cumulative

B.22 Behavioral momentum and response persistence

What the task asks: Recognize how behavioral momentum explains why some behavior keeps going when its conditions are disrupted, and apply that account to practice.

Concepts and Principles5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Some behavior keeps going when conditions get rough. Other behavior falls apart. Behavioral momentum is John Nevin’s metaphor from physics for this difference (Nevin, Mandell, & Atak, 1983). Behavior has something like velocity, its rate, and something like mass, its resistance to change. A heavy object is hard to stop. So is behavior with a rich reinforcement history in a particular context.

Resistance to change is how much responding continues, relative to its own baseline, when something disrupts it: extinction, distraction, satiation, a free reinforcer or a competing activity. The theory explains why some well-meant interventions can make problem behavior more persistent, why new skills taught under rich reinforcement hold up better, and why old behavior comes back.

Breaking it down

Rate and persistence are separate

Momentum theory separates two relations:

  • The response-reinforcer relation (the operant contingency) mainly determines response rate.
  • The stimulus-reinforcer relation (all reinforcement correlated with the context, whether it depends on the response or not) mainly determines resistance to change.

In laboratory studies with multiple schedules (B.10), adding free food to one component lowered the rate of the target response there, because the free food competed with it. Yet responding in that component was more resistant to disruption than responding in the leaner component. A lower rate came with more persistence.

Measuring persistence

Resistance to change is measured as a proportion of baseline. If a behavior drops from 20 per hour to 16 when disrupted, it kept 80% of its baseline. A behavior that drops from 20 to 4 kept 20%. The first is more resistant to change.

Data entryFiling020406080100120Before the moveOffice move12345678910WorkdaysPercentage of baseline
The office move from the table below, with each task plotted as a percentage of its own baseline. Data entry, which gets frequent feedback, keeps about 80% of its baseline and filing keeps about 20%, so data entry is more resistant to change.

What it means for problem behavior

DRA and noncontingent reinforcement (NCR) delivered in the same context as problem behavior add reinforcement to that context. They usually reduce problem behavior while they are running. Momentum theory predicts a side effect: the problem behavior may become more persistent when treatment is challenged. If caregivers stop reinforcing the alternative, the problem behavior can come back, often strongly. This return is resurgence. Mace and colleagues (2010) showed this effect with clients and tested one remedy: teach the alternative behavior in a separate context before bringing it into the problem context. Planning for treatment lapses is part of H.5.

What it means for skills

The same logic works in your favor. Skills that are reinforced richly in the contexts where they need to occur are more likely to persist when routines are disrupted, and to survive schedule thinning and the end of the intervention (B.15).

Extinction is a special case

Behavior reinforced intermittently usually shows more resistance to extinction than behavior reinforced every time, which seems to contradict the rule that more reinforcement means more persistence. Momentum researchers explain the difference by noting that the shift from continuous reinforcement to extinction is easier to detect than the shift from a lean schedule to extinction.

The high-p request sequence

In applied work, “behavioral momentum” often refers to the high-probability request sequence (Mace et al., 1988). Present three to five requests the learner almost always follows, reinforce each one, then immediately present the low-probability request. Compliance with the low-p request often improves. The procedure borrows the momentum metaphor, but whether it works through the same process as Nevin’s theory is debated. How to use it as an antecedent procedure belongs to G.5.

High-p 1 High-p 2 High-p 3 Low-p "High five" "Touch your nose" "Say hi" "Put on your coat" Praise Praise Praise Compliance more likely Each request comes right after the last one is followed and praised
The high-p sequence before Jae's coat request. Three easy requests, each followed and praised in quick succession, come right before the low-p request.

Seeing it in practice

SituationWhat momentum predictsWhy
A class has been praised all year for lining up in the hallway and rarely for cleaning up. A fire drill disrupts both routines.Lining up holds up better than cleaning up.Lining up has the richer reinforcement history in its context.
Ravi’s yelling was reduced with DRA in the family room. His parents get busy and stop responding to his requests.Yelling may resurge sharply.DRA added reinforcement to the family-room context.
Before asking Jae to put on his coat, the teacher asks for a high five, “touch your nose” and “say hi,” praising each.Jae is more likely to put on his coat.High-p sequence.
An office move disrupts routines. Data entry, which gets frequent feedback, stays at 80% of baseline. Filing, which rarely gets feedback, falls to 20%.Data entry is more resistant to change.Richer reinforcement in the data-entry context.

