The big idea
Much human behavior is evoked by words: “Line up at the door.” “Wash your hands before you start.” “If you finish by noon, you can leave early.” Instructions and rules are the cheapest procedures in the field.
They also fail often, for predictable reasons. A rule works only when the listener has a history of reinforcement for following rules, can do what the rule describes, and meets consequences that back it up. This task asks you to design instructions and rules that work, and to recognize when words alone are not enough.
Breaking it down
Instructions
An instruction tells the listener what to do. Effective instructions:
- Get attention first: use the person’s name and be close by.
- Name the behavior specifically: “Put the red blocks in the bin” rather than “Clean up.”
- Are statements, not questions: “Time to put your shoes on” rather than “Do you want to put your shoes on?” A question invites “no.”
- Are short and matched to the listener’s language: one or two steps at a time for young learners, with written or picture supports where useful.
- Are given once and followed by a short wait, then a prompt if needed (see G.7), rather than repeated again and again.
- Are followed by reinforcement for compliance.
Repeating an instruction five times teaches the listener that the first four did not count.
Rules as contingency-specifying stimuli
A rule is a verbal description of a contingency: a behavior, its consequence and often the setting. “If you finish your reading log, you can choose the game on Friday.” Skinner called such descriptions contingency-specifying stimuli. Rule-governed behavior is controlled by the description; contingency-shaped behavior is controlled by direct experience with the consequences (see B.18). Analysts disagree about exactly how rules work: some treat them as a special kind of SD, while others argue they change the function of other stimuli. For the exam, the key point is that a rule can control behavior the listener has never directly experienced.
Rules are especially useful when consequences are:
- delayed (a grade at the end of term);
- small or cumulative (one healthy meal does little alone);
- dangerous to learn by experience (traffic, hot stoves).
Rules are more likely to be followed when they name the behavior clearly, state a consequence that is sizable and likely, give a deadline, and come from someone who reliably follows through.
Group and classroom rules
Keep the list short (three to five), state what to do rather than what not to do, make each rule observable, post them, teach them with examples and non-examples, and back them with consequences. In a classic classroom study (Madsen, Becker, & Thomas, 1968), posting and reviewing rules alone changed little. Adding praise for following them made the difference.
Instructional control
Instructional control is reliable responding to instructions, and it is learned. People follow instructions because following them has paid off in the past. A learner whose instructions have often led nowhere, or who rarely contacted reinforcement for compliance, will show weak instructional control. Build it with easy instructions, quick reinforcement for compliance and consistent follow-through.
Insensitivity to changed contingencies
Rule-governed behavior can persist after the real contingencies change. A staff member told to check a paper schedule may keep doing it after the schedule moves online. When the stated rule and the actual contingency differ, check which one is controlling behavior.
When instructions alone are not enough
Add more than words when:
- the skill is not in the repertoire. Instructions cannot build a new, complex response; use modeling, prompting and shaping (see G.7, G.9 and G.11);
- the listener lacks the verbal skills to understand the instruction;
- competing contingencies are stronger. “Do your homework” loses to a video game if nothing backs it up;
- there is no history of reinforcement for following this person’s instructions.
This is why emailing a protocol to staff is not training. Behavioral skills training (BST) adds modeling, rehearsal and feedback to the instructions (see I.5).
Evaluating instructions and rules
Measure compliance: the percentage of instructions followed, the latency to start and whether the task was done correctly. Compare instructions alone with instructions plus consequences. If compliance is low, check the instruction’s clarity, the listener’s skills and what happens after compliance.
Seeing it in practice
| Situation | Weaker version | Stronger version |
|---|---|---|
| Home: Kofi, 6 | “Can you get ready for bed?” called from another room, three times | Close by: “Kofi, pajamas on, then pick a book.” Praise when he does. |
| Classroom: Ms. Patel’s 3rd grade | Ten rules that start with “Don’t,” posted on day one | Four positive rules, practiced with role-play, praised when followed |
| Clinic: new technicians | An emailed protocol for a new prompting procedure | BST: written steps, modeling, rehearsal and feedback to criterion |
| Home: Ayumi, 15 | “Study harder or you’ll regret it.” | “Do 20 practice items each night. If you average 80 percent this week, you pick Saturday’s outing.” |
Common mix-ups
- Rules and ordinary SDs gain control differently. An SD gains control through direct experience with reinforcement in its presence. A rule describes the contingency, so it can control behavior the listener has never contacted.
- Rules need backup. A rule whose stated consequence never arrives loses control.
- Instructions are not teaching. If the person cannot perform the skill, instructions only tell them what they cannot do.
- A question is not an instruction. If “no” is not an acceptable answer, do not ask a question.
Exam tip: If people know the rule but do not follow it, look for missing consequences. If they want to comply but cannot perform the skill, the answer is modeling, rehearsal and feedback, not a clearer instruction.
Quick recap
- Effective instructions get attention, specify the behavior, are statements, are short, are given once and are reinforced.
- Rules describe contingencies and help most when consequences are delayed, small or dangerous.
- Instructional control is learned through reinforcement for following instructions.
- Rule-governed behavior can be insensitive to changed contingencies.
- When skills, verbal ability or consequences are missing, add modeling, prompting and reinforcement.
Further reading
- Madsen, C. H., Jr., Becker, W. C., & Thomas, D. R. (1968). Rules, praise, and ignoring: Elements of elementary classroom control. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1(2), 139-150.
- Hayes, S. C. (Ed.). (1989). Rule-governed behavior: Cognition, contingencies, and instructional control. Plenum Press.
- Parsons, M. B., Rollyson, J. H., & Reid, D. H. (2012). Evidence-based staff training: A guide for practitioners. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 5(2), 2-11.
Key terms
- Rule (Contingency-specifying stimulus)
- A verbal description of a contingency: a behavior, its consequence and often the conditions in which it applies. Rules can control behavior that the listener has never contacted directly.
- Rule-governed behavior
- Behavior controlled by a verbal description of a contingency (a rule) rather than by direct experience with the consequences. It can be acquired quickly but may persist after the actual contingencies change.
- Contingency-shaped behavior
- Behavior that has been selected and maintained by direct contact with its consequences, rather than by a verbal description of them.
- Instructional control
- Reliable responding to instructions, established through a history in which following instructions has been reinforced. Weak instructional control often reflects a history in which compliance went unreinforced or instructions were not followed through.
- Behavioral skills training (BST)
- A training package made up of instructions, modeling, rehearsal and feedback, repeated until the learner performs the skill to a mastery criterion. It is a well-supported way to teach new skills to staff, caregivers and clients.
Check yourself
4 questions on G.10. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Effective instructions gain attention, are specific statements rather than questions, are given once with a short wait, and are followed through with prompting and reinforcement. Repeating the request and then doing the task for him has taught Kofi that the instruction does not need to be followed. Long explanations and repeated warnings keep the same weak instruction in place.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Rules gain control when following them produces consequences, and classroom research has found that posted rules alone change little until praise for rule-following is added. More rules or longer reviews add words without adding consequences. Rules stated as what not to do are generally less effective than rules that say what to do.
Show the answer
Answer: B. The staff member's checking is controlled by the original rule, not by what checking actually produces now, which is the classic insensitivity of rule-governed behavior. If the behavior were contingency-shaped it would have weakened once the binder stopped providing information. Extinction would show a decrease, but here the behavior persists.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Written instructions alone rarely produce accurate implementation of a new skill. Behavioral skills training adds modeling, rehearsal and feedback to the instructions until staff meet criterion. Reformatting, reading aloud or signing the protocol are still instructions alone.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.