cumulative

F.5 Designing and evaluating descriptive assessments

What the task asks: Design and interpret direct observations of behavior in natural routines, and recognize what descriptive data can and cannot show about function.

Behavior Assessment5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

A functional behavior assessment (FBA) is the process of identifying the variables that reliably predict and maintain a behavior. It draws on three kinds of method: indirect assessment (interviews, rating scales, records), descriptive assessment, and functional analysis (F.6).

A descriptive assessment is direct observation of the behavior in the client’s natural routines, with no deliberate changes to the environment. The observer records what happens before and after the behavior as it occurs. This produces real data from real settings, and it is often safer and easier than an analysis.

Its limit is the one you met in A.1. Descriptive data show which events go together. They support prediction, not control. A consequence that often follows a behavior is not necessarily the one that maintains it.

Breaking it down

ABC continuous recording

In ABC continuous recording, the observer records every occurrence of the target behavior during an observation period, along with specified antecedents and consequences, usually by marking codes on a prepared form (for example: demand given, attention diverted, item removed; reprimand, escape, item given). Because it uses defined categories across the whole period, it produces data you can summarize and analyze.

ABC narrative recording

In ABC narrative recording, the observer writes a brief description of what happened before and after each occurrence, only when the behavior occurs. It is open-ended, which helps early in a case when you do not yet know which events matter. Its weaknesses: descriptions can be subjective, and because nothing is recorded when the behavior does not occur, you cannot tell how often the same antecedents or consequences happen without it.

ABC continuous Preset codes, every occurrence Time D AD IR Rep Esc IG 10:04 10:11 10:20 10:26 A: D demand, AD attention diverted, IR item removed C: Rep reprimand, Esc escape, IG item given ABC narrative Written notes, only when it happens 10:04 A: Writing sheet handed out. B: Throws pencil across desk. C: Sent to the hallway. 10:20 A: Teacher helps another student. B: Throws her book. C: Teacher says "stop that."
Excerpts from the two kinds of ABC sheet. The continuous sheet ticks one preset antecedent code and one consequence code for every throw, so the data can be summarized. The narrative sheet describes each episode in words, which is flexible but harder to count.

Scatterplot

A scatterplot (Touchette et al., 1985) is a grid of time intervals (for example, 30-minute blocks) across days. Each cell is marked to show whether the behavior occurred, and sometimes how often. Over days, patterns may appear: the behavior clusters during transitions, before lunch or on certain shifts. A scatterplot shows when behavior happens, which can point to activities or people to look at more closely. It does not record antecedents or consequences, and many scatterplots show no clear pattern.

Week 1 Week 2 M T W T F M T W T F 8:30 9:00 9:30 10:00 10:30 11:00 11:30 12:00 12:30 1:00 1:30 2:00 10:00 block: writing time None Once Two or more times
A two-week scatterplot for Sofia, one row per 30-minute block. Shaded cells cluster in the 10:00 row, writing time, while the rest of the day is mostly empty. The plot says when to look, not why the behavior happens.

Conditional probabilities

From ABC continuous data you can calculate a conditional probability: the likelihood that an event follows (or precedes) the behavior, given that the behavior occurred. If attention followed 18 of 20 episodes of screaming, the conditional probability of attention given screaming is .90.

Compare it with the background probability: how often attention occurs regardless of behavior. If the student receives attention in 85% of intervals anyway, a .90 conditional probability shows little relation between screaming and attention. Events that are common everywhere, such as adult attention, will often appear to follow the behavior, which is one reason descriptive and functional analyses frequently disagree.

Screaming and attention 0 .5 1 .90 .85 After the behavior Background (any time) Little relation: attention is common anyway Sofia: throwing and escape 0 .5 1 .80 .10 After the behavior Background (any time) A stronger lead: escape is rare otherwise
Compare each conditional probability with its background rate. Attention follows screaming 90% of the time but occurs 85% of the time anyway, so the link is weak. Escape follows Sofia's throwing 80% of the time and is otherwise rare, which makes it a stronger lead.

Designing a descriptive assessment

  • Write operational definitions of the behavior first (C.1).
  • Observe in the settings and at the times where the behavior is a concern, guided by interviews or a scatterplot.
  • Define antecedent and consequence categories before recording, based on the most plausible functions.
  • Collect enough observations to capture several occurrences, and check interobserver agreement.

Seeing it in practice

Sofia, 10, throws materials in class. Her analyst uses three descriptive methods in sequence.

