cumulative

H.3 Choosing a socially valid replacement behavior

What the task asks: When a behavior is targeted for reduction, select an alternative behavior to build that serves the same function and is acceptable and effective in the client's world.

Selecting and Implementing Interventions4 min read5 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Reducing a problem behavior leaves a gap. The behavior was getting the person something: attention, a break, an item or sensory stimulation. If nothing takes its place, the need is still there, and the problem behavior, or a new one, is likely to return.

A replacement behavior is an alternative the team teaches or strengthens so the person can meet the same need in a better way. The best replacement is functionally equivalent, socially valid and efficient: it produces the same reinforcer, it fits the setting, and it works at least as well as the problem behavior did.

Breaking it down

Functional equivalence

The replacement must produce the same reinforcer as the problem behavior. If screaming is maintained by escape from tasks, a replacement that produces attention will not compete with it. Functional communication training (FCT) (Carr & Durand, 1985) is the most common example: the person learns a communicative response, such as a word, sign, card or device message, that produces the reinforcer that used to follow the problem behavior. FCT is a form of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA) (see G.2), usually combined with extinction of the problem behavior.

Writing task Tears the worksheet Hands over a break card No longer ends the task (extinction) Every time at first Break from writing Same reinforcer, low effort, quick to deliver
Aiden's two routes to the same reinforcer. FCT makes the break card the route that works, every time at first, while tearing the worksheet no longer ends the task. The card produces the same break the tearing used to, which is what makes it functionally equivalent.

For automatically maintained behavior, look for alternatives that produce similar sensory consequences, such as toys or activities matched to the stimulation.

Social validity

The replacement should be acceptable to the client and the people around them, suited to the person’s age and setting, and understood by others. A picture card that only the therapist recognizes will not work at the grocery store. A teenager may prefer a discreet hand signal to a communication board. Ask: will people in the client’s daily life recognize this response and reinforce it?

Efficiency

Problem behavior often works quickly and reliably, so the replacement has to compete. Response efficiency depends on:

  • Response effort: how much physical or cognitive work the response takes. Low effort is better at first. Asking a child who rarely speaks to say a full sentence makes screaming the easier option.
  • Schedule: reinforce the replacement every time at first, then thin gradually (H.5, G.16).
  • Immediacy: the reinforcer should follow the replacement quickly.
  • Quality: the replacement should produce a reinforcer at least as good as the one the problem behavior produced.

Horner and Day (1991) showed that when the alternative took more effort, was reinforced less often or was reinforced after a delay, problem behavior persisted.

Other qualities of a good replacement

  • Already in the repertoire, or easy to teach. A response the person can already make speeds up treatment.
  • Incompatible when possible. A behavior that cannot occur at the same time as the problem behavior (hands in pockets instead of hand flapping) adds a second advantage, as in DRI.
  • Leads somewhere. A break request can later be combined with gradually longer work periods to build tolerance.

A simple planning habit, sometimes called the fair pair rule, is to name a behavior to increase for every behavior targeted for decrease.

Seeing it in practice

Client and functionProblem behaviorReplacementWhy it fits
Aiden, 6: escape from writingTearing worksheetsHanding over a “break” cardSame reinforcer, low effort, and the teacher can honor it
Rania, 15: peer attentionShouting jokes in classAsking to share a joke in the last five minutes of classSame reinforcer, age-appropriate, fits school norms
Mr. Diaz, 40: access to coffeeGrabbing cups from coworkersSigning “coffee” or showing a picture on his phoneUnderstood by coworkers, quick
Ellie, 4: automatic (visual stimulation)Flicking fingers in front of her eyesPlaying with a light-up spinning toySimilar sensory stimulation, socially acceptable

Common mix-ups

  • An alternative is not automatically equivalent. “Sitting nicely” is an alternative to tantrums, but it does not get a child the break the tantrum produced. Match the function first.
  • FCT is not just any communication training. The trained response must produce the specific reinforcer that maintains the problem behavior.
  • Teaching the replacement is not enough. If the problem behavior still pays off as well or better, the person will keep using it (see B.23 on the matching law). Make the replacement richer and the problem behavior less effective.
  • High effort undermines a good replacement. Start with a response the person can make easily, and raise expectations later.

