so that control transfers to the natural SD.
Stimulus shaping
Gradually changing the shape or form of a stimulus across steps, so that correct responding to an easy stimulus carries over to the target stimulus. It differs from shaping behavior, which changes the response rather than the stimulus.
Constant time delay (CTD)
A prompt-fading procedure in which early trials use a 0-second delay between the SD and the prompt, and all later trials use one fixed delay, such as 4 seconds, giving the learner a chance to respond before help is given.
Progressive time delay (PTD)
A prompt-fading procedure that starts with a 0-second delay between the SD and the prompt and lengthens the delay in small steps across trials or sessions.
Graduated guidance
A procedure for fading physical prompts in which guidance is adjusted moment to moment: the instructor gives only as much help as needed, lightens it as the learner moves independently, shifts the point of contact (hand, wrist, elbow, shoulder) and then shadows without touching.
Prompt dependence (Prompt dependency)
A pattern in which a learner waits for a prompt before responding, even when they can respond correctly without it. It often results from prompts that are not faded, prompting too quickly, or reinforcing prompted and independent responses equally.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.8. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1To teach June coin names, a therapist shows each coin and says its name at the same moment for one session. From then on, the therapist waits 4 seconds on every trial before saying the name. Which procedure is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Starting at 0 seconds and then jumping to one fixed delay used on every trial is constant time delay. Progressive time delay would raise the delay in small steps, such as 1 second at a time. Graduated guidance fades physical help, and least-to-most adds more intrusive prompts after errors.

  2. Question 2Yusuf labels pictures correctly when the therapist gives the first sound, but he waits silently for that sound on almost every trial. Prompted and unprompted correct answers earn the same praise and token. What should the team change?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Yusuf shows prompt dependence: waiting pays off as well as answering alone. Richer reinforcement for unprompted answers, plus a delay that gives him a chance to answer first, makes independent responding the better option. Prompting sooner or switching to a bigger prompt adds help he does not need, and withholding all reinforcement would put correct answers on extinction.

  3. Question 3A drawing of a snake is changed in small steps across sessions until only the printed letter S remains, and the learner names it 's' throughout. Which procedure is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. The form of the stimulus is gradually transformed into the target stimulus, which is stimulus shaping. Stimulus fading changes the intensity or presence of a feature (darker to lighter, bigger to smaller) rather than its shape. Shaping of behavior changes the response, and the response here stays the same.

  4. Question 4During progressive time delay, Felipe's correct responding stays high until the delay reaches 4 seconds. At that step he starts giving wrong answers before the prompt on most trials. What is the best next step?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Errors before the prompt at a new step suggest the step was too large for Felipe. Going back to the last delay that worked and increasing in smaller steps keeps errors low. Pushing ahead, or removing the prompt, would multiply errors, and reinforcing prompted answers more than independent ones would encourage waiting.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.