The big idea
MOs and SDs both come before behavior, and both can make behavior more likely right now. That is why they are easy to confuse. The difference is what each is related to:
- A discriminative stimulus (SD) is related to the availability of a reinforcer. The response has been reinforced in its presence and not in its absence.
- A motivating operation (MO) is related to the value of a reinforcer. It changes how effective the consequence is, and with it how often behavior that has produced that consequence occurs (B.16).
An SD answers Can I get it here? An MO answers Would getting it matter right now?
Breaking it down
The SD: differential availability
An SD has a particular history. In its presence the response produced reinforcement. In its absence the same response did not, even though the reinforcer would have been effective if it had come. That last clause is the key. The no-SD condition only counts as a fair comparison if the learner would still have valued the reinforcer then.
The MO: differential effectiveness
An MO involves a different comparison. When the MO is absent, the reinforcer may be fully available, but it does not work well as a reinforcer. Food deprivation is not an SD for asking for food. A well-fed person standing in a full kitchen rarely asks for food, and the reason is that food is worth less to them, not that it is unavailable.
The test question
Imagine the antecedent gone and ask what happens to the reinforcer:
- Is the reinforcer now unavailable, even though it would still be effective? Then the antecedent was an SD.
- Is the reinforcer still available, but less effective? Then the antecedent was an MO.
Put the other way round: would the behavior still occur if reinforcement were available but the antecedent were absent? If not, because the consequence would no longer be worth much, the antecedent is an MO.
The hard cases
CMO-T vs. SD. Michael’s classic example is a worker taking apart a piece of equipment who reaches a screw that must come out and asks an assistant for a screwdriver. The screw does not signal that screwdrivers are available; they were available all along. It makes a screwdriver valuable, so it is a transitive conditioned motivating operation. The assistant, who hands over tools when asked, is the SD for asking.
CMO-R vs. SD. A demand that has preceded hard work evokes escape. It can look like an SD, because escape is only possible while the demand is present. But without the demand there is nothing to escape, so removing it has no value. Michael argued that this makes it an MO, a reflexive conditioned motivating operation. The same logic applies to any aversive stimulus in an escape contingency. What signals that escape is available, such as a staff member who allows breaks, would be the SD.
CMO-S. A surrogate conditioned motivating operation borrows the effect of another MO it has been paired with. It is rarely tested on its own; just recognize that it changes value, not availability.
They work together
An SD evokes behavior only when a relevant MO is in effect. A vending machine is an SD for inserting coins, but whether you bother depends on thirst. When you teach mands, you need the MO and you need an SD (a listener who can deliver the item). G.5 covers how to arrange both.
Seeing it in practice
| Antecedent | Behavior | MO or SD | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| The teacher who has always answered questions walks in | Student asks for help | SD | Help is available from this teacher and not from a substitute who ignores questions. The student would value help either way. |
| The student has been stuck on a problem for ten minutes | Asks for help | MO (CMO-T) | Being stuck makes help valuable. The teacher was available all along. |
| The “Open” sign at a coffee shop is lit | Going in to order | SD | Coffee is available when the sign is lit. You would want coffee either way. |
| Skipping breakfast | Ordering a large lunch | MO (UMO) | Food is more valuable, not more available. |
| Bright sun in a driver’s eyes | Putting on sunglasses | MO (UMO) | Reducing glare matters only when glare is present. The sunglasses in the cup holder are the SD. |
Common mix-ups
- “It came first, so it is an SD.” Both come first.
- “It made the behavior more likely, so it is an SD.” MOs have evocative effects too.
- “The aversive stimulus in escape is an SD.” In Michael’s analysis it is an MO, because it changes the value of its own removal.
- “An instruction is always an SD.” One stimulus can have more than one function. A demand can be an SD for compliance (if compliance has been reinforced) and a CMO-R for escape at the same time.
- “An SD makes the reinforcer more valuable.” It does not. If the value changed, an MO did it.
Exam tip: Remove the antecedent in your head and look at the reinforcer. Still there but not worth much? MO. Still worth a lot but cannot be gotten? SD.
Quick recap
- SDs signal availability; MOs alter value.
- An SD’s absence means the reinforcer is unavailable but would still be effective.
- An MO’s absence means the reinforcer may be available but is not effective.
- The aversive stimulus in an escape contingency is an MO, not an SD.
- CMO-Ts and CMO-Rs are the cases most often mistaken for SDs.
- SDs only evoke behavior when a relevant MO is in effect.
Further reading
- Michael, J. (1982). Distinguishing between discriminative and motivational functions of stimuli. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 149-155.
- Laraway, S., Snycerski, S., Michael, J., & Poling, A. (2003). Motivating operations and terms to describe them: Some further refinements. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 36(3), 407-414.
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 16.
Key terms
- Motivating operation (MO)
- An environmental variable that temporarily changes how effective a stimulus is as a reinforcer or punisher (the value-altering effect) and changes how often behavior that has produced that stimulus occurs (the behavior-altering effect).
- Discriminative stimulus (SD, S-dee)
- A stimulus in whose presence a particular behavior has been reinforced and in whose absence it has not been reinforced, or has been reinforced less. Because of that history, the behavior is more likely when the stimulus is present. A discriminative stimulus evokes behavior; it does not elicit it.
- Stimulus control
- A relation in which the rate, latency, duration or intensity of a behavior changes in the presence of a particular antecedent stimulus. It develops when the behavior has been reinforced in the presence of that stimulus and not reinforced, or reinforced less, in its absence.
- Transitive conditioned motivating operation (CMO-T, Transitive CMO)
- A stimulus that makes some other stimulus effective as a reinforcer, usually because that other stimulus is needed to obtain a further reinforcer, and evokes behavior that has produced it.
- Reflexive conditioned motivating operation (CMO-R, Reflexive CMO)
- A stimulus that has reliably preceded some form of worsening, so that its own removal becomes reinforcing and behavior that has removed it is evoked. A stimulus that has preceded improvement works the other way: its removal becomes punishing.
- Surrogate conditioned motivating operation (CMO-S, Surrogate CMO)
- A stimulus that has been paired with another motivating operation and comes to have the same value-altering and behavior-altering effects as that motivating operation. Evidence for this type in people is limited.
Check yourself
4 questions on B.17. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: B. The lit display signals that buying produces a drink, so it is an SD. The run does not make drinks any more available; it makes them more valuable, so it is an MO. Coming first and increasing behavior are true of both, so neither fact tells them apart.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Without the salt, water is still available but worth less, so the salt changes value, not availability. That makes it an MO. The last choice describes an MO's value-altering effect but labels it an SD, which is the confusion the item is testing.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Without the demand, a break from it would have no value, so the demand changes the value of escape. Michael argued that this makes it an MO (here a reflexive CMO), not an SD. The SD choice is tempting, but an SD requires that the reinforcer would have been effective in its absence.
Show the answer
Answer: C. An SD's absence means the reinforcer is not available even though it would still be effective. An MO's absence means the reinforcer may be available but is not effective. Both come before behavior and both can increase it, and both can be learned, so the other questions do not separate them.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.