cumulative

I.4 Selecting supervision goals from an assessment

What the task asks: Choose supervision goals by first assessing what the supervisee can already do, the cultural variables that affect how they learn and work, and what their setting requires and makes possible.

Personnel Supervision and Management5 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

No behavior analyst would write a client’s treatment goals without an assessment. Supervision follows the same logic. Before deciding what a supervisee should learn, find out what they can already do, what they cannot do yet and what their setting needs from them.

A supervision plan that skips this step wastes time on skills the supervisee already has and misses the ones they lack. A plan built on assessment targets the gaps that matter most, fits the supervisee’s background and can be carried out where they work. The Ethics Code expects supervision to be individualized for each supervisee and their circumstances (Standard 4.06, Providing Supervision and Training).

Breaking it down

Assessing the supervisee’s skills

Competency-based assessment measures whether a supervisee can actually perform a skill to a set standard, rather than whether they have heard of it or logged hours doing it. Common sources:

  • Direct observation with clients, scored on a task-analyzed checklist
  • Role-play with the supervisor acting as client or caregiver, useful for skills that rarely come up naturally, such as responding to severe problem behavior
  • Work products: data sheets, graphs, written plans and reports
  • Knowledge checks: quizzes or verbal explanations, best for conceptual skills

Self-assessment asks the supervisee to rate their own skills. It is quick, involves the supervisee in planning and shows what they want to learn. But self-ratings often do not match observed performance, in either direction, so they supplement direct measures rather than replace them.

Assess across areas: technical skills (measurement, assessment, intervention), professional skills (time management, communication, receiving feedback), ethics and, for a trainee, the content they will need as an independent practitioner.

Assessing cultural variables

Cultural variables shape how a supervisee learns and works. Relevant ones include:

  • The languages they speak, and whether they serve families who share them
  • Their values, learning history and prior training contexts
  • How they prefer to receive feedback, and what is reinforcing for them
  • Their skill at serving clients whose backgrounds differ from their own

The Ethics Code asks behavior analysts to evaluate how well their supervisees can meet the needs of people from diverse backgrounds (Standard 1.07, Cultural Responsiveness and Diversity). That makes cultural responsiveness both a skill area to assess and, where needed, a goal.

Assessing the environment

The setting limits and shapes which goals are realistic:

  • Role and requirements: what the supervisee’s job, credential path and funders require
  • Opportunities: which clients, assessments and meetings are available for practice
  • Resources: time for supervision, materials, technology and supervision modality
  • Organizational priorities: policies and the skills the team most needs

A trainee in a school will meet different opportunities than one in an in-home program. If a needed experience does not occur naturally, the supervisor arranges it through role-play, a rotation or a different case.

Writing and prioritizing the goals

Write supervision goals the way you would write client goals (see H.1): observable, measurable and with a mastery criterion that says how well and how consistently the skill must be performed. For example: “Implements discrete-trial teaching with at least 90% integrity across three consecutive observations, with two different clients.” Requiring more than one client or setting builds generalization into the goal.

Prioritize goals that affect client safety and outcomes first, then skills that are prerequisites for others, then goals that match the supervisee’s career interests. Reassess regularly and update the plan.

1. Assess 2. Write 3. Prioritize Skills Observation, role-play, work products Cultural variables Language, values, feedback preferences Environment Role, opportunities, resources, priorities Measurable goals Mastery criterion More than one client or setting First: client safety and outcomes Then: prerequisites Skills others build on Then: career interests The supervisee's goals
Assessment comes before goals and covers skills, cultural variables and the environment. The findings become measurable goals, ranked with client safety and outcomes first.

Seeing it in practice

Assessment findingSourceResulting goal
Rates self “very confident” at functional analysis but skips steps in role-playSelf-assessment plus role-playRun analysis conditions with 90% integrity in role-play, then with a client
Writes accurate data summaries but submits them a week lateWork productsSubmit session notes within 24 hours for four consecutive weeks
Bilingual in Spanish and English and wants to work with Spanish-speaking familiesInterviewLead caregiver training in Spanish, with performance checked by observation
The clinic has no clients with severe problem behaviorEnvironmentPractice crisis procedures in role-play to criterion

Common mix-ups

  • Hours are not competence. Completing required hours does not show that a skill is in place. Measure the performance.
  • Self-assessment is a starting point, not the answer. Pair it with direct observation before setting goals.
  • Assess before setting goals, not after. Handing every supervisee the same generic goal list ignores individual skills, culture and setting.
  • The environment is part of the assessment. A goal the setting cannot support will not be met, however well it is written.