Exam tip: When choosing a replacement behavior, ask in order: does it produce the same reinforcer, will people in the setting accept and reinforce it, and is it easier and faster than the problem behavior?

Quick recap

  • Every behavior targeted for reduction needs a replacement that meets the same need.
  • Functional equivalence comes first: the same reinforcer as the problem behavior.
  • Social validity: acceptable, age-appropriate and understood in the client’s settings.
  • Efficiency: low effort and dense, immediate reinforcement at first, thinned later.
  • FCT is the most common function-based replacement strategy and is a form of DRA.

Further reading

  • Carr, E. G., & Durand, V. M. (1985). Reducing behavior problems through functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(2), 111-126.
  • Horner, R. H., & Day, H. M. (1991). The effects of response efficiency on functionally equivalent competing behaviors. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 24(4), 719-732.

Key terms

Replacement behavior (Alternative behavior)
A desirable behavior taught or strengthened to take the place of a problem behavior, ideally one that produces the same reinforcer with less effort and in a way other people accept.
Functional communication training (FCT)
A form of differential reinforcement of alternative behavior in which a communicative response (a word, sign, picture exchange or device press) produces the reinforcer that maintained the problem behavior, while the problem behavior no longer produces it.
Differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA)
A procedure that reinforces a specified appropriate behavior while withholding reinforcement for the problem behavior. The alternative ideally produces the same reinforcer that maintained the problem behavior and takes less effort.
Response effort
The physical or cognitive work a response requires. Because people tend to choose lower-effort options, making a desired response easier, or an undesired one harder, can change how often each occurs.
Social validity
The extent to which the goals, procedures and outcomes of an intervention are acceptable, important and useful to the people it affects, such as clients, caregivers and supervisees. It is usually measured with surveys, interviews or rating scales.

Check yourself

5 questions on H.3. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A functional analysis shows that Aiden's tantrums are maintained by escape from writing tasks. Which replacement behavior is most appropriate?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A break card produces the same reinforcer as the tantrums, escape from writing, so it can compete with them. Raising a hand for attention is a fine skill, but it produces a different reinforcer and will not replace escape-maintained behavior.

  2. Question 2Mila, 4, grabs toys and hits peers to get them; the behavior is maintained by access to toys. She speaks in single words. The team teaches her to say 'May I have a turn, please?' and honors every request, yet she rarely uses it. What is the most likely problem?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A five-word sentence is far harder for a child who uses single words than grabbing is, so the problem behavior remains the more efficient response. Starting with a low-effort request, such as 'turn,' and building up later is more likely to work. The request does produce the same reinforcer.

  3. Question 3Which example best illustrates functional communication training?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. FCT teaches a communicative response that produces the same reinforcer that maintained the problem behavior. Labeling feelings is communication, but it is not tied to the maintaining reinforcer. Ignoring screaming alone is extinction, not FCT.

  4. Question 4Rania, 15, shouts jokes during class, and the behavior is maintained by peer attention. Which replacement is the most socially valid?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Sharing jokes at an agreed time gives Rania peer attention in a way that fits a high school classroom. A picture card asking for attention is functionally related but would stand out and could stigmatize her. Showing jokes to a therapist produces adult attention, not peer attention.

  5. Question 5A replacement behavior is taught and reinforced every time it occurs, but the problem behavior also still produces the same reinforcer most of the time. Based on the matching law, what is most likely?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. The matching law predicts that responding is distributed across options in proportion to the reinforcement each produces. While the problem behavior still pays off often, it will continue. That is why FCT is usually paired with extinction or reduced reinforcement for the problem behavior.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.