The big idea
Successful treatment does not erase a behavior’s history. Relapse is the general term for the return of a behavior that treatment had reduced. It is especially likely when the conditions of treatment change: the setting changes, the alternative behavior stops paying off, or the old reinforcer turns up again.
Relapse is predictable, and research on its specific forms points to concrete planning steps. That planning is as much a part of treatment as the intervention itself.
Breaking it down
Four forms of relapse
Resurgence is the return of a previously reinforced behavior when reinforcement for a more recent alternative behavior is withheld or worsens. Example: after FCT, a child asks for breaks instead of hitting. On a busy day, staff do not honor the requests, and hitting returns. Some authors define resurgence broadly, to include any worsening of reinforcement for the alternative, such as thinner schedules or longer delays.
Renewal is the return of an extinguished behavior when the context changes. It is described by three arrangements:
| Type | Behavior learned | Extinction (treatment) | Test | Applied example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ABA | Context A | Context B | Back to A | Treated in clinic; returns at home, where it began |
| ABC | Context A | Context B | New context C | Treated in clinic; appears at a grandparent’s house |
| AAB | Context A | Context A | New context B | Treated at home; appears at a new school |
In laboratory research, ABA renewal is usually the strongest of the three.
Reinstatement is the return of an extinguished behavior after the reinforcer that once maintained it is delivered again, independent of the behavior. Example: a teen’s tantrums for video game time were treated with extinction. A relative later offers free game time, and the tantrums return.
Spontaneous recovery is the reappearance of an extinguished behavior after time away from the extinction conditions, such as at the start of a new day (H.4).
Behavioral momentum and persistence
Behavioral momentum theory (Nevin & Grace, 2000; see B.22) holds that a behavior’s resistance to change depends on the total rate of reinforcement in a context, not only on the reinforcement that follows the behavior. Adding reinforcement to the context, as DRA and noncontingent reinforcement do, can reduce problem behavior quickly yet make it more persistent if treatment lapses. Mace et al. (2010) showed this with DRA, and showed that teaching the alternative behavior first in a separate context reduced the effect.
Planning against relapse
- Thin reinforcement gradually, using data, so the alternative behavior keeps working during thinning (G.16). Signals, such as a card that shows when requests can be honored, help clients tolerate periods without reinforcement.
- Program for several contexts. Treat with different people, places and times, including the settings where the behavior first developed (G.15).
- Fade treatment stimuli gradually so the change from treatment to everyday life is small.
- Keep the alternative behavior strong. Make sure people in every setting will reinforce it, and teach the client to wait for times when they cannot.
- Protect integrity. Lapses, especially reinforcing the problem behavior by mistake, are common triggers for reinstatement and resurgence (H.6).
- Prepare caregivers. Teach them what relapse looks like and how to respond, so a brief recurrence is not reinforced into a full one.
- Monitor after treatment. Follow-up probes and booster sessions catch relapse early.
Seeing it in practice
Nadia, 7, used to hit to get her tablet. Treatment in a clinic combined FCT (“tablet, please”) with extinction.
| What happened | Form of relapse | Plan that would help |
|---|---|---|
| Hitting returned during her first week back home | ABA renewal | Train at home, with her parents, before discharge |
| At school, staff stopped honoring her requests during testing week, and hitting resumed | Resurgence | Teach waiting with signals; brief the school before schedule changes |
| A babysitter gave her tablet time “just because,” and hitting reappeared | Reinstatement | Train every caregiver on the plan |
| Hitting reappeared briefly on Monday mornings after weekends | Spontaneous recovery | Continue extinction consistently; warn staff to expect it |
Common mix-ups
- Resurgence vs. renewal. Resurgence follows a change in what happens to the alternative behavior. Renewal follows a change in context.
- Reinstatement vs. resurgence. Reinstatement needs the old reinforcer to be delivered freely. Resurgence needs reinforcement for the alternative behavior to decrease or stop.
- Spontaneous recovery vs. renewal. Spontaneous recovery comes from the passage of time, in the same context. Renewal comes from a change of context.
- Fast reduction is not lasting reduction. A rich DRA schedule can reduce problem behavior quickly while making it more resistant to change later.
Exam tip: Find the trigger in the scenario. Alternative behavior stopped working: resurgence. A new setting or the original one: renewal. The old reinforcer given for free: reinstatement. Time passed: spontaneous recovery.
Quick recap
- Relapse is the return of a treated behavior; it is predictable and can be planned for.
- Resurgence, renewal, reinstatement and spontaneous recovery each have a different trigger.
- Behavioral momentum theory explains why rich reinforcement in the treatment context can increase persistence.
- Thin schedules gradually, treat across contexts, keep the alternative reinforced, protect integrity and monitor after treatment.
Further reading
- Nevin, J. A., & Grace, R. C. (2000). Behavioral momentum and the law of effect. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 23(1), 73-90.
- Hanley, G. P., Iwata, B. A., & Thompson, R. H. (2001). Reinforcement schedule thinning following treatment with functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 34(1), 17-38.
Key terms
- Relapse (Treatment relapse)
- The return of a behavior that had been reduced by treatment. Specific forms include resurgence, renewal, reinstatement and spontaneous recovery, each with a different trigger.
- Resurgence
- The return of a previously reinforced behavior when reinforcement for a more recently reinforced alternative behavior is reduced or stopped.
- Renewal
- The return of an extinguished behavior when the context changes from the one in which extinction took place, either back to the original context (ABA renewal) or to a new one (ABC and AAB renewal).
- Reinstatement
- The return of an extinguished behavior after the reinforcer that used to maintain it is delivered again, independent of the behavior.
- Spontaneous recovery
- The reappearance of an extinguished behavior after time has passed, often at the start of a later session, even though reinforcement is still withheld (or, in respondent extinction, the unconditioned stimulus is still absent). The recovered behavior is usually weaker and briefer than before and fades if extinction continues.
- Behavioral momentum
- John Nevin's metaphor and theory holding that behavior has a rate, like velocity, and a resistance to change, like mass. Resistance to change depends mainly on the total reinforcement correlated with the stimulus context. In applied work the term is also used for the high-probability request sequence.
- Resistance to change
- How much a behavior continues, relative to its own baseline, when it is disrupted by extinction, distraction, satiation, free reinforcement or another challenge. In behavioral momentum theory it depends on the reinforcement correlated with the stimulus context.
Check yourself
5 questions on H.5. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.
Show the answer
Answer: D. The crying returned because the more recent alternative behavior, asking for help, stopped being reinforced. That is resurgence. Renewal would require a change of context, but Mia is in the same classroom with the same teacher.
Show the answer
Answer: D. The behavior was learned at home (A), extinguished in the clinic (B) and returned on going back home (A), which is ABA renewal. ABC renewal would involve a third, new setting, and reinstatement would require the old reinforcer to be delivered freely.
Show the answer
Answer: C. Reinstatement is the return of an extinguished behavior after the reinforcer that once maintained it is delivered again, independent of the behavior. Resurgence would require reinforcement of an alternative behavior to stop.
Show the answer
Answer: A. Behavioral momentum theory holds that persistence depends on the total reinforcement available in a context. DRA adds reinforcement to that context, so if treatment lapses, the problem behavior can be more resistant to change. DRA does not reinforce the problem behavior directly.
Show the answer
Answer: D. Training in the home with the people who will continue the plan reduces the context change that drives renewal and keeps the alternative behavior reinforced. Adding reinforcement only in the clinic does nothing for the home context and may increase persistence there.
Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.