Exam tip: If a question asks what to do before setting supervision goals, look for the answer that measures performance directly. If it asks how to choose among possible goals, favor the one the assessment identified that matters most for client outcomes.

Quick recap

  • Assess before setting goals: skills, cultural variables and the environment.
  • Competency-based assessment compares direct observation, role-play and work products against a standard.
  • Self-assessment adds the supervisee’s view but often differs from observed performance.
  • Write goals in measurable terms with mastery criteria, and build in generalization.
  • Prioritize safety and client outcomes, then prerequisites, then career interests.

Further reading

  • Turner, L. B., Fischer, A. J., & Luiselli, J. K. (2016). Towards a competency-based, ethical, and socially valid approach to the supervision of applied behavior analytic trainees. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9(4), 287-298.
  • Sellers, T. P., Valentino, A. L., & LeBlanc, L. A. (2016). Recommended practices for individual supervision of aspiring behavior analysts. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9(4), 274-286.

Key terms

Competency-based assessment
Assessment that measures whether a person can actually perform a skill to a specified standard, using direct observation, role-play or work products, rather than relying on time spent, attendance or self-report.
Self-assessment
A person's own rating or description of their skills, knowledge and learning needs. In supervision it involves the supervisee in planning and reveals their goals, but self-ratings often differ from observed performance, so they supplement direct measurement rather than replace it.
Mastery criterion
A predetermined level of performance that shows a skill has been learned, usually stated as an accuracy level sustained across a set number of sessions, opportunities or settings.
Supervisee
Anyone whose delivery of behavioral services is overseen by a behavior analyst within an agreed supervisory relationship, such as a behavior technician, an assistant behavior analyst or another behavior analyst. A trainee is a supervisee who is also accruing fieldwork toward certification.
Trainee
A person accruing supervised fieldwork experience toward the eligibility requirements for certification as a behavior analyst or assistant behavior analyst.

Check yourself

5 questions on I.4. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A new trainee, Amara, rates herself as highly skilled at writing behavior plans. What should her supervisor do before setting supervision goals?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Self-ratings often differ from actual performance, so the supervisor checks a work product against a clear standard before deciding. Accepting the rating could leave a real deficit unaddressed. A second self-rating still gives no direct measure of the skill.

  2. Question 2A trainee works at a clinic that serves only young children with communication goals. One of the trainee's supervision goals is experience with severe aggression. What is the best way to handle this limit of the setting?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. When the setting lacks an opportunity, the supervisor creates one through role-play, a rotation or another arranged experience. Dropping the goal leaves a gap in the trainee's competence. Reading builds knowledge but does not show that the trainee can perform the skill.

  3. Question 3Which supervision goal is written most appropriately?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. A good goal names an observable behavior and a mastery criterion, so anyone can tell when it has been met. Understanding and comfort cannot be observed directly. Completing a module is a training activity, not evidence that the skill is performed.

  4. Question 4Lucía is bilingual in Spanish and English and wants to work with Spanish-speaking families. Her assessment shows strong caregiver-training skills in English. Which goal best reflects the assessment of cultural variables?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. The assessment found a language repertoire, a career interest and strong underlying skills, so a goal that applies those skills in Spanish fits all three. Translating forms uses her language but does not build a clinical skill. Restricting her to English ignores both her strengths and the families who could benefit.

  5. Question 5Theo has completed all of his required fieldwork hours, but his supervisor has never observed him conduct a preference assessment. Which statement is accurate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Competency-based supervision asks whether the trainee can perform each skill to criterion, which takes direct measurement. Time in the role, even supervised time, does not guarantee skill. A written quiz would test knowledge, not performance.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.