cumulative

G.19 Procedures that promote emergent relations

What the task asks: Design teaching that produces untrained relations and novel responses, such as equivalence classes, recombined skills and naming, and test whether those relations actually emerged.

Behavior-Change Procedures6 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Teaching every skill directly would take forever. Procedures for emergent relations teach a small set of relations and produce others that were never taught. Teach a learner that the spoken word “seven” goes with the numeral 7, and that the numeral 7 goes with a picture of seven dots, and the learner may match the dots to the spoken word with no further teaching. That untaught performance is the payoff.

B.21 covers the processes, including stimulus equivalence and its properties. This guide covers the procedures: how to arrange teaching so new relations are likely to emerge, and how to test that they did.

Breaking it down

Equivalence-based instruction

Equivalence-based instruction (EBI) uses match-to-sample training to teach a few conditional discriminations (G.6) among stimuli, then tests for the relations that were not trained. Stimuli show stimulus equivalence when tests show reflexivity (A matches A), symmetry (after A-B training, B-A) and transitivity (after A-B and B-C training, A-C), including combined tests such as C-A.

trained trained A "seven" B 7 C symmetry symmetry transitivity: A to C equivalence: C to A
The "seven" example from above. Two relations are trained (solid arrows); four more are tested without feedback (dashed): two symmetry relations, transitivity from A to C, and the combined equivalence test from C to A.

A typical EBI program:

  1. Choose stimulus sets, such as A (spoken state names), B (state outlines) and C (printed capital cities).
  2. Train the baseline relations with feedback until mastery.
  3. Thin reinforcement on baseline trials so the learner is used to trials without feedback.
  4. Test the untrained relations without feedback, mixed with baseline trials.
  5. If tests fail, check that the baseline still holds, retrain it, or change the training structure.

Training structures

The training structure is the arrangement of the trained relations. In each pair below, the first stimulus is the sample and the second is the comparison.

StructureTrained relationsWhat stays the same
Linear seriesA-B, B-C, C-DNothing: each set links to the next
One-to-many (sample-as-node)A-B, A-C, A-DOne set is the sample in every relation
Many-to-one (comparison-as-node)B-A, C-A, D-AOne set is the comparison in every relation
Linear series A-B, B-C, C-D A B C D One-to-many A-B, A-C, A-D A B C D Many-to-one B-A, C-A, D-A B C D A
The three structures as diagrams, each arrow running from sample to comparison. Linear series is a chain; in the other two, one set (highlighted) is the node every trained relation passes through.

Many studies find that one-to-many and many-to-one produce equivalence more readily than linear series, though results vary with learners and procedures. With four stimulus sets, training 3 relations can produce 9 untrained ones, which is where the efficiency comes from.

Testing for emergence

Testing is what makes a relation emergent. Untrained relations must be presented without reinforcement or feedback, or the test becomes training. After one-to-many training (A-B, A-C), typical tests are symmetry (B-A, C-A) and equivalence (B-C, C-B). Where relevant, also test whether the relations carry over to new response types, such as saying the capital when shown the state outline.

Matrix training and recombinative generalization

Matrix training arranges two or more sets of components on a grid, such as animals on one axis and actions on the other. Teaching only some combinations, often along the diagonal, can produce recombinative generalization: correct responding to untaught combinations of components learned in other combinations.

Animaljumpingsleepingeating
horsetaughtprobeprobe
pigprobetaughtprobe
duckprobeprobetaught

Three combinations are taught and six are tested. Diagonal teaching alone may not produce recombination, especially when the learner does not yet know the separate components. If so, teach overlapping combinations that share components. Matrix training is used for language (noun-verb, adjective-object), play actions, following directions, and early reading and spelling.

Multiple exemplar instruction and naming

Multiple exemplar instruction (MEI) teaches with many examples, or rotates one stimulus across several response types: pointing to it (listener), naming it (tact) and matching it. Rotating listener and speaker responses this way, across many stimulus sets, can establish a generalized repertoire in which learning one response type produces the other without direct teaching.

Bidirectional naming, often just called naming, is that repertoire. After hearing an object’s name, or after being taught one response to it, the learner can both select the object when the name is said and say the name when the object is shown. Teams check for it with probes: new stimuli are named for the learner without reinforcement, then both listener and tact responses are tested.

Seeing it in practice

  • University. Dr. Mensah’s course software teaches students to match brain-region names to diagrams and diagrams to functions, then tests without feedback whether they can match names to functions.
  • Clinic. Fatima, 5, learns “horse jumping,” “pig sleeping” and “duck eating” with toy figures. On probes she correctly acts out “pig jumping” and “duck sleeping,” which were never taught.
  • School. A teacher uses a one-to-many structure: spoken coin names (A) to coins (B) and spoken coin names to printed values (C). The student then matches coins to values without being taught.
  • Home. A parent rotates “Show me the giraffe,” “What’s this?” and “Find the same” with each new animal. After several sets, Leo names animals he has only been taught to point to.

