cumulative

G.3 Time-based schedules and noncontingent reinforcement

What the task asks: Design and evaluate schedules that deliver reinforcers by the clock instead of after a response, including noncontingent reinforcement used to reduce problem behavior.

Behavior-Change Procedures5 min read4 practice questionsOfficial outline (opens in a new tab)

The big idea

Most schedules in B.9 deliver a reinforcer after a response. A time-based schedule delivers it after a period of time passes, whatever the person is doing. On a fixed-time (FT) schedule the period is the same every time (every 2 minutes). On a variable-time (VT) schedule it varies around an average (every 2 minutes on average).

The main clinical use is noncontingent reinforcement (NCR): delivering the reinforcer that maintains a problem behavior, or a competing one, on a time-based schedule. The person gets plenty of what they were working for, so the problem behavior has less reason to occur, and it no longer produces the reinforcer on its own.

Breaking it down

Time-based versus interval schedules

Do not confuse FT with fixed-interval (FI). On FI 2 min, the first response after 2 minutes produces the reinforcer: a response is required. On FT 2 min, the reinforcer arrives at 2 minutes with no response required. The key word is response-independent.

Shout or other response Attention or other reinforcer Baseline shouts get attention NCR, FT 2 min by the clock just after a shout FI 2 min needs a response 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 min
Three ways attention can be scheduled across six minutes of Eli's group time. In baseline every shout gets attention. On FT 2 min, attention arrives at 2, 4 and 6 minutes whatever Eli is doing, and one delivery happens to land just after a shout. On FI 2 min, nothing arrives until the first response after the interval.

How NCR reduces behavior

Two mechanisms are usually involved.

  1. An abolishing effect. Frequent free access to attention reduces the value of attention for a while, so behavior that has produced attention becomes less likely (see B.16).
  2. A broken contingency. If attention arrives on a schedule and problem behavior no longer produces extra attention, the response-reinforcer relation weakens, much as in extinction.

NCR is usually combined with extinction of the problem behavior, which makes the second mechanism complete.

Choosing the stimulus

  • Function-based NCR uses the reinforcer identified in a functional analysis (see F.6): attention for attention-maintained behavior, breaks for escape-maintained behavior (often called noncontingent escape).
  • NCR with an alternative stimulus uses a different item that competes with the behavior. This is common for automatically reinforced behavior, where the sensory consequence cannot be delivered or withheld. A child who mouths objects might have free access to a chew toy.

Starting dense, then thinning

Begin with a schedule dense enough that problem behavior drops quickly. Some teams start with continuous access; others set the first interval at or below the average time between problem behaviors in baseline. Then use schedule thinning: lengthen the interval in small steps (for example 10 s, 20 s, 40 s, 1 min, 2 min) while behavior stays low, and step back if it rises. Aim for a final schedule that caregivers and teachers can keep up in daily life.

The risk of adventitious reinforcement

Because delivery does not depend on behavior, the reinforcer will sometimes arrive just after a problem behavior. That adventitious (accidental) reinforcement can maintain the very behavior you are trying to reduce, or strengthen some unrelated behavior by chance, much as Skinner’s pigeons developed “superstitious” turning and head-bobbing on a fixed-time food schedule. The risk is highest when schedules are lean and problem behavior is frequent. Some teams add a short rule that the reinforcer is not delivered within a few seconds of a problem behavior. That rule makes the procedure partly contingent, so it is now closer to a DRO (see G.2).

Strengths and limits

NCR is simple to run, does not require the learner to learn a new response, and often produces fewer extinction bursts than extinction alone. Its limits: it teaches no replacement behavior, its abolishing effect can lower motivation for appropriate behavior (a child flooded with attention has little reason to ask for it), and gains can fade if the schedule is thinned too fast. Combining NCR with FCT or DRA addresses the first two.

Time-based schedules as a research control

Fixed-time schedules also serve as a control condition in research. If behavior drops when the same reinforcers are delivered without regard to responding, the contingency, not the reinforcer alone, was responsible for the earlier increase.

Seeing it in practice

LearnerFunctionNCR plan
Eli, 6, shouts during groupAttentionA brief comment from the teacher every 2 minutes (FT 2 min); shouts get no response; thin toward FT 5 min
Hana, 15, tears her worksheetEscapeA 30-second break on a VT 3-min schedule; tearing no longer ends the task; thin toward VT 6 min
Omar, 30, mouths objectsAutomaticFree access to a chew tube, plus scheduled offers of a crunchy snack

For Eli, staff graph shouting every session. When it stays near zero for three sessions, the interval lengthens. When it climbs, they return to the last step that worked.