MethodWhat it showedWhat it could not show
Scatterplot, two weeksThrowing clusters in the 10:00 to 10:30 block, which is writing timeWhy writing time matters
ABC narrative, three daysThrowing usually follows a writing task; the teacher then sends Sofia to the hallwayHow often Sofia leaves writing without throwing
ABC continuous, five sessionsConditional probability of escape given throwing is .80; background probability of escape is .10Whether escape, rather than some other event, maintains the throwing

The data suggest an escape function. Because the teacher’s reprimands also followed many episodes, the analyst designs a functional analysis with demand and attention conditions to test both (F.6).

Common mix-ups

  • Descriptive is direct but not experimental. It is direct observation, unlike interviews, but nothing is manipulated, unlike a functional analysis.
  • Narrative vs. continuous. Narrative ABC is written only when the behavior occurs and is open-ended. Continuous ABC records across the whole period with predefined codes.
  • A scatterplot is about time, not function. It shows when, not why.
  • A high conditional probability is not proof. Always compare it with how often the event happens anyway.
  • FBA is the umbrella. Descriptive assessment is one part of an FBA; a functional analysis is another.

Exam tip: If an answer says a descriptive assessment demonstrated or confirmed a function, it is overstated. Descriptive data suggest hypotheses; only manipulating the variables shows a functional relation.

Quick recap

  • Descriptive assessment means direct observation in natural routines, with no manipulation.
  • ABC continuous recording uses codes across the whole period; ABC narrative recording describes each episode as it happens.
  • Scatterplots show when behavior occurs across the day.
  • Conditional probabilities must be compared with background rates.
  • Descriptive data show correlation and generate hypotheses for a functional analysis.

Further reading

  • Touchette, P. E., MacDonald, R. F., & Langer, S. N. (1985). A scatter plot for identifying stimulus control of problem behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(4), 343-351.
  • Thompson, R. H., & Iwata, B. A. (2007). A comparison of outcomes from descriptive and functional analyses of problem behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 40(2), 333-338.

Key terms

Descriptive assessment
Direct observation of a behavior and the events around it in the person's natural routines, without deliberately changing the environment. It shows which events are correlated with the behavior but cannot demonstrate its function.
Functional behavior assessment (FBA, Functional assessment)
The overall process of identifying the variables that reliably predict and maintain a behavior, using indirect assessment, descriptive assessment, functional analysis or a combination of them.
Antecedent-behavior-consequence recording (ABC recording, ABC data collection)
A descriptive assessment method that records the antecedents and consequences surrounding a behavior. In continuous recording, the observer uses predefined codes for events across a whole observation period; in narrative recording, the observer writes a description only when the behavior occurs.
Scatterplot (Scatter plot)
A graph showing how individual measures are distributed in relation to two variables. In applied practice the term often refers to a time-of-day grid recorded across days, which shows when a behavior tends to occur and helps guide observation and assessment.
Conditional probability
In descriptive assessment, the likelihood that a particular event precedes or follows a behavior, given that the behavior occurred. It is interpreted by comparing it with the background probability of that event regardless of the behavior.
Indirect assessment
Assessment that gathers information about a behavior from sources other than direct observation of it, such as interviews, rating scales, questionnaires and records. In a functional behavior assessment it is used to form hypotheses, not to confirm function.

Check yourself

5 questions on F.5. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Each time Liam, 5, has a tantrum, an observer writes a short description of what happened just before and just after it. Nothing is recorded when no tantrum occurs. Which method is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Narrative recording describes antecedents and consequences in the observer's own words, and only when the behavior occurs. Continuous ABC recording uses predefined codes across the whole observation period, whether or not the behavior occurs.

  2. Question 2ABC data show that a teacher's reprimand followed 15 of Ava's 20 call-outs. The same teacher reprimands some student in nearly every minute of class. What is the best conclusion?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. A conditional probability means little until it is compared with how often the event happens regardless of the behavior. If reprimands occur almost constantly, they will follow call-outs often by chance. Concluding that attention maintains the behavior treats a correlation as a function.

  3. Question 3A residential team marks each half-hour of the day for two weeks to show whether a resident's yelling occurred. Yelling appears mostly between 4:00 and 6:00 p.m. What has the team learned?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. A scatterplot shows the temporal distribution of behavior, which can direct attention to the activities, people or routines at those times. It records no antecedents or consequences, so it cannot show why the behavior occurs.

  4. Question 4What keeps a descriptive assessment from demonstrating function?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Showing function requires manipulating a variable and seeing behavior change reliably, which is control. Descriptive assessment only observes, so it reaches prediction. It is direct observation in natural settings, which is why the interview and contrived-setting choices are wrong.

  5. Question 5An analyst finds that escape followed 70% of a client's aggressive episodes, while escape occurred in only 10% of observation intervals without aggression. What does this most reasonably support?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Escape is far more likely after aggression than at other times, which makes an escape function a strong hypothesis. Because nothing was manipulated, it is still a correlation; a functional analysis or a closely monitored treatment would test it.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.