Common mix-ups

  • Rate is not persistence. A high rate does not guarantee high resistance to change, and a low-rate behavior in a rich context can be very persistent.
  • Theory vs. procedure. Behavioral momentum theory is about persistence. The high-p sequence is a compliance procedure that borrows the name.
  • More alternative reinforcement has a trade-off. DRA reduces problem behavior now but can raise its persistence later. Keep using DRA, and plan for lapses.
  • Resistance to change is broader than resistance to extinction. Extinction is one disruptor among many, and it follows its own pattern.
  • Momentum is not maintenance. Maintenance is an outcome after intervention ends (B.15). Momentum theory is one account of why some behavior lasts.

Exam tip: For a persistence question, look at the reinforcement history of the context, not just of the response. More reinforcement correlated with the context means more resistance to change.

Quick recap

  • Behavioral momentum compares response rate to velocity and resistance to change to mass.
  • Response-reinforcer relations drive rate; stimulus-reinforcer relations drive persistence.
  • Adding reinforcement to a context, even for other behavior, can make problem behavior more persistent.
  • Resurgence is the return of problem behavior when alternative reinforcement stops.
  • The high-p request sequence is an applied procedure named after the metaphor.

Further reading

  • Nevin, J. A., Mandell, C., & Atak, J. R. (1983). The analysis of behavioral momentum. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 39(1), 49-59.
  • Nevin, J. A., & Grace, R. C. (2000). Behavioral momentum and the law of effect. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 23(1), 73-90.
  • Mace, F. C., Hock, M. L., Lalli, J. S., West, B. J., Belfiore, P., Pinter, E., & Brown, D. K. (1988). Behavioral momentum in the treatment of noncompliance. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21(2), 123-141.

Key terms

Behavioral momentum
John Nevin's metaphor and theory holding that behavior has a rate, like velocity, and a resistance to change, like mass. Resistance to change depends mainly on the total reinforcement correlated with the stimulus context. In applied work the term is also used for the high-probability request sequence.
Resistance to change
How much a behavior continues, relative to its own baseline, when it is disrupted by extinction, distraction, satiation, free reinforcement or another challenge. In behavioral momentum theory it depends on the reinforcement correlated with the stimulus context.
High-probability request sequence (High-p sequence, High-probability instructional sequence)
An antecedent procedure in which two to five quick requests that the learner usually follows are presented and reinforced, followed immediately by a request the learner usually does not follow. Compliance with the low-probability request tends to increase.
Resistance to extinction
How long, or how many times, a behavior keeps occurring after extinction begins. It is greater after intermittent reinforcement (especially on variable schedules) than after continuous reinforcement, and it is also affected by the length of the reinforcement history, the current motivating operation and response effort.
Resurgence
The return of a previously reinforced behavior when reinforcement for a more recently reinforced alternative behavior is reduced or stopped.

Check yourself

4 questions on B.22. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1In a multiple schedule, a pigeon earns food for pecking in both components. In component A, extra food is also delivered free every minute, and pecking there is slower than in component B. When both components are disrupted by prefeeding, what does behavioral momentum theory predict?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Resistance to change depends on the total reinforcement correlated with a stimulus context, contingent or not. Component A has more total reinforcement, so pecking there should hold up better relative to its own baseline, even though its baseline rate is lower. Response rate and resistance to change are separate.

  2. Question 2Ravi's attention-maintained yelling at home was reduced with DRA: his parents attend to 'Excuse me' in the same family room where yelling occurred. During a busy week they stop responding to 'Excuse me,' and yelling returns at higher levels than before treatment. What best explains this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. When reinforcement for the alternative stopped, the previously reinforced problem behavior returned, which is resurgence. Momentum theory adds that the extra reinforcement delivered in the family room during DRA may have made yelling more resistant to change. Spontaneous recovery involves a return after a break during extinction, not the loss of alternative reinforcement.

  3. Question 3Before asking Lena to start a writing task she usually refuses, her teacher asks her to give a high five, pass a pencil and say her name, praising each response. This procedure is:
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Several easy requests that Lena almost always follows are delivered and reinforced just before the low-probability request. That is the high-p request sequence, which applied researchers often call a behavioral momentum procedure. The praise is contingent on compliance, so it is not noncontingent reinforcement.

  4. Question 4According to behavioral momentum theory, which variable mainly determines how resistant a behavior is to disruption?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Nevin's account separates response rate, which depends on the response-reinforcer contingency, from resistance to change, which depends on the stimulus-reinforcer relation. A behavior can occur at a low rate yet be very persistent if its context is rich in reinforcement.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.