05101520BaselineFT 2 minFT 3 minFT 5 minFT 3 minFT 4 minFT 5 min246810121416182022SessionsShouts per session
Thinning Eli's NCR schedule from FT 2 min. Each step waits for three sessions near zero. The jump to FT 5 min was too big, so the team stepped back to FT 3 min and reached FT 5 min in a smaller step.

Common mix-ups

  • NCR is not a reward for good behavior. It is delivered on the clock, whatever the person is doing.
  • FT is not FI. One requires no response; the other requires a response after the interval.
  • A contingent delay turns NCR toward DRO. If problem behavior postpones or resets delivery, you have added a contingency.
  • NCR is not extinction. The two are often combined, but NCR is defined by time-based delivery.

Exam tip: If a stem says reinforcers are delivered “every X minutes regardless of behavior,” the answer is a time-based schedule (FT or VT) or NCR. If it says reinforcers come “only if the behavior has not occurred,” the answer is DRO.

Quick recap

  • FT and VT schedules deliver reinforcers by the clock with no response required.
  • NCR reduces problem behavior through an abolishing effect and a broken contingency, usually with extinction.
  • Start dense, thin gradually and set a practical final schedule.
  • Watch for adventitious reinforcement of problem behavior, especially on lean schedules.
  • NCR does not teach a replacement, so pair it with FCT or DRA.

Further reading

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), chapter 26.
  • Vollmer, T. R., Iwata, B. A., Zarcone, J. R., Smith, R. G., & Mazaleski, J. L. (1993). The role of attention in the treatment of attention-maintained self-injurious behavior: Noncontingent reinforcement and differential reinforcement of other behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 26(1), 9-21.
  • Skinner, B. F. (1948). ‘Superstition’ in the pigeon. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 38(2), 168-172.

Key terms

Noncontingent reinforcement (NCR)
Delivery of a stimulus with known reinforcing value on a fixed-time or variable-time schedule, independent of behavior. Used to reduce problem behavior, it lowers the value of the maintaining reinforcer and breaks that reinforcer's link to the problem behavior.
Fixed-time schedule (FT schedule)
A time-based schedule that delivers a reinforcer each time a constant amount of time has passed, with no response required. Unlike a fixed-interval schedule, it does not wait for a response.
Variable-time schedule (VT schedule)
A time-based schedule that delivers a reinforcer after amounts of time that vary around an average, with no response required.
Adventitious reinforcement (Accidental reinforcement)
Strengthening of a behavior that happens to occur just before a reinforcer, even though the reinforcer did not depend on it. It is a risk with time-based schedules, where it can maintain problem behavior or produce so-called superstitious behavior.
Schedule thinning
Gradually reducing how often reinforcement is delivered, by raising the response requirement, lengthening the interval or adding delays, while keeping behavior at the desired level. It makes a procedure practical to sustain and the behavior more durable.

Check yourself

4 questions on G.3. Choose an answer to see whether you're right and why.

  1. Question 1Every 3 minutes, a timer prompts staff to give Eli a few seconds of attention, whether he is working, chatting or shouting at that moment. Shouting no longer produces any extra attention. Which procedure is this?
    Show the answer

    Answer: A. Attention arrives every 3 minutes regardless of behavior, which is a fixed-time schedule used as NCR, with shouting on extinction. DRO would deliver attention only if shouting had not occurred. A fixed-interval schedule would require a response after 3 minutes. It is not a variable-time schedule either, because the interval here never varies.

  2. Question 2Because staff are busy, a team starts NCR attention for Lucia's head-hitting at FT 5 min. In baseline, head-hitting occurred about once a minute. After a week, head-hitting has not decreased, and staff notice attention often arrives right after a hit. What is the most likely explanation and fix?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. With frequent head-hitting and a lean schedule, attention often follows hits by chance, which can keep head-hitting going. A dense starting schedule, near or below the baseline time between hits, gives the abolishing effect a chance to work and makes chance pairings less likely. Satiation is what NCR aims for, so it would reduce the behavior, not maintain it.

  3. Question 3Which arrangement is a fixed-time schedule?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. A fixed-time schedule delivers the reinforcer after a set time with no response required. The first hand-raise after 10 minutes is a fixed-interval schedule, every tenth hand-raise is fixed-ratio, and a sticker for no call-outs is DRO.

  4. Question 4NCR attention reduced Ibrahim's classroom disruption to near zero, but his teacher notices he has stopped asking for help with his work. What is the most likely reason, and what should the team add?
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Dense NCR works partly through an abolishing effect, and that effect can also lower motivation for appropriate ways of getting attention, such as asking for help. Teaching a communicative alternative and thinning NCR restores a reason to ask. Nothing in the scenario punished asking; the change came from the reduced value of attention.

Adds a step to your study record. Saved in this browser only.

Type to search all 104 guides and the glossary.