cumulative

B.5 Positive vs. negative punishment

What the task asks: Classify a consequence as positive or negative punishment by asking whether a stimulus was added or removed and whether the behavior then became less frequent.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Punishment is the process in which a behavior is followed by a consequence and, as a result, occurs less often in the future. It is the mirror image of reinforcement (see B.4) and is defined the same way: by what happens to the behavior, not by what anyone meant to do.

The same labels apply. Positive punishment adds a stimulus after the behavior. Negative punishment removes one. In both, the behavior decreases. As with reinforcement, positive and negative are arithmetic signs, not judgments.

Breaking it down

Defined by the effect

A consequence is punishment only if the behavior it follows becomes less frequent in the future. The stimulus change that has this effect is a punisher. A scolding that makes a student’s swearing increase is not a punisher for that student; it is a reinforcer. A fine that has no effect on speeding is not functioning as a punisher either.

Punishment works best when it is immediate and consistent. Its effect is also weaker when the behavior is still producing reinforcement at the same time, which is why punishment alone rarely solves a problem that reinforcement is maintaining.

The same two questions

  1. Was a stimulus added or removed right after the behavior?
  2. Did the behavior decrease in the future?

If a stimulus was added and the behavior decreased, it is positive punishment. If a stimulus was removed and the behavior decreased, it is negative punishment.

Stimulus added Stimulus removed Behavior increases Behavior decreases Positive reinforcement Praise follows a raised hand. Hand-raising happens more. Negative reinforcement Buckling up stops the chime. Buckling up happens sooner. Positive punishment A reprimand follows calling out. Calling out happens less. Negative punishment Screen time is lost after hitting. Hitting happens less.
Punishment is the bottom row of the same grid that defines reinforcement (B.4). Read the column first (added or removed), then the row (did the behavior go up or down afterward).

Positive punishment

A stimulus appears or increases after the behavior, and the behavior becomes less frequent. Touching a hot stove produces a burn. A coach adds a lap each time a player arrives late. A supervisor gives corrective feedback each time a technician skips a data sheet, and skipped sheets decline. The added stimulus is often an aversive stimulus, one the person would act to escape or avoid, but what makes it punishment is the decrease in behavior.

Negative punishment

A stimulus is removed or reduced after the behavior, and the behavior becomes less frequent. What is removed is usually a reinforcer the person already has, or access to one. The two main procedures, covered in G.17, are:

  • Response cost: losing a specific amount of a reinforcer, such as tokens, points, minutes of recess or money.
  • Time-out from positive reinforcement: losing access to reinforcement for a period, such as sitting out of a game for two minutes.

Punishment is not extinction

Negative punishment and extinction (see B.11) both reduce behavior, and both can look like “taking something away”, so candidates mix them up. The difference is which reinforcer is involved:

  • Extinction withholds the reinforcer that has been maintaining the behavior. The behavior simply stops producing it.
  • Negative punishment removes a different reinforcer, one the person already has, as a consequence of the behavior.

If a child whines for attention, ignoring the whining is extinction. Taking away the child’s tablet time for whining is negative punishment.

Seeing it in practice

ScenarioAdded or removed?BehaviorContingency
A teen loses phone privileges the next day each time they miss curfew; missed curfews drop.Phone access removedDecreasesNegative punishment
A worker grabs a frayed cable and gets a mild shock; grabbing cables without checking stops.Shock addedDecreasesPositive punishment
A student loses two tokens for each call-out; call-outs fall over two weeks.Tokens removedDecreasesNegative punishment (response cost)
A parent says “No!” sharply each time a toddler reaches for an outlet; reaching drops.Reprimand addedDecreasesPositive punishment
A teacher sends a student to the office for swearing; swearing increases.Class removedIncreasesNot punishment: negative reinforcement (escape)

The last row is the one the exam likes best. Being sent out of class looked like punishment, but the behavior went up. For a student who wants out of a hard lesson, leaving is an escape contingency.

Common mix-ups

  • Negative punishment is not negative reinforcement. Both involve removal, but reinforcement increases behavior and punishment decreases it.
  • Positive punishment is not “bad punishment”. Positive only means a stimulus was added.
  • Intent and harshness do not decide. Something meant to punish that increases behavior is a reinforcer for that person.
  • Negative punishment is not extinction. Extinction withholds the maintaining reinforcer; negative punishment removes a different one.
  • Not every decrease is punishment. Behavior can also fall because of satiation, extinction or a change in setting. Punishment requires the decrease to come from the contingent consequence.
  • Effects may not last. Behavior reduced by punishment often returns once the punishment contingency ends, especially if the behavior is still reinforced.

Exam tip: Check the direction of the behavior first. If it went up, the answer is some form of reinforcement, no matter how harsh the consequence sounds.

Quick recap

  • Punishment decreases future behavior and is defined by that effect alone.
  • Positive punishment adds a stimulus; negative punishment removes one.
  • Response cost and time-out are the two main negative punishment procedures.
  • Extinction withholds the maintaining reinforcer; negative punishment removes a different reinforcer.
  • When behavior increases after a “punishment”, it is reinforcement.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 14 and 15.
  • Lerman, D. C., & Vorndran, C. M. (2002). On the status of knowledge for using punishment: Implications for treating behavior disorders. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 35(4), 431-464.

Key terms

Punishment
A process in which a behavior is followed by a stimulus change that decreases the future frequency of that behavior under similar conditions. Like reinforcement, it is defined by its effect on behavior, not by anyone's intent or by how unpleasant the consequence seems.
Punisher
A stimulus change that follows a behavior and decreases its future frequency. As with reinforcers, the label depends on the effect on behavior, not on how the stimulus looks or what anyone intended.
Positive punishment (Type I punishment)
Punishment in which a stimulus is added, or increased in intensity, right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs less often in the future. Positive means added, not good.
Negative punishment (Type II punishment)
Punishment in which a stimulus, usually a reinforcer the person already has or access to one, is removed or reduced right after a behavior, and the behavior occurs less often in the future. Response cost and time-out from positive reinforcement are the two main procedures.
Aversive stimulus
A stimulus whose removal after a behavior functions as reinforcement, or whose presentation after a behavior functions as punishment. It can also evoke behavior that has ended it in the past. In everyday terms it is unpleasant, but technically it is defined by these effects on behavior.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.5. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1At a group home, residents earn points they trade for outings. Each time Devon curses at staff, he loses 10 points, and cursing decreases over the month. Which contingency does this describe?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Points Devon already had were removed after cursing, and cursing decreased, which is negative punishment (response cost). Extinction would mean withholding whatever reinforcer had been maintaining the cursing, such as staff reactions, rather than taking away points.

  2. Question 2A preschooler pulls a classmate's hair, and the teacher immediately says 'No pulling!' in a firm voice. Over the next two weeks, hair-pulling continues at the same rate. What can be concluded about the reprimand?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Punishment is defined by a decrease in future behavior. Hair-pulling did not change, so the reprimand is not functioning as a punisher of any kind, however firm it was. The teacher's intent does not make it punishment.

  3. Question 3Ximena used to get her older brother Andrés's attention by poking him. Now Andrés stays silent and keeps reading when she pokes him, and poking gradually decreases. Which procedure is Andrés using?
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Attention was the reinforcer maintaining poking, and Andrés is withholding it, which is extinction. Negative punishment would require removing a different reinforcer Ximena already had, such as her own tablet time, after each poke.

  4. Question 4Which example best illustrates positive punishment?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A stimulus (the extra lap) is added after lateness and lateness decreases, so this is positive punishment. Losing screen time is negative punishment, being excused from a quiz is negative reinforcement, and the broken button is extinction.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.