/ Single-Case Design Graphs

Overview › Design guide › Changing criterion

Design guide

Changing criterion design

Change a performance criterion in steps. If behavior moves to each new criterion when it changes, and not before, the criterion is controlling it.

You will be able to

  • Explain how each criterion change is a demonstration, and why subphase lengths and step sizes should vary.
  • Tell behavior that tracks the criterion from a jump to the final level or a steady drift.
  • Decide whether changing criterion graphs show experimental control, and say why when they don't, reaching 8 of your last 10 in the practice.
Question it answersDoes behavior change in steps that match the criterion?
Use it whenThe goal can be reached gradually, and the intervention ties reinforcement to meeting a criterion.
Avoid it whenThe behavior should change all at once, or it doesn't have a scale that can be stepped.

How it shows control

Each new criterion predicts a new level of behavior. When behavior shifts to match each criterion promptly, and stays near it until the next change, each step is a demonstration. Three things make the design stronger: subphases of different lengths, steps of different sizes, and a temporary step back down to a lower criterion. These show that the shifts follow the criterion, not the passage of time. The example below uses all three. With equal steps at equal intervals, a steady climb could look like control.

The logic of this design in more depth, its judgment calls and exceptions, and a knowledge check: Visual analysis Lesson 3, Part F.

Minimum standards

What experimental control looks like

Experimental control Changing criterion graph of minutes of exercise. Baseline is 7 to 10 minutes. In each subphase, data stay within 1 minute of the criterion of 12, 20, 16, 26, and 30 minutes, including the temporary return to 16 minutes. The subphases last 3, 5, 3, 4, and 3 sessions.
Behavior tracks every step, including the step back down. Exercise moves to each criterion (the dashed lines) as soon as it changes and levels off near it until the next change. The subphases differ in length, the steps differ in size, and when the criterion drops from 20 to 16 minutes, behavior drops with it. Time or practice alone can't explain that pattern.

What it doesn't look like

Didn't follow the steps Changing criterion graph of minutes of exercise. Baseline is 7 to 10 minutes. In the first subphase, with a 12-minute criterion, behavior jumps to 28 to 31 minutes, and it stays between 28 and 32 minutes through every later criterion, including 16 minutes.
An immediate jump to the final level. Behavior improved, but not in step with the criterion, and it didn't drop when the criterion was lowered to 16 minutes. The criterion isn't shown to control it.
Steady drift Changing criterion graph where minutes of exercise rise steadily, about 1.5 minutes per session, from 11 to 37 minutes across subphases with criteria of 12, 20, 16, 26, and 30 minutes. Behavior keeps rising to 23 to 26 minutes when the criterion drops to 16, and ends at 34 to 37 minutes, above the final 30-minute criterion.
Rising regardless of the criterion. Behavior climbs about 1.5 minutes a session within every subphase instead of leveling off near each criterion. It reaches the 20-minute criterion only in the last two sessions of that subphase, keeps rising to 23 to 26 minutes after the criterion drops to 16, and overshoots the final 30-minute criterion. The changes follow the passage of time, not the criterion.

Practice

Decide whether each graph shows experimental control. When it doesn't, also choose why. An item counts only when both answers are right.

Graph it