Common mix-ups

  • Training vs. testing. A relation is emergent only if it was never reinforced. Giving feedback on test trials turns the test into training.
  • Sample vs. comparison. In A-B training, A is the sample presented first, and the B stimuli are the comparisons the learner chooses from.
  • One-to-many vs. many-to-one. One-to-many keeps the sample set constant (sample-as-node). Many-to-one keeps the comparison set constant (comparison-as-node).
  • Recombinative generalization vs. equivalence. Recombination produces new combinations of known parts. Equivalence produces new relations among stimuli in a class.
  • MEI vs. sufficient exemplars. Both use many examples (G.15). MEI for naming also rotates the learner across response types.

Exam tip: On a training-structure question, find what stays the same. One sample set in every trained relation means one-to-many. One comparison set in every relation means many-to-one. Each set linked only to the next means linear series.

Quick recap

  • EBI teaches a few conditional discriminations and tests for symmetry, transitivity and equivalence without feedback.
  • Linear series, one-to-many and many-to-one are the three training structures, and linear series tends to be the least effective.
  • Matrix training teaches a subset of combinations and tests the rest for recombinative generalization.
  • MEI rotates listener and speaker responses to build bidirectional naming.
  • Emergent relations make teaching efficient and generative.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapters 19 and 20.
  • Sidman, M. (1994). Equivalence relations and behavior: A research story. Authors Cooperative.

Key terms

Stimulus equivalence
The emergence of untaught relations among stimuli after some relations have been taught, shown by reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity. Stimuli that pass these tests form an equivalence class and are interchangeable even when they share no physical features.
Emergent relation (Derived relation)
A relation between stimuli, or between stimuli and responses, that appears without direct teaching or reinforcement as a result of other relations that were taught.
Equivalence-based instruction (EBI)
Teaching that trains a small number of conditional discriminations, usually with matching-to-sample, and then tests without feedback for the untrained relations among the stimuli, so that more relations are learned than were taught.
Training structure
The arrangement of the relations taught in equivalence-based instruction. In a linear series each stimulus set is linked to the next (A-B, B-C); in one-to-many, or sample-as-node, one set is the sample for every other set (A-B, A-C); in many-to-one, or comparison-as-node, every other set is matched to one comparison set (B-A, C-A).
Matrix training
Arranging two or more sets of components, such as objects and actions, on a grid, teaching only some of the combinations, and then testing the untaught combinations for recombinative generalization.
Recombinative generalization
The production of new, correct combinations of components from responses that were taught separately. Matrix training arranges teaching to promote it.
Multiple exemplar training (Multiple exemplar instruction, MEI, Teaching sufficient exemplars)
Teaching with several varied examples of the stimuli, settings or response forms involved in a skill, or rotating one stimulus across different response types, so that responding extends to examples that were never taught.
Naming (Bidirectional naming, BiN)
A two-way relation between speaker and listener behavior. After learning to tact an object, a person can also select it as a listener when hearing its name, and the reverse, without separate teaching.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.19. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1A teacher trains students to match each country's name (A) to its flag (B), and each country's name (A) to its capital city (C). Which training structure is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. The same stimulus set, country names, is the sample in both trained relations, with flags and capitals as comparisons, which is one-to-many. Many-to-one would use flags and capitals as samples and names as the shared comparison. A linear series would link A to B and then B to C.

  2. Question 2Students have mastered matching country names to flags (A-B) and country names to capitals (A-C). Which trial type best tests for equivalence?
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Matching flags to capitals (B-C) was never trained and requires combining symmetry and transitivity, so it tests equivalence, and running it without feedback keeps it a test. Flags to names (B-A) tests only symmetry, and identity matching tests reflexivity. Name-to-flag trials with praise repeat a trained relation.

  3. Question 3A speech-language pathologist and a BCBA teach a learner to label 'red car,' 'blue ball' and 'green cup' with toys. Without further teaching, the learner correctly labels a blue car and a green ball. What has the team demonstrated?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Correct, untaught combinations of components (colors and objects) that were learned in other combinations show recombinative generalization, the goal of matrix training. Equivalence class formation concerns untrained relations among stimuli in a class, such as matching a picture to a printed word, not new combinations of parts.

  4. Question 4With each new set of animal pictures, a parent rotates 'Point to the zebra,' 'What is this?' and matching tasks. After several sets, when Ibrahim is taught only to point to a new animal on hearing its name, he can also name it when shown. What is the procedure designed to establish?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Rotating listener and speaker responses across many stimulus sets is multiple exemplar instruction, and the result described, a tact emerging from listener training alone, is naming. One-to-many training arranges match-to-sample relations among stimulus sets; it does not rotate the learner across response types.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.