The big idea
Knowing what works in research is not enough. An intervention also has to match why the behavior happens, suit the person and family, and be something the people in the client’s life can actually carry out. Behavior analysts weigh four things together: the assessment results, the scientific evidence, the preferences of the client and stakeholders, and the contextual fit of the procedure with the setting.
Standard 2.14 (Selecting, Designing, and Implementing Behavior-Change Interventions) lists these considerations, including that interventions be based on assessment results and prioritize positive reinforcement. Standard 2.15 (Minimizing Risk of Behavior-Change Interventions) sets the conditions for restrictive or punishment-based procedures.
Breaking it down
1. Assessment results
A function-based intervention is built around the maintaining variables found in the functional assessment. If a student’s disruption is maintained by escape from hard tasks, extra praise may do little; teaching a break request, adjusting task difficulty and not letting disruption end the task address the function. Interventions chosen without regard to function can fail or make things worse, such as time-out for behavior maintained by escape.
2. Scientific evidence
Evidence-based practice in ABA integrates the best available research, the client’s values and context, and the practitioner’s professional expertise (Slocum et al., 2014). Ask: has this procedure been shown to work for similar behaviors, people and settings? How strong and how often replicated is that evidence? Single-case research counts, and the size and consistency of effects matter.
3. Client and stakeholder preferences
Clients and families have a right to choose among effective options (Standard 2.09, Involving Clients and Stakeholders). Present choices in plain language, with likely benefits, risks and effort. Procedures that people find unacceptable are often implemented poorly or dropped, which is why the social validity of procedures (how acceptable the goals, methods and results are to the people affected) matters as much as that of goals.
4. Contextual fit
Contextual fit is the match between a procedure and the people and setting that will use it:
- Implementer skill and time: Can a teacher with 25 students deliver reinforcement every 2 minutes? Can a parent run a complex token system during dinner?
- Cultural values: Does the procedure conflict with the family’s views on rewards, discipline or independence?
- Resources: Staffing, space, materials, money and schedule.
- Sustainability: Will it still run after the behavior analyst steps back?
A slightly less powerful intervention that will be implemented well usually beats a stronger one that will not.
Least restrictive, most effective
The least restrictive alternative is the option that limits the client’s freedom, comfort and access to typical settings the least while still being effective. In practice:
- Start with antecedent and reinforcement-based procedures.
- Use restrictive or punishment-based procedures only when less intrusive ones have not worked, or when the risk of harm from the behavior outweighs the risk of the procedure, with any required review and close monitoring (Standard 2.15).
- Remember that clients also have a right to effective treatment (Van Houten et al., 1988). Months of a mild procedure that is not working can do more harm than a well-supported, more intensive one.
Seeing it in practice
Ama, 12, screams and drops to the floor when asked to leave the computer. The functional analysis shows the behavior is maintained by continued access to the computer.
| Option | Matches function? | Evidence | Preference and fit | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Warnings before transitions, a visual timer, and computer time again after the next activity | Yes | Good support for transitions | Teachers can do it; Ama’s parents like it | Use |
| Teach “five more minutes, please” and honor it, then thin gradually | Yes | Strong (functional communication training) | Fits; staff need brief training | Use |
| Time-out after screaming | No: does not address losing the computer and may let her avoid the next activity | Weak for this function | Family dislikes it | Reject |
| Response cost of computer minutes | Partly | Some support | More restrictive; consider only if the first two fail, with review | Hold |
Common mix-ups
- Evidence-based does not mean research only. It combines research, client values and context, and professional judgment.
- Least restrictive is not least effective. The aim is the least restrictive option that works.
- Preference does not override safety or ethics. If a family asks for a harmful or unsupported procedure, explain the evidence and offer effective alternatives.
- A procedure that worked for one client may not fit the next. Function, setting and implementers differ, so repeat the assessment and check contextual fit for each client.
Exam tip: In intervention-choice questions, first rule out options that do not match the function. Then prefer reinforcement-based options that the actual implementers can carry out and the family accepts.
Quick recap
- Base interventions on assessment results, especially function.
- Weigh research evidence, client and family preferences and contextual fit together.
- Contextual fit includes implementer skill, culture, resources and sustainability.
- Choose the least restrictive option likely to be effective, with positive reinforcement first.
Further reading
- Slocum, T. A., Detrich, R., Wilczynski, S. M., Spencer, T. D., Lewis, T., & Wolfe, K. (2014). The evidence-based practice of applied behavior analysis. The Behavior Analyst, 37(1), 41-56.
- Van Houten, R., Axelrod, S., Bailey, J. S., Favell, J. E., Foxx, R. M., Iwata, B. A., & Lovaas, O. I. (1988). The right to effective behavioral treatment. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21(4), 381-384.
Key terms
- Function-based intervention (Function-based treatment)
- An intervention designed around the variables found to maintain a behavior in a functional behavior assessment, typically by changing the antecedents that evoke it, teaching an alternative that produces the same reinforcer, and withholding that reinforcer for the problem behavior.
- Evidence-based practice (EBP)
- Decision making that integrates the best available research evidence with the client's values and context and the practitioner's professional expertise (Slocum et al., 2014).
- Contextual fit
- How well an intervention matches the values, skills, routines and resources of the people and setting where it will be used. Plans with good contextual fit are more likely to be carried out as designed and to last.
- Least restrictive alternative
- The principle of choosing, among interventions likely to be effective, the one that places the fewest limits on the client's freedom, comfort and access to typical settings.
- Social validity
- The extent to which the goals, procedures and outcomes of an intervention are acceptable, important and useful to the people it affects, such as clients, caregivers and supervisees. It is usually measured with surveys, interviews or rating scales.
Check yourself
5 questions on H.2. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: D. A function-based plan gives Jamal another way to get a break and stops hitting from producing escape. Time-out removes him from the task, so it would likely reinforce hitting. Tokens and attention do not address escape at all.
Show the answer
Answer: D. A procedure that does not fit the implementer's time, skills and routines is often not carried out, however strong its evidence. Research support for token systems is good, so the evidence was not the weak point in this case.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Evidence-based practice integrates the best available research with the client's values and context and the practitioner's expertise. Single-case research counts as evidence, and family preference matters but is one input, not the whole decision.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Standard 2.15 permits restrictive or punishment-based procedures when less intrusive ones have not produced the needed results or when the risk of harm outweighs the risk of the procedure, with required reviews and ongoing evaluation. Continuing an ineffective plan indefinitely ignores the client's right to effective treatment.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Client and family preferences are part of selecting an intervention, and other effective options are available. Using food without the family's agreement, even only in the clinic, would disregard their values and their right to make informed choices about